Chicago Bears’ Caleb Williams fully disrespected in latest quarterback rankings

Having Williams at No. 21 makes complete sense. He has plenty of potential, but his rookie season didn’t paint him as one of the top quarterbacks in the league. However, McKenna’s entire argument against Williams goes out the window when you see JJ McCarthy’s placement.

The Minnesota Vikings quarterback, who is essentially entering his rookie season, ranked No. 12.

“You could put just about anyone in the Vikings’ QB slot, and I’d get excited about him,” McKenna wrote. “But McCarthy was a top-10 pick in what’s shaping up to be an incredible QB class. This year, McCarthy might look like 2023 Brock Purdy — an athletic point guard with an idyllic supporting cast.”

McCarthy has yet to play an down of NFL football after suffering a season-ending meniscus injury. He was the No. 10 overall pick in 2024 and oozes potential. But without any experience, how can anyone be for certain how he will perform when the lights are the brightest?

McCarthy has a strong-minded offense head coach in Kevin O’Connell and an explosive offensive. But isn’t Williams in the same situation with Ben Johnson and Chicago’s cast of pass catchers? Plus, Williams understands the speed required at the NFL level.

The Vikings and Bears will face off on Monday Night Football in Week 1, so the debate will be settled then. If nothing else, but Williams and McCarthy are entering their sophomore campaigns with plenty of expectations on their shoulders.

Chicago Bears believe in Caleb Williams

The Bears, nor Johnson will pay little mind to preseason rankings, especially before training camp takes place. But they at least know their entire season hinges on their quarterback finding his form.

Luckily for him, Johnson has a clear track record of developing former No. 1 overall picks. In Johnson’s final season with the Detroit Lions, quarterback Jared Goff finished second in passing yards (4,629) and fourth in touchdown passes (37). The Lions as a whole ranked second in total offense, averaging 409.5 yards per game.

To help aid this offensive revival, the Bears completely revamped their offensive line. They traded for guards Joe Thuney and Jonah Jackson before signing Drew Dalman. After leading the league by allowing 68 sacks in 2024, Chicago was aggressive in ensuring that doesn’t happen again in 2025.

Furthermore, the team has bulked out their receiving room. DJ Moore, Rome Odunze and Cole Kmet was already a strong core. But now rookies Colston Loveland and Luther Burden are joining the fray. If Williams plays to Johnson’s expectations, it’ll be difficult for any defense to stop all of Chicago’s receiving options.

But if the quarterback struggles, the Bears will be answering the same questions in 2026. And Williams won’t climb up the QB rankings much.