Jonathan Taylor Dominates Offensive Player of the Year Conversation

His combination of volume, efficiency, and ball security has powered an Indianapolis offense that sits among the league’s elite.

The preseason projections are laughable in hindsight. Taylor’s total touchdown prop line was listed at +9.5 TDs (-102) for the entire year, and he’s already hit eight with 11 games left to play.

His rushing yard total opened at +1,200.5 yards (-114), a mark he’s on pace to hit by late November. For those who took Taylor's futures in August, the cash-out button is practically glowing.

If his pace continues, Taylor will finish with 326 carries, 1,708 rushing yards, 416 receiving yards, 23 total touchdowns, 82 first downs, and zero fumbles on the 2025 season. 

Those numbers would mark his second 2,000-yard, 20-touchdown season since 2021—and put him on the short list of backs bound for Canton, Ohio.

The Colts’ offense flows through Taylor, and defenses still can’t stop it. Even when opponents load the box, Taylor’s vision and burst turn nothing plays into drive-sustaining runs.

What separates him this season is his efficiency. Every carry feels calculated—patient enough to let blocks develop, explosive enough to flip field position in seconds.

If the current trend holds, the OPOY race may already be over before Thanksgiving. Taylor’s the engine of a 5–1 Colts team that looks built for a deep playoff run.

Taylor isn’t just leading the NFL in rushing—he’s leading the next great Colts era. And if this pace continues, he won’t just be Offensive Player of the Year—he’ll be carving out a Hall of Fame path in real time.

His dominance has reignited pride in Indianapolis, echoing the days of past Colts legends. Taylor isn’t just building a résumé, he’s building a legacy that defines a generation.

For bettors, this might be the last window to find value before the market moves again. At +175, Taylor’s OPOY odds still offer plus money—but he’s one dominant performance away from the line flipping to minus money for good.

Game odds refresh periodically and are subject to change. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem and wants help, call 1-800-GAMBLER.