On Facebook
On Flipboard
On Twitter
Because of their cap situation, the Miami Dolphins are going to be facing some very difficult decisions this offseason and one of them just might involve Christian Wilkins.
Yes, Christian Wilkins.
On the surface, it should be a slam dunk that the Dolphins need to re-sign their 2019 first-round pick after he had an impressive performance in the just-completed season playing on his fifth-year option, but it's just not that simple.
WHY THE DOLPHINS NEED TO RE-SIGN WILKINS
The reason the Dolphins absolutely should re-sign Wilkins is that he's become a foundational piece not only on defense but for the entire roster.
Wilkins has been a tone-setter for the defense almost from the time he arrived as the 13th overall selection out of Clemson in 2019 and after four seasons being a dominant run defender, he broke out as a pass rusher in 2023 with career highs in sacks (previous high was 4.5) with nine and quarterback hits with 23 (previous high was 10).
Alongside Zach Sieler, Wilkins gave the Dolphins tremendous production in the interior of the defensive line. Sieler and Wilkins were the only interior defensive line teammates to each finish with at least nine sacks and they helped Miami finish the season seventh in the NFL in rushing yards allowed per game and sixth in rushing yards allowed per play.
At 28, Wilkins also should have plenty of good football ahead of him.
WHY THE DOLPHINS MIGHT LET WILKINS WALK
So from a pure football standpoint, the Dolphins re-signing Wilkins wouldn't even be a discussion, and this is where the team's nasty cap situation comes into play.
It's not just that the Dolphins won't have a lot of money to spend this offseason. They have to shed contract commitments — and a lot of them — just to get to the salary cap limit by the start of the league year March 13.
The Dolphins are almost $52 million over the cap at this time, according to overthecap.com, which means some tough decisions are coming soon before too long.
Wilkins played on that fifth-year option after his representation and the Dolphins couldn't come to terms on a long-term extension last summer, which led to Wilkins staging a training camp "hold in."
The Dolphins had the upper hand in negotiations then because of the fifth-year option, and they also have a tool this year with the franchise tag.
The projected franchise tag number for defensive tackles for 2024 is $19.7 million, per overthecap.com, and it would give the Dolphins the right to match any offer sheet or get two first-round picks if they declined to match.
The problem there is that the deadline to apply the franchise tag is March 5 and that money goes on the books for 2024 the second the player signs the tag.
If the Dolphins do sign Wilkins to a long-term extension, the contract can be structured to carry a lower cap number in the first year than the $19.7 million the tag would carry, but that leads to the question of how high the team wants to go in its price to make that happen.
THE DEFENSIVE TACKLE MARKET
While he looked for a new deal last year, Wilkins watched a half-dozen other high-end defensive tackles around the league get new contracts and he can bet he was paying attention.
Five defensive tackles — Quinnen Williams, Jeffery Simmons, Daron Payne, Dexter Lawrence and Javon Hargrave — got new deals in 2023 for an annual average between $21 million and $24 million and one could argue Wilkins was every bit as good as any of them, if not better, with Williams maybe being the one exception.
Wilkins' market value was estimated at $20.2 million annually by spotrac.com, but it would surprise no one if he asked for more than that.
If Wilkins was the only important Dolphins player headed for free agent, it would be a lot easier to dish out big money to keep him, but the team has several other key players on whom to make a decision.
GM Chris Grier discussed Wilkins' pending free agency in the annual season review media session with him and head coach Mike McDaniel.
"Christian and I actually had a really good conversation today," Grier said. "I was very happy for him. He bet on himself after a summer of negotiations where we made a couple offers and one we felt very good about, was fair, and he and his representation said as much, but we couldn’t close that gap at the end. So he bet on himself and it paid off for him. I’m very happy for him. So we’ll stay in communication and see where this ends up, but he earned the right to be a free agent. Again, I’m happy for him. We drafted him here, developed him here, and he’s the type of person we’re looking for. So we’ll see what happens.”
In an ideal world, what happens is that Wilkins signs a new long-term contract with the Dolphins. But this clearly is not an ideal offseason for the Dolphins because of their cap situation, so, — as Grier said — we'll see what happens.
More must-reads:
- Five potential landing spots for Christian Wilkins after stunning Raiders release
- Sizzling AFC training-camp position battles
- The 'Single-season sack leaders by NFL team' quiz
Breaking News
Trending News
Customize Your Newsletter
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!
