
Ohio State University’s debate over whether to shut down junior wide receiver Jeremiah Smith has become a question of competing obligations: preserving an elite NFL Draft prospect or letting a cornerstone player finish a season that still includes the Michigan game. Smith has not been portrayed as seeking an exit. The argument instead centers on whether the program should make that call for him after a season in which he has continued to produce at a record-setting level.
Smith’s production gives Ohio State a difficult calculation. The 6-foot-4 receiver is a junior on the Buckeyes’ roster, and Ohio State’s Northwestern game materials listed him with 1,200 receiving yards and 14 touchdowns through nine games. He also owns the program career records for receptions, receiving yards, and receiving touchdowns.
Ohio State’s remaining schedule keeps the case for playing intact. Daniel of The Sitdown w/ Malik Wright said Smith should not be shut down now, though he believes a sit-out deserves serious consideration because of Smith’s NFL future. Daniel’s position rests on Smith’s standing within the offense, his continued production while drawing extra attention, and the value of seeing through the commitment to his teammates.
Ja’Marr Chase supplies the precedent Daniel raised, although the circumstances were different. Chase opted out of LSU’s 2020 season during the COVID-19 pandemic and was selected fifth overall in the 2021 NFL Draft. Smith’s profile has prompted the same long-term question, but Daniel stopped short of saying that Smith should leave the Buckeyes immediately.
Ohio State should be the ones to shut down Jeremiah Smith.
Lucky
Ohio State’s responsibility to protect Smith is the opposing view. Lucky of The Sitdown w/ Malik Wright argued that the school, rather than Smith, should make a shutdown decision to protect his draft capital and keep an opt-out from being framed as a player abandoning the team. The argument also recognizes Smith’s competitiveness, because continuing to play would reinforce the commitment Lucky believes he has shown throughout his career.
Smith’s current place in Ohio State history makes either choice consequential. He has 3,758 career receiving yards, 232 receptions, and 41 touchdown catches, totals that place him first in program history in all three categories. A shutdown would preserve a player already positioned near the top of the NFL Draft conversation. Playing on would give Ohio State its best receiver for the games that remain.
Ohio State’s immediate path still includes a November 28 home game against the University of Michigan. The program also launched its “JJ 4 It All” campaign on November 11 to promote Smith’s candidacy for the Heisman Trophy, Biletnikoff Award, Maxwell Award, and Walter Camp Player of the Year Award. The decision around Smith now sits between the value of those remaining stakes and the risk that comes with asking a premier prospect to continue playing.
The Sitdown w/ Malik Wright · watch the full segment
Cited segments:
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!