
The New York Giants are leading the NFC East by two games but are still searching for the signature win that will boost them into contender status in the NFC.
For now, Mike Jones of The Athletic deemed the Giants “pretenders” on his list of contenders vs. pretenders that was released Thursday.
The Giants are 5-3-1 and are the odds-on favorite to win the NFC East for the first time since 2011. But they are 0-1 against teams currently over .500 — losing 28-6 at the Los Angeles Rams in Week 2 in a game in which Jaxson Dart sustained a torn MCL and meniscus.
The Giants have exceeded expectations in their first season under John Harbaugh. They already surpassed their 2025 win total and have proven resilient by going 4-2-1 in one-possession games while also dealing with a rash of season-ending injuries to Dart, edge rusher Brian Burns and inside linebacker Tremaine Edmunds.
The Giants shouldn’t apologize for where they are. But Jones, and most of the leaguewide punditry, also doesn’t have to buy in.
“John Harbaugh’s team has definitely exceeded expectations,” Jones wrote. “But the sad state of the NFC East — where injuries plague the Philadelphia Eagles, displays of late-game ineptitude hobble the Washington Commanders and defensive incompetence derails the Dallas Cowboys — has helped the Giants.
“They rank fifth in total defense, but offensive inconsistency with quarterback J.J. McCarthy will doom this team against quality foes.”
Things have broken right for the Giants. The Eagles have been decimated by injuries. The Cowboys defense continues to worse than their offense is good. The Commanders are still horribly coached by Dan Quinn.
But the Giants have an opportunity to prove they are more than the last team standing in a horrible division. They will have huge tests against the Jacksonville Jaguars, San Francisco 49ers and Seattle Seahawks over the next four weeks, plus a home game against the upstart Cleveland Browns on Dec. 20 and a prime-time road tilt in Detroit after Christmas.
It’s fair to wonder how the Giants will fare in those games, considering two of their losses came at home to the Saints and Commanders and they are the only true road team to lose at SoFi Stadium this season — the Chargers are 0-4, and the Rams beat the Chargers 24-9 in their only other home win this year.
But if the Giants can go 2-3 or even 3-2 in those five games, they’ll win over a lot of believers and will lock up the NFC East with ease.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!