x
Brock Purdy is the NFL's Most Underrated QB
IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Brock Purdy is the NFL’s Most Underrated QB

Every NFL season has the same quarterback debate, and Brock Purdy always gets the same answer: nice player, great system. The facts haven’t fit that story for a while. Purdy was the final selection of the 2022 NFL Draft, the “Mr. Irrelevant” pick, and that label has followed him further than it should. In Week 6 against Washington he officially passed 1,500 career attempts, the minimum needed to qualify for the all-time leaderboards.

That made him No. 1 all time in passer rating (105.4), adjusted yards per attempt (8.7) and adjusted net yards per attempt (7.9), among other statistics. The previous passer rating record belonged to Lamar Jackson at 102.7, and the names just below Purdy include Aaron Rodgers, Joe Burrow, Patrick Mahomes, Russell Wilson, Drew Brees, Tom Brady and Peyton Manning. When a seventh-round pick holds the career efficiency record over that list, “system quarterback” stops working as an explanation.

The system argument also ignores what happens when Purdy’s support is thin, as it has been this year. After the Week 10 win in Dallas, the San Francisco Standard noted that the 49ers’ offense isn’t at full strength, but it was at full force in a 46-40 win over the Cowboys. Purdy completed 22 of 28 passes for a career-high 389 yards and three touchdowns. He was sacked five times, threw no interceptions and finished with a 154.5 passer rating. Much of that came off schedule: plenty of those yards came early, when coverage broke down while he scrambled. Kyle Shanahan builds a great scheme, but schemes don’t extend broken plays. Even FOX Sports’ writeup, while crediting Shanahan, said that no matter who the 49ers put out at receiver, the offense keeps rolling, and Purdy deserves a lot of the credit.

This isn’t a hot streak, either. Through the first three games of 2026, no quarterback had posted a better ESPN QBR than Purdy since the stat was introduced in 2006. The 49ers are now an NFC-best 8-1. This is also the player who led San Francisco to the Super Bowl in 2023, led the league in passer rating and made the Pro Bowl, then finished fourth in that year’s MVP voting. Even his own coach doesn’t think the numbers capture him. Shanahan called passer rating an “overrated stat” and praised Purdy for doing things that help the team but hurt his rating, like throwing the ball away to avoid a sack. He has the best rating ever partly while giving some of it up on purpose. Brock Purdy +3

So why is he still underrated? Purdy doesn’t fit what people expect a star quarterback to look like. He’s not a top-10 pick, he doesn’t have a cannon arm, and he’s not a highlight-reel athlete, so his success keeps getting credited to someone else: Shanahan, Christian McCaffrey, or whichever receiver is healthy. The way to measure a quarterback is to ask how much better his offense is with him than without him, and Purdy’s career answers that every week. That case gets a big national stage this Sunday, when the 49ers (8-1) play the Minnesota Vikings (7-2) in Mexico City with the top spot in the NFC on the line. If he keeps playing like this, the debate shouldn’t be about whether Purdy is good enough. It should be about why it took so long to admit he’s one of the best. sfstandard

This article first appeared on TWSN and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!