TODAY'S BEST
Releasing Christian Wilkins Proves Spytek, and the Raiders Mean Business
Since taking over as the general manager of the Las Vegas Raiders, John Spytek and Raiders Head Coach, Pete Carroll, have emphasized how critical it will be for them to establish a new culture for their team. After years of subpar play, the Raiders needed to improve their culture equally as much as they needed to improve their roster. Spytek wasted no time significantly improving the Raiders' roster, adding Geno Smith and Ashton Jeanty this offseason. Although a culture change usually takes more than offseason, the Raiders may have expedited the process by releasing veteran defensive tackle Christian Wilkins. The organization and Wilkins were not on the same page in regard to his rehab, pushing the Raiders to make a drastic move. While drastic, the move appears to align with Spytek's intended composition of the Raiders' roster. At the NFL Combine months before Wilkins' recent release, the Raiders' general manager explained what he would take into consideration when assembling the Raiders' roster. While Spytek likely figured Wilkins would be part of the team at the time, his words rang true following the veteran defensive tackle's release. “I think we're going to have a lot of positive energy. The guys that love to compete and play with passion are going to have a chance at our place. And the guys that maybe don't have that love of the game, they like it, it's a means to an end, there probably won't be as many places or spaces for them at our place," Spytek said. "I think we want to set the tone with our film. When people watch a week or two out for our games coming, like they want to know, like this is going to be a battle, this is going to be physical, this is going to be old-school football." It is challenging to maintain positive energy when a player who has only played five games with the Silver and Black fails to uphold their end of a contract worth over $100 million. Shortly after releasing Wilkins, the Raiders issued the following statement. "We have decided that it is in the best interests of the organization to move on from Christian Wilkins. This franchise has a Commitment to Excellence on and off the field. With no clear path or plan for future return to play from Christian, this transaction is necessary for the entire organization to move forward and prepare for the new season." The Raiders' words spoke loudly enough, but they did not say nearly as loudly as the actual move of releasing Wilkins. Full details of why the Raiders decided to move on from Wilkins after just one season remain unclear, but one thing is clear: the Raiders' new-look front office means business. Find us on X (formerly Twitter) @HondoCarpenter and Instagram @HondoSr and weigh in on this take. While here, check out our Facebook page WHEN YOU CLICK RIGHT HERE to discuss this take
Chris Pronger to Connor McDavid: A Lost Edmonton Oilers Decade
In the spring of 2006, Chris Pronger was traded to the Edmonton Oilers. He then did something no one thought possible: he made the Edmonton Oilers a Stanley Cup contender again. That playoff run was legendary. Pronger logged enormous minutes, quarterbacked the power play, killed penalties, and led the team in scoring. In every zone and every moment, he was the difference-maker. He was the kind of player who gave an entire franchise a sense of direction—and belief. And then, just weeks after that Game 7 heartbreak in Carolina, he was gone. The Impact of the Oilers Losing a True No. 1 Blueliner Pronger’s trade request stunned the city and changed everything. Instead of building around a generational defenseman in his prime, the Oilers entered a prolonged decline. The team wouldn’t return to the playoffs for another decade. But what if he had stayed? It’s not just about Pronger’s elite play. It’s about the ripple effect of having that kind of presence anchoring a lineup. With Pronger in the fold, free agents might have been more willing to come. The team wouldn’t have scrambled to fill the void on the blue line with a carousel of short-term fixes. Young players could have developed under a true leader instead of inheriting pressure without support. The Oilers Championship Window Closed Too Soon The Oilers were close in 2006. It was not a fluke, but it was a team suddenly galvanized by elite goaltending from Dwayne Roloson, role players like Mike Peca, top-six grit like Ryan Smyth and Fernando Pisani, and above all, Pronger’s towering presence. Run it back even one more year, and who knows? A healthy Roloson, a stabilized core, and the confidence of a team that knew how close they came. Perhaps 2007 would be the season that ended differently for the Oilers. Instead, the Oilers lost their best player and wandered through the wilderness for ten years. How bad did the Oilers become? The 2006–07 season was a major disappointment in Edmonton, capped by the emotional deadline trade of fan favorite Smyth to the New York Islanders. That collapse marked the beginning of a long drought, as the team went on to miss the playoffs for 10 straight seasons until finally returning in 2016–17. Hockey Is Filled with What Ifs, the Oilers Are No Exception Hockey is full of what-ifs. But this one lingers. Because Pronger did come to Edmonton, and he did show what was possible. And for one electric spring, it looked like the Oilers had found the player who could lead them back to greatness. We just never got to find out how far that road might have gone. Fortunately, the team’s return to the playoffs in 2016–17 was spearheaded by Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl. And that’s where the team is today. It’s a new era of success, but it took ten years to get there.
