Chiefs' Backup Options Could Consist of a Familiar Name

“If that is the case,” wrote ESPN’s Seth Walder on Wednesday, “they'd want a reliable backup who can ideally win a few games while Mahomes finishes up his recovery. I believe Mariota fits the bill.

“The 32-year-old stood in for Jayden Daniels for eight starts in Washington last season and was capable, with a 50.2 QBR. He has a long history of being solid, which is essentially what Kansas City needs -- a player who can keep the team afloat in Mahomes’ absence but is willing to be a backup and won't be overly expensive.”

Last season at Arrowhead

One of Mariota’s eight starts, a 28-7 loss at Kansas City in Week 8, wasn’t overly impressive. The quarterback finished 21 of 30 for 213 yards and an 11-yard touchdown pass to Terry McLaurin late in the first half. The Chiefs sacked him twice while linebacker Jack Cochrane and defensive end Mike Danna picked him off.

But Mariota could indeed keep the Chiefs afloat should Mahomes need extra time, whether one week or multiple games, at the start of the season. He also could be a solid offseason addition in running the offense while Mahomes watches from behind the huddle on the practice field.

And winning without Mahomes has been a tall task for the Chiefs. They’re just 2-8 without him, including a forgettable three games to close the 2025 season. Combined with Gardner Minshew and Chris Oladokun, the Chiefs were 0-3 with just one offensive touchdowns and zero games above 170 total yards. The Chiefs also have Jake Haener on their roster.

“I imagine that the Chiefs would want to be cautious with Mahomes,” Walder said, “given his importance to the franchise.”

How about a Week 1 game opposite Colts and Minshew?

Speaking of Minshew, some have forecasted the 2025 Mahomes backup as a likely candidate to re-sign with Kansas City in the offseason. Not Walder. He sees Minshew returning to a familiar playbook not in Kansas City but in Indianapolis.

It’s a fascinating prediction because the Colts still need to re-sign Daniel Jones, also a free agent. Plus, Jones is coming off a season-ending Achilles’ injury, and some have suggested the Chiefs pursue Anthony Richardson – not as a starter but as a Sam Darnold-type stopover on the way to bigger and better things.

Perhaps the NFL schedules a Week 1 matchup featuring Minshew traveling with the Colts for a rematch with the Chiefs, against Mariota?

“If the Colts bring Jones back,” Walder wrote, “they'll need another QB to start the season. And they would want it to be someone they can win with in the short and medium term -- but probably not someone who would cost too much or to whom they would have to commit beyond 2026.

“Enter Minshew. The journeyman had more success playing for Shane Steichen in 2023 than at any other point in his career.”