The Detroit Lions were unable to steal a win after holding the upper hand in a pair of joint practices in their third preseason game this season. The Miami Dolphins stormed back in the second half and did just enough to keep the Lions at bay, winning 24-17.
Penalties were a big factor in this game, as the two teams combined for 22 penalties including 13 for 86 yards on the Lions.
Here are grades for each position group in the Lions' 24-17 preseason loss to the Miami Dolphins.
Kyle Allen has taken a commanding lead of the backup job through three preseason games, and he was fantastic throughout the first half of Saturday's game. The veteran finished 14-of-17 and threw two touchdowns, one of which was the result of a two-minute drive that he finished 6-for-6 on.
Hendon Hooker sputtered at the start of the second half, as the Lions struggled to move the ball. They got a break after a muffed punt gave them the ball deep in Miami territory, and Hooker was able to finish off his first scoring drive of the preseason.
Hooker led a promising drive at the end of the game with the Lions down seven. However, it came to a crashing halt when Ethan Robinson made a phenomenal play to intercept Hooker's final pass of the night.
The Lions had some difficulties running the ball early in Saturday's game. Craig Reynolds averaged 2.2 yards per carry, but the team got strong performances from Jacob Saylors and Sione Vaki.
Detroit got Vaki onto the field for the first time this preseason, as he had been dealing with a hamstring injury throughout camp. As long as he stays healthy, he'll have plenty of special teams value in addition to what he can do on the ground.
Newcomer Deon Jackson made his Lions debut, carrying the ball four times for 20 yards. Both Saylors and Jackson have caught the coaching staff's eye, and could make things interesting down the stretch.
The Lions' group of young wide receivers continues to steal the show in the preseason. Isaac TeSlaa and Jackson Meeks each scored for the second-straight week, and both players had highlight-reel plays.
TeSlaa is a lock to make the roster, and could be working his way into a bigger role after another solid performance. Meeks, meanwhile, is giving the coaching staff plenty of pause about whether or not he's someone they can afford to leave off the roster.
Dominic Lovett was back in action after suffering an abdominal injury, and he had two catches for 14 yards in addition to a fumble recovery.
The Lions' tight end depth took a hit with the injury to Kenny Yeboah, but the tandem of Shane Zylstra and Zach Horton are still making for an intriguing position battle for the third and presumably final roster spot.
Detroit got a nice look at Horton, as he played 72 percent of the snaps in Saturday's game. He was more involved in the passing attack, with two catches for 15 yards, but also was whistled for holding at one point. Zylstra played less of the snaps and did not get any targets.
The Lions got two tackles back in the mix with Dan Skipper and Jamarco Jones both returning. The overall effort from the offensive line was sloppy, as there was a plethora of whistles throughout the afternoon.
Giovanni Manu, who entered at tackle at halftime, was the guilty party on a holding call that negated Hooker's touchdown run in the third quarter. The team does have some nice offensive line depth, as veterans Netane Muti and Kayode Awosika could help along with Skipper and Jones in the event of an injury.
While it wasn't the cleanest effort, the Lions should walk away from this game feeling solid about the depth they have at their disposal up front.
The defensive line was able to get some pressure on Zach Wilson throughout the first half, but struggled to get to Quinn Ewers after the intermission. Isaac Ukwu had two sacks on the afternoon, but one was negated due to a facemask on linebacker Grant Stuard.
Outside of Ukwu and the occasional contributions from Nate Lynn, the pass-rush was largely stagnant. Lynn had a tackle for loss, though, and Lions' defensive interior did a decent job of stifling the Dolphins' run game.
The Lions have plenty of depth at the linebacker position, as the likes of Ezekiel Turner and Grant Stuard bring veteran depth to the group. The issue may be just how many of the options can make the roster, as there's a case for each of the players to have a spot when the team breaks camp.
Turner had nine total tackles Saturday, while Stuard had four solo tackles and a forced fumble. While Stuard's facemask penalty negated a sack, he has proven to be a player the Lions can rely on in multiple aspects of the game. Behind the starting trio of Barnes, Anzalone and Campbell, the Lions should feel quite confident in what they have.
The Lions' secondary bounced back in a big way after some ups and downs against Atlanta. Specifically, Erick Hallett was much better. He paced the defense with three pass breakups, including one in the end zone to stifle a Dolphins drive.
Nick Whiteside continues to impress as well, deflecting one pass and making four combined tackles. Luq Barcoo and D.J. Miller each had two pass breakups as well. Safety Loren Strickland had four total tackles, while Ian Kennelly had two assisted stops.
Jake Bates connected on his only field goal attempt of the afternoon to remain perfect, while Jack Fox boomed seven punts that averaged a gross over 50 yards. When the Lions are strong on special teams, they are incredibly difficult to beat.
Detroit's special teams also benefited from the presence of Sione Vaki, who is expected to be a core special teams player on multiple units.
The Lions look to have found their backup at this point, as the decision to start Kyle Allen paid off with 14 first-half points. Allen looks much more comfortable in the offense than Hooker has through the first three preseason games.
Ultimately, the Lions' depth players weren't able to squeeze out the victory, but Detroit should feel pretty solid following this week as they dominated the joint practices between these two teams.
The Lions' starters passed the test, and while they weren't able to emerge victorious, the Lions and coach Dan Campbell should feel good about where they're at heading into the preseason finale.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!