Colts, DE Arden Key Agree To Deal

Key, who will turn 30 in May, is joining the fifth organization of his eight-year career. He began as a Raiders third-round pick in 2018. After spending three seasons with the Raiders, he had one-year stints with the 49ers and Jaguars.

The Titans gave Key some stability when they inked him to a three-year, $21MM accord in 2023. Although Key was the subject of trade rumors before last November’s deadline, he wound up staying in Tennessee for his entire contract. There was mutual interest in a return next season, but Key will head to Indianapolis instead.

While Key combined for just three sacks in 37 games with the Raiders, he has averaged a respectable 5.5 per year dating to 2021. During his most productive season, 2024, the ex-LSU Tiger logged career highs in tackles (42), starts (15) and sacks (6.5). Key also reached 15 QB hits for the third time.

Quad and hip injuries limited Key to 12 games (nine starts) in 2025, during which he recorded 11 QB hits and four sacks. Pro Football Focus ranked Key 71st among 119 qualified edge rushers. Colts defensive end Samson Ebukam checked in two spots higher. Ebukam is now among the Colts’ free agents. More importantly, though, the team could lose the unsigned Kwity Paye to a richer payday elsewhere. Bringing in Key will give the Colts a decent veteran option as they brace for the potential exits of Ebukman and Paye.