x
Don’t Pull the McCord!
IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

In the immediate aftermath of the Kyle McCord strip-sack and touchdown, when it looked for all the world like a winnable game was getting out of reach for the Dolphins, I tweeted that a lot of people would be deleting their McCord hot takes, most of which revolved around the fact that people had already made up their minds that, should the former Syracuse passer sink or swim, it wouldn’t make a difference: he wasn’t Malik Willis, and that’s all they cared about.

The narratives around Willis have become insufferable. People actively want him to fail so they can prove they were right in front of peers they’ve never met on a social media app.

For the record, and to remove any doubt, here’s where I stand on Willis, and where I’ve always stood:

I thought he was a tantalizing free-agent prospect and one that Miami absolutely should have signed. Big, athletic, with a cannon for an arm, he’d come from arguably the most high school-style, one-read-and-go offense in college football and floundered as a third-rounder in Tennessee because of his lack of development. Then, to all intents and purposes, he learned the game in Green Bay in a Mike Shanahan system, sitting behind one of the game’s best in Jordan Love.

My partner just so happens to be a Packers owner, so I see all their games. I also have a number of Green Bay-related friends in the industry who fed back an awful lot of stuff on him. The bottom line? He was beloved, and there was a firm belief from the front office and coaching staff up there that he would be a good NFL starter long-term. When forced into a starting position after Love suffered a second-quarter concussion against the Bears last season, he was 9-of-11 for 121 yards and a touchdown while also rushing for 44 yards.

He started against the Ravens a week later and was spectacular, completing 18-of-21 passes for 288 yards and a touchdown, while also rushing for 60 yards and two touchdowns, and finished the game with a 134.6 passer rating. He pulled off a number of high-tariff throws against a very good defense.

At his age, with his obvious upside, and with the comfort level of Jeff Hafley and Jon-Eric Sullivan, who’d been with him in Green Bay, it was a no-brainer. The team believed he could be a top-10-to-12 QB in this league, but also understood that it might take some time given the new scheme and a raft of young, inexperienced players at key skill positions. That was then exacerbated when star tailback De’Von Achane tore his ACL.

Through eight games this season, he’s struggled at times and certainly hasn’t looked like a top-10-to-12 quarterback. There’s no doubt about that. But he’s certainly not been the only culprit.

However, what I’ve maintained – and what the Dolphins are unequivocal about – is that eight games simply isn’t enough to judge any quarterback on, especially with the paucity of talent around him. People seem to forget that when Josh Allen first entered the league, he struggled through his first two seasons, notably with his passing accuracy, completing just 52.8% of his passes with 10 touchdowns and 12 interceptions in 12 games as a rookie. In Year Two, his completion percentage was still a very modest 58.8%. Bills writer Peter Berkes summed up that time perfectly:

“For the first year-plus, Allen was the worst quarterback in the league by a wide margin. He improved somewhat in year two, but anyone telling you Allen was a no-doubt franchise cornerstone was still basing that on projected growth, not what he was at that moment.”

Now, people will—rightly—argue that Allen was a rookie and Willis had started six games before coming to Miami. But the point remains that, whilst Allen had to rebuild his throwing mechanics, Willis had to learn how to play NFL football.

No matter what you think about Willis, or indeed what I think, I don’t believe you can judge anyone on eight games – and really, it was seven games because he clearly wasn’t healthy against the Lions, on a day when the offensive line forced a guy with what sounds like a sports hernia to run for his life. If he’s not good enough, then so be it. But the argument that we should have let Quinn Ewers play is null and void: Ewers was appalling in camp and just isn’t good enough to play as a starter in this league.

Which leads me nicely to Kyle McCord and his performance yesterday in Indianapolis.

What I liked, first of all, was that Bobby Slowik and Jeff Hafley didn’t change the playbook. They didn’t do what Baltimore did with poor Joe Fagnano and turn him into a de facto competition winner at QB.

There was some solid stuff in there. There was one very good throw, and an ability to feel pressure and work the pocket. He also helped his offensive line by not drifting from the midline. But his lack of zip was an issue at times, as was his accuracy. Not that he was miles off too much, just that when you needed to be pinpoint, the inconsistency showed a little. And although I was pleasantly surprised by how readily he found the out button underneath when he had to – something I’ve been critical of Willis about – there were also some poor misses where he didn’t work his progressions, or the ball was just too slow to come off his hand.

That, coupled with his lack of zip, meant Miami couldn’t move the ball when they had the chance to. He also got very lucky with a small handful of passes that on another day would have been picked.

On the game’s second drive, he eschewed a running back leak to Gordon and tried to force the ball to Kevin Coleman on a 10-yard dig from a levels concept, and it was almost picked off by both CJ Allen and Cam Bynum. He had a clean pocket, and had he waited a beat longer, McCord had Malik Washington flashing wide open underneath. On third down, he had Coleman again at the sticks, but the ball came out a bit late and lacked the zip to fit it in, forcing a field-goal attempt—which was missed.

On the next drive, he threw a good ball to Malik that was incomplete only because of a pass-interference call on Sauce Gardner. He then eschewed a high-tariff throw to Caleb Douglas for a touchdown on an in-breaker, where the LB breaks off at around the seven, leaving the rookie one-on-one against the safety. His leverage and the break at the stem meant he was in perfect position. McCord looked at him but for some reason didn’t pull the trigger, opting for the checkdown.

That was a miss.

The drive ended with an off-target throw to Dulcich on fourth-and-two that he really should have completed, especially with the defender falling down. The fact that he doesn’t even give his TE a chance is an issue because that wasn’t a difficult throw. So he missed two clear touchdown throws on the same drive, which was a shame.

The second half started badly, obviously, and his inexplicable kick back towards the end zone was the killer. I think a part of the blame for the play, however, lies with Caleb Douglas, who sees Justin Walley blitz but doesn’t cut off his route, and instead runs a five-yard out. McCord wants to throw to him, but pulls it down because the rookie has his back to the play. The outside corner is side-saddling, and any off-target ball to Douglas could have been a pick-six.

On the next possession, Malik makes the great one-handed catch, but that was an incredibly dangerous throw on the run into an area with multiple Colts defenders that Hunter Wohler should have picked off. On third-and-11, he was late on a ball to Coleman, albeit with Arden Key in the throwing lane. But again, if he comes back side, he has Malik wide open on a comeback at the 24.

I did like his late-third-quarter roll-out, where he was heading to the sideline and chucked it away at the last minute, saving a two-yard loss. That was a small thing, but smart football.

His best throw of the day by some distance was the third-and-13 deep out to Douglas that was dropped into the bucket perfectly against tight coverage. It was a beautiful pass.

Into the fourth quarter, he had a third-down pass to Douglas that was called for holding against the corner as the rookie worked back to the ball. However, it was an off-target delivery, and the penalty essentially saved him. On the next possession, he misses Douglas again down the field short, after the defender falls down. However, it wouldn’t have counted because there was an illegal shift.

On the next play, he connects with the rookie again across the middle. It’s a sensational catch, but another ball that he probably got away with a little, as Cam Bynum undercuts it and almost picks it. To his credit, McCord throws it high enough, but the ball came out late, forcing the high throw as he saw the Colts defender closing.

Down the stretch, on the final two drives, he really struggled with batted balls: with 1:50 to play, he misses Douglas again, who was wide open on an in-breaker, to put them in position for Zane Gonzalez to miss a game-winner. Then, on third down, he had Malik Washington open early because the receiver sees the blitz and cuts off his route, but McCord doesn’t throw it. There were also some – understandable – communication issues here, given the situation: how mugged up Indy were, and Lou Anarumo’s propensity to blitz in these situations. Finally, on fourth down, he has a second-down-and-three knocked down, essentially ending the game.

As I said, for a backup quarterback, it was promising enough to think that he could become a solid #2, especially with more time in the system and more reps. He could have found himself in a position to win the game if he’d made some quicker reads, but I appreciated how he took what was there at times. He struggled with pressure, especially from the interior, but he generally played on time on early or non-critical downs. Coaches will rightly say he missed too many open receivers he didn’t see, and while he certainly wasn’t helped by drops on occasion, a little more certainty and trust in his arm may have made the difference.

I think, however, it goes without saying that Miami would have won this game with a healthy Malik Willis at quarterback because the Colts aren’t a good team and that isn’t a good defense. But although there were plenty of misses, Kyle McCord didn’t play badly. He certainly wasn’t the reason why they lost. And in a season where the Dolphins are finding pieces in that jigsaw of a rebuild, they may be able to tick back-up QB off the list.

This article first appeared on Dolphins Talk and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!