x
NFL drops the ball with Puka Nacua suspension
Icon Sportswire / Getty Images

As has been expected for months, the NFL finally dropped the hammer on Rams wide receiver Puka Nacua on Thursday, suspending the star for three games for violating the league’s personal conduct policy. But the hammer was one of those rubber ones that squeak when you smash them because Nacua will serve those three games while he’s out on injured reserve.

It’s an odd conclusion to an odd disciplinary journey over the past 12 months. The threat of suspension has been hanging over Nacua and the Rams for months, but now that they have their verdict, they know their best player won’t be missing any time that he wouldn’t have already missed because of his injury.

The decision invites intense scrutiny because it appears the NFL is playing favorites with the Rams by ensuring they don’t lose a player who actually matters to wins and losses.

Nacua to serve suspension while injured

NFL insider Adam Schefter reported that Nacua’s suspension is effective immediately as of Thursday, Nov. 19, and that Nacua is eligible for reinstatement Monday, Dec. 14.

Nacua was injured on the final drive of the Rams’ Week 9 win over the Commanders. With LA up 20-13 with 1:44 left, they ran an inside jet sweep that left Nacua slow to get up off the turf. The Rams ended up placing him on injured reserve with a sprained MCL, PCL and turf toe on Nov. 12.

It was yet another injury in a season that has been riddled with them for the fourth-year wideout. Nacua also battled a calf injury and played through it against the Raiders, and he missed Weeks 2 and 3 with a pulled groin.

FANTASY LINEUP TIPS: QB Week 11 rankings • RB Week 11 rankings • WR Week 11 rankings • TE Week 11 rankings • D/ST Week 11 rankings

But the IR designation automatically keeps Nacua out for four games, three of which he will be suspended for.

Why was Nacua suspended?

This isn’t the first time Schefter reported that Nacua would be suspended. In August, Schefter said on his podcast that Nacua’s case was being reviewed and that he could ¨potentially face discipline for some of the offseason headlines that accompanied him and some of those incidents last year with another woman. What did and did not occur, we’ll leave that to the NFL to figure out what did and did not happen.¨

Nacua is being sued by a woman who claims that he bit her and her friend without their consent after a New Year’s Eve dinner last December.

Nacua didn’t face criminal charges for the incident, which his lawyer described as “horseplay.” Instead, he was entered into a diversion program that “diverts individuals detained for non-serious/non-violent misdemeanors and felonies to community supports, instead of criminal charges being filed (which could entail prosecution and jail time),” USA Today reported. 

The woman sued Nacua in March, and the case is still pending. 

“Puka denies these allegations in the strongest possible terms,” his attorney said at the time. In April, Nacua’s attorney revealed that his client had checked into rehab. 

His attorney revealed that Nacua will be filing a defamation suit against the woman, who says that she got a tetanus shot after the incident. 

The NFL suspended other players

Nacua wasn’t the only player Schefter reported on at the time, but he was by far the biggest name. Those other names ran the gamut of infractions, like the Commanders’ Dorance Armstrong, who was suspended for one game, or the Falcons edge rusher James Pearce Jr., who was suspended for eight games.

But while those punishments were handed down just weeks before the start of the season, Nacua’s suspension has been delayed until Week 11. And his infraction occurred in December of last year.

That raises questions about why it took the NFL so long to make this decision and whether they are showing favoritism to the Rams by waiting to suspend him now. Unless the league has some plausible explanation, the timing of this suspension seems designed to help the Rams mitigate Nacua’s loss as much as possible.

If you are going to suspend him, suspend him. If you don’t think his infraction reaches the level of suspension, then don’t suspend him. But to land in the middle like this is the worst of both worlds. It only punishes Nacua monetarily (estimated game-check losses of about $961,000), and it doesn’t hurt the Rams at all.

The NFL has a lot to answer for with its decision. Agree or disagree in the comments below.

This article first appeared on Lindy's Sports and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!