One of the more interesting assessments of Caleb Williams came not from one of the major analytical websites but from a longtime NFL writer via Substack.
Veteran NFL writer Frank Cooney takes a look at the Williams-Ben Johnson tandem and actually breaches the sociological barrier in his assessment.
Fascinating stuff. Way too deep and essentially incorrect but definitely fascinating.
"While the team still tries to justify this No. 1 pick by rearranging furniture, I stick to pre-draft concerns that, despite displays of magicianry, Williams has flaws hard-wired into his game (can you say Hero ball?) that will take time to fix," Cooney wrote.
When I read anything about Ben Johnson and Caleb Williams working together….
— Kevin (@Krazy4golf) April 1, 2025
I’m soooo looking forward to next season. ⬇️ pic.twitter.com/rOHjQHprq6
And his kicker: "As a quintessential Gen-Z product, he is accustomed to customizing things to fit him rather than adapting himself."
Cooney obviously paints with too wide of a brush when he indicts a full generation of human beings for being spoiled, but it's an interesting assessment because the Bears have said they are catering to Williams to some extent.
I have never seen a play like this in my lifetime
— Josh Norris (@JoshNorris) October 9, 2023
a called direct snap to the RB... with the QB under center
Lions OC Ben Johnson was having fun out there pic.twitter.com/6w2pSp7Qxw
Johnson even said when he came in the building that his offense was being built to suit Williams.
"He is a phenomenal talent that had, as many quarterbacks do, an up and down rookie year," Johnson said. "Where I see my role is as a supporter of him.
I still find myself watching this throw by Caleb Williams often.
— Bearsszn (@bearssznn) July 16, 2025
Just look at the speed on that ball. An absolute laser. The Bears have their guy.
pic.twitter.com/sa6fimRBfF
"This offense will be calibrated with him in mind. We're going to build this thing. This is not simply a dropping of a previous playbook down on the table and starting there. Nope, we're ripping this thing down to the studs, and we're going to build it out with him first and foremost."
It's not just a "generation Z" thing. Football coaches have adapted to their talent for decades. Those who do it best are the most successful long term.
Ben Johnson's offenses are obviously creative, but they execute the basics really well too.
— Bobby Peters (@b_peters12) June 25, 2025
Under center Stick Spacing beating a blitz here. pic.twitter.com/RtlTHMHmTM
Good luck to those too rigid and unyielding with their aim because a smaller percentage will hit it big and the huge percentage will immediately flame out.
What is being done besides that is implementing a style of offense easier for quarterbacks to run. You can't make it all about the player's past experience. It needs to be about their actual skills and Williams should be no different than most QBs in that he'll benefit with open receivers.
The other interesting aspects of this analysis includes the point Williams' inability to quickly learn Johnson's offense because he lacks experience at taking snaps under center.
Ben Johnson is just so good
— Josh Norris (@JoshNorris) September 10, 2024
Window dressing with Amon-Ra at the snap, fake it to him on a sweep in the opposite direction. Pulls two defenders.
David Montgomery exiting out the opposite direction, pulls another defender.
Leave LaPorta wide open, uncovered, after the delay… pic.twitter.com/qgEn5Sbowd
Cooney is right about Williams lack of experience under center. He's really never been in an offense that does this much, going back to high school. However, it's using plays under center that makes Johnson's offense so wildly successful.
It lets Johnson make "...the same things to look different and different things to look the same," as he famously told everyone former Bears offensive coordinator John Shoop taught him to do at North Carolina.
Ben Johnson creates so many easy yards for receivers in the screen game. pic.twitter.com/ZytPXvZFpC
— Bobby Peters (@b_peters12) April 27, 2025
According to an ESPN analysis by Bill Barnwell, play-action passs generate .21 expected points added (EPA) while throws without play fake only add .15 EPA. It's higher EPA that is Johnson's stated goal.
It doesn't matter that Williams lacks experience under center. What matters is they'll use this proven approach and make it easier for Williams to find receivers who are more wide open, thereby improving his accuracy issues downfield, his low completion percentage and yards per attempt. The end result will b better EPA.
They're not catering to what Williams has done in the past and is comfortable with so much as they are challenging him to adjust his own skillset to a proven way of success.
Yall really let this demon get Ben Johnson after a horrible horrible coaching staff ? pic.twitter.com/e0RHcNaAYk
— (Drew) Chicago Fan (@CHITOWNDREW23) May 15, 2025
This doesn't sound like catering an offense to anyone. It sounds like a winning coach who knows what needs to be done to succeed and does it.
The Lions led the NFL in plays under center at 56.2% last year. They ran play-action 36.1%, more than any other team. The Bears were 30th in play-action usage.
Peyton Manning shares his thoughts on Caleb Williams and Ben Johnson pic.twitter.com/h0dJE76e7W
— Dave (@dave_bfr) July 12, 2025
Williams will find this to be a more liberating way of play.
What will happen is Johnson's methods break receivers more open and facilitate more yards after the catch—another area where the Lions QB was No. 1 in the league. It means more yards per pass attempt and a more explosive attack.
The receivers who are more wide open are easier to see and Williams' completion percentage should go up while his catchable throw rate—terrible last year—should dramatically improve. Williams already was good at finding receivers in tight coverage with passes. Now he'll ned to throw fewer into tight coverage and percentages increase even more.
Pretty average if you ask me https://t.co/2jsOOaUnpG pic.twitter.com/zAnOylt1hB
— Steven Patton (@PattonAnalytics) July 13, 2025
If it doesn't happen this way, then expect Johnson to reroute and look for something different at quarterback after this season.
This seems unlikely, though.
Any quarterback, whether Generation X, millennials or Generation Z, could improve when a coach's approach does what Johnson's does for them.
These Caleb Williams TD passes are even more impressive from this angle @CALEBcsw | @ChicagoBears pic.twitter.com/HaOcSjbf84
— NFL (@NFL) July 17, 2025
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!