Biggest impact of Josh Naylor trade may still be to come
While the Seattle Mariners landed an impact bat on Thursday night, their trade for Josh Naylor has also likely impacted the entire upcoming MLB trade deadline. On Thursday, Seattle sent a pair of top pitching prospects to the Arizona Diamondbacks in exchange for Naylor, with left-hander Brandyn Garcia (ranked as Seattle's 13th-best prospect by MLB.com) and right-hander Ashton Izzi (ranked as Seattle's 16th-best prospect by the same rankings) heading to the desert. Knowing what the Diamondbacks received in exchange for Naylor could well set the market for what is to come between now and the conclusion of the 2025 MLB trade deadline, set for 6 p.m. (Eastern) on July 31. The 28-year-old first baseman was ranked by The Athletic as the 17th-best trade candidate likely to be available, but ranked behind just one other first baseman (Baltimore's Ryan O'Hearn, who was slotted in at 16th). If Naylor brought in a pair of pitching prospects, including Garcia, who has appeared in two games this season for Seattle, the Diamondbacks could be salivating over what third baseman Eugenio Suarez and his 36 home runs could bring in return. All MLB teams who will be buying or selling at this year's trade deadline have had the first price bar set for them with the Naylor deal. Now it will be fascinating to see what comes next, especially knowing that Naylor will be a free agent at the end of this season. If Seattle gave up two pitching prospects for a player who could be a late-season rental only, imagine what the Minnesota Twins may be able to recoup for starting pitcher Joe Ryan (under team control through the 2027 season) or the Boston Red Sox might get back for outfielder Jarren Duran, who won't be a free agent until the 2029 campaign. While Naylor may not be the biggest move to come during this span before the trade deadline comes to a close, his deal could be the one that establishes selling prices for the trades that are to come. With so few MLB teams expected to be outright sellers, the price for available talent was expected to be high. We learned on Thursday night with the Naylor swap just how high those prices may go.
Commanders sign special teams standout to extension
The Washington Commanders are primed for a big season after surprising the league last year thanks to the brilliant play of Jayden Daniels. But the front office has done a great job of building the entire roster, not just the offense. On Thursday, the organization managed to extend one of its key contributors on special teams. Reports indicate that the Commanders are signing safety Percy Butler to a one-year contract extension, according to Tom Pelissero of the NFL Network. Butler, who is 25 years old, excels as a gunner in Washington’s punt unit. “The Commanders have agreed to terms on a one-year extension with safety Percy Butler, per source. Locking up a special teams standout.” It’s an underrated position, as typically individuals think about offense and defense in terms of making an impact. But Butler has proven to be a reliable option for the Commanders’ special teams units, as he does a fantastic job at sprinting downfield after the kick to make the tackle. However, Percy Butler has stepped in as a safety as well throughout his three years in the NFL so far. Last season, Butler stepped in as the starting safety for five games, but made an appearance in all 17 contests. He ended the 2024-25 campaign with 47 combined tackles (29 solo), two tackles for a loss, and one pass deflection. Butler was a fourth-round pick by the Commanders in the 2022 NFL Draft. He’s done nothing but prove to be a consistent option in special teams, and looks like he’ll continue playing that role for quite some time. He, along with his teammates, will play their first game of the regular season on September 7 against the New York Giants. That should be a fun matchup for a Commanders team aiming for a big year. Although many don’t have high expectations for the Giants, it is a divisional contest. Typically, those games can go in any direction regardless of the record. Especially in a Week 1 game, where the NFL can be quite unpredictable. Either way, it should be a fun game.
PRIVACY POLICY EDITORIAL POLICY CONTACT US
ABOUT YARDBARKER TERMS OF SERVICE
Use of this website (including any and all parts and
components) constitutes your acceptance of these
Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
This site is for entertainment purposes only.
There is no gambling offered on this site.
Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-Gambler.
