Colts Add the Perfect Role Player Through Draft

The Indianapolis Colts strayed from their typical athletic mold in this draft class. They selected multiple players with average to below-average athletic scores, and defensive tackle Tim Smith may be the biggest outlier in the group. Despite his athletic limitations, Smith is arguably the most intriguing day-three selection the Colts made this year.

The Colts have had major issues stopping the run in the recent season, particularly when defensive tackle Grover Stewart is subbed off the field. 152 defensive tackles had at least 78 snaps in run defense this past season (according to Pro Football Focus). Stewart and DeForest Buckner ranked among the top 11 in run defense grade, while reserve players Taven Bryan (68th) and Raekwon Davis (137th) both graded out poorly.

This problem isn't even limited to 2024, either. Eric Johnson ranked 146th (out of 146 qualifying players) in run defense back in 2023, while Bryan was 116th (Stewart was number six in run defense grade in comparison). The expectation for a backup defensive tackle shouldn't be superstardom, but the Colts simply need adequate play behind Stewart so he can get some much-needed rest in the middle of games. That is where a player like Smith comes into play.

Smith is coming off of his best collegiate season in 2024, hitting career-highs in tackles, run stops, and overall run defense grade. He flashed outstanding power on film and he is as technically sound as it gets in the run game coming into the NFL. The Colts have needed this type of player for years, and Smith will have every chance in training camp to win a key rotational job.

Power and Explosion in Run Defense

Smith's bread and butter is his ability to defend the run. He showcases excellent power and pop on film, and he does an excellent job of displacing offensive players at the snap. He is well versed in attacking double teams as well and he is a player that almost always wins with leverage at the point of attack. Smith even played across the defensive line at Alabama, so he has the versatility and the experience to be a bit of a chess piece in multiple fronts in the NFL.

Smith's frame offers a lot to like as well, as he could likely stand to get back to his playing weight of 310-315 or so. His low center of gravity along with his massive hands and sturdy build remind me a lot of Star Lotulelei, a former first round pick that played many years in the NFL as a key reserve defensive tackle.