
The coverage of the 2025 Dallas Cowboys has been strange. After their convincing win over the Las Vegas Raiders on Monday night, a clear path to the postseason emerged. And still, very few people are taking their playoff chances seriously. The Cowboys are the team we overrate, not underappreciate. This version of the team has a real chance for a shocking late-season run.
The reasons for pessimism are obvious: They’re 4-5-1, they haven’t won back-to-back games all season and their next three games are against the Philadelphia Eagles, Kansas City Chiefs and Detroit Lions. They may have to finish the season winning six of their last seven games to reach the playoffs. The Dallas team we watched most of the season isn’t capable of that. Today’s version of the Cowboys might be.
Galvanized by the loss of a teammate, reinforced by a midseason overhaul on defense and buoyed by the emergence of an explosive offense, Dallas shouldn’t be afraid of competing with anyone. We saw all those elements come together last Monday night in the 33-16 win over the Raiders, the Cowboys’ first game since the tragic death of defensive end Marshawn Kneeland.
There are reasons to believe that today’s Dallas Cowboys are closer to the 2021-23 version of the team that finished 12-5 three years in a row. Each of those seasons, they got hot late. In ’21, the Cowboys won five of their last six. In ’22, they finished 6-2 and in ’23, they closed out the season at 7-2. Last season, injuries and uncertainty around coach Mike McCarthy buried them. Now they’re healthier than they’ve been in a while and buying into new head coach Brian Schottenheimer.
Dallas is a better team on both sides of the ball than the team that lost to Philadelphia 24-21 in Week 1. Start with new addition defensive tackle Quinnen Williams. The former Jet dominated Las Vegas and draws consistent double-teams. The Cowboys also added linebacker Logan Wilson and welcomed linebacker DeMarvion Overshown back to the lineup last week after a lengthy rehab from a knee injury. While they miss departed star Micah Parsons’ pass rush, this version of the defense could pose a different kind of challenge. Now they can put Williams on the field with tackles Kenny Clark and Osa Odighizuwa and challenge teams up the middle. They also appear to have fixed a sub-par linebacker group by adding Overshown and Wilson.
Offensively, the emergence of receiver George Pickens changes everything. He was on the field against the Eagles in the opener, but Dallas was still figuring out his role. Pickens had three catches on four targets against Philadelphia. Since Week 1, he’s averaged 9.8 targets per game and ranks second in the NFL with 908 receiving yards. Pickens paired with CeeDee Lamb presents problems for any defense. The offensive line is finally healthy and should give quarterback Dak Prescott time to find his big receivers even against elite defenses.
ESPN Analytics’ numbers aren’t inspiring – giving the Cowboys a 44% chance against Philadelphia, a 35% chance against Kansas City and a 35% chance against Detroit. Understandable based on what’s happened so far this season. But a closer look at each matchup provides a glimmer of hope...
Prescott is 9-5 in his career against the Eagles and was carving them up in Week 1 before a 65-minute third-quarter rain delay derailed the game. For Philadelphia to beat Prescott twice won’t be easy. The Eagles come in with more drama than Dallas for once. Receiver A.J. Brown has been a distraction most of the season. Now there are reports that the rest of the offense isn’t on the same page with quarterback Jalen Hurts. More importantly, Philly will be without injured right tackle Lane Johnson. The Eagles are 15-23 when Johnson is out of the lineup. And center Cam Jurgens has been ineffective because of a back injury. Even the Tush Push didn’t look right last week in a 16-9 win over the Lions. Philly’s O-line issues could open up opportunities for Williams, Clark and Odighizuwa to cause havoc.
This could be a do-or-die game for both teams and normally the Chiefs are terrifying in that situation. But they are 1-4 on the road this season and their offense has stalled away from Kansas City. The Chiefs average 28.6 points per game at home and just 22.2 ppg on the road. The defense isn’t the same on the road, either. Broncos quarterback Bo Nix was struggling and may have turned his season around last week against K.C. If QBs like Nix and Trevor Lawrence can have efficient games against Kansas City, Prescott should be just fine.
Traveling to Detroit is the toughest challenge in this three-week stretch. But the Lions are a confusing team. They lost at home two weeks ago to the struggling Vikings and their offense has hit a rough patch. There are still lingering questions about whether they can recreate former OC Ben Johnson’s explosive unit even after head coach Dan Campbell took over play-calling duties. Detroit averaged 5.1 yards per carry in a 47-9 win over Dallas last season. If the Cowboys’ rebuilt defense can stop the Lions rushing attack, this will be a very different game.
If Dallas survives the Philly/K.C./Detroit gauntlet, it will be favored in its last four games: vs. Minnesota Vikings, vs. Los Angeles Chargers, at Washington Commanders, at New York Giants. The Chargers are the only team with a winning record they’ll face down the stretch. But L.A. is dealing with several injuries and has struggled against the NFC, dropping games to the Commanders and Giants.
If the Cowboys can win two of three in this upcoming span and then win the last four winnable games, they’ll finish 10-5-1 and most likely reach the playoffs. If they lose two games, it’s not over at 9-6-1. They’ll need teams like the Chicago Bears and San Francisco 49ers, both of whom are 7-3, to collapse down the stretch. The Bears face a difficult schedule and could struggle. The Niners face an easy schedule, but have had trouble staying healthy. Ten wins isn’t guaranteed for either team.
Even if all these scenarios are far-fetched ... even if they lose to the Eagles and this is all pure fantasy, in a normal year there would be enough hope to keep the Dallas hype train rolling. The last few years have taken a toll on America’s Team.... or at least how America views the Cowboys. The idea that owner Jerry Jones ultimately comes out the winner in the Parsons trade is hard to believe.
This Sunday’s game against Philadelphia is a major challenge and could signal the end of any realistic shot. Then again, Jerry has gotten out of sticky situations before. Maybe he strikes oil one more time and the Cowboys earn all the attention they get by actually winning football games.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!