Dolphins’ McDaniel Faces Ultimatum Amid Controversy and Trade Fallout

Originally posted on Athlon Sports | By Andy Hageman | Last updated Jul 9, 2025 6:00 PM ET

Mike McDaniel’s tenure as Miami Dolphins head coach teeters on the edge for 2025. The team’s lack of a playoff win this century fuels fan frustration. Controversial trades have also drawn sharp criticism. Despite fan displeasure, owner Stephen Ross often absent, needs to see McDaniel deliver results to secure his future.

The trade of Jalen Ramsey to the Pittsburgh Steelers sparked outrage. Two-time Super Bowl champion Asante Samuel Sr. slammed the decision, stating, “There’s no leadership in the Dolphins organization. Mike McDaniel is a pushover. Chris Grier, the general manager, has no backbone."

McDaniel’s player-friendly style has won Tua Tagovailoa’s loyalty but not any playoff wins. The Dolphins’ 8-9 record in 2024 and postseason failures intensify scrutiny. ESPN’s Louis Riddick called the team “the very definition of uncertainty going into 2025”.

Ramsey’s departure, despite a $24 million extension, exposed deeper rifts. Samuel Sr. claimed McDaniel and Grier seemingly failed to sell Ramsey on a believable championship vision. The recently traded out Jonnu Smith has also hinted at locker-room dysfunction.

The Dolphins appear to be the definition of uncertainty.

Fan discontent with Ross grows as the playoff winless streak hits 25 years. A deep postseason run is McDaniel’s only path to silence doubters. Can he unify a fractured roster that needs an overhaul?

The pressure is crushing for McDaniel in his fourth season. Analysts suggest a wildcard berth won’t suffice; a divisional round appearance is the minimum to appease fans. Leadership voids and roster upheaval threaten his vision.

Critics question if McDaniel can adapt his innovative offense to a tougher AFC East. The Athletic notes that rival coaches view Miami as “talented but soft”. The clock is ticking for McDaniel to prove he’s the answer.

This article first appeared on Athlon Sports and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads: