
The Patriots season changed in a flash Sunday vs. the Lions after Aidan Hutchinson sacked quarterback Drake Maye on New England’s first drive of the game. With Maye knocked out of the game, the Patriots were forced to turn to Tommy DeVito.
Sunday’s Week 10 matchup turned into a disaster for the Patriots from that point on, and now, with news that Maye’s injury is serious and could knock him out for the season, the Patriots are stuck in a bind.
The trade deadline has already passed, so they can’t get help there. If there were a better free-agent option out there, you would think the Patriots would’ve already signed them and had them around the team, learning offensive coordinator Josh McDaniels’ playbook. So they are stuck with Tommy DeVito for now, and that’s a scary proposition for the Patriot faithful.
On Sunday, Fox Sports personality Colin Cowherd tweeted that ¨For all those that believe Drake Maye is overrated—he gets hurt and the Patriots aren’t remotely competitive.¨
Patriots fans better hope that’s not the case and that the team is better prepared than that, because not having a viable operation after one player went down is a serious failure by the New England front office and coaching staff.
Tommy DeVito had a rough go of it against the Lions, to say the least. The 28-year-old, fourth-year, former undrafted free agent was forced into action early in the first quarter after Maye was tackled and his ankle got caught underneath him.
DeVito came into the game with about 9:30 left in the first quarter but never seemed to be able to get his feet underneath him. He completed just 50% of his 24 attempts for 81 yards, 1 TD and 1 interception. The Patriots’ offense was dead in the water with him at the helm.
Also Read: Week 11 waiver wire pickups to help you survive fantasy Bye-pocalypse 2026
But his numbers just scratch the surface of how bad New England’s offense was on Sunday. Across 12 possessions, the Patriots averaged just 5.2 plays per drive and 12.1 yards per drive. They averaged just 4.6 yards per attempt (compared to Detroit’s 9.7), according to PFF.
But it wasn’t all his fault. The Patriots receivers dropped three passes, and star free-agent acquisition A.J. Brown continued his disappointing play this season. The Pats O-line was abysmal, allowing 16 pressures and 5 sacks on the day while doing nothing to get the ground game going. It was an awful showing all around. But this game was lost in the offseason.
The backup quarterback position in the NFL is like the emergency flashlight in your house: you don’t know how important one is until you need it.
Teams like the Commanders and Ravens have been caught without a flashlight when the power’s gone out before, so they make signing a competent backup quarterback a priority. Both of those teams have had to rely on third-string starters this season after their backups were also injured, but Commanders’ backup Marcus Mariota has proved over his 12-year career that he can be an NFL-caliber starter. Ravens backup Tyler Huntley is a 7th-year veteran who has played in at least 5 games in every season since his rookie year.
The Bengals brought back Super Bowl champion Joe Flacco, with 19 years of experience, as their backup. According to NFL insiders, the San Francisco 49ers were reportedly asking for a second-round pick for their backup QB Mac Jones. Drew Lock is 3-0 in Seattle and keeping their season afloat right now.
God bless him, but coming into Week 10, Tommy DeVito had just 14 games of playing experience, starting just 8 of them. He’s 3-5 as a starter and is approaching just 1,500 yards passing in his career. With the Patriots in the thick of the playoff race, losing Drake Maye for the season would absolutely torpedo any hopes of them reaching the playoffs.
The timing of Drake Maye’s injury probably hurts the most. Less than one week removed from the trade deadline, the Patriots can’t reach out to other teams for help.
There are practice-squad options, but the Eagles have already signed perhaps the best available prospect in Joe Milton. However, the Eagles’ season is already pretty much over, so having a guy with no experience learn on the job is a luxury they can afford. With their loss Sunday, the Patriots are officially one game behind the Browns for the final AFC Wild Card playoff spot. So they need someone who can come in and run an NFL offense at a high level, immediately.
DeVito has an opportunity to get his feet wet against a bad Chargers team that still has a decent defense. Then it is a murderer’s row for pretty much the rest of the season as the Patriots face the Bills, Vikings and Chiefs in back-to-back-to-back weeks and the Broncos in Week 17.
DeVito will presumably be backed up by Behren Morton, the seventh-rounder they picked out of Texas Tech in April. But Morton was a healthy scratch from Sunday’s game. He was available as the emergency third quarterback, but listed as inactive.
Unless there is a Philip Rivers-like dark horse veteran out there waiting to suit up, the Patriots are trapped with what they have because they didn’t prepare for Maye to go down, at all.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!