The perception around Chicago Bears' tight end Cole Kmet has always been an interesting discussion to follow, both from the outside and from other people in and around the league.
Through five seasons in Chicago, Kmet has never been named to the Pro Bowl, much less receive All-Pro recognition. Statistically, he's always been a reliable target for the Bears regardless of who's at quarterback.
Inside the locker room, Kmet has always been one of the team's top leaders and now has become one of the longest tenured players in the building.
Which is why in July of 2023, the Bears rewarded Kmet with a four-year, $50 million extension, a deal that still ranks seventh in average per year and sixth in total value. Outside of the Bears' building, many still consider Kmet to be overpaid.
That kind of talk only grew louder after people looked at the stats and saw Kmet posted the fewest receptions and yards since his rookie season in 2024. On closer inspection, Kmet actually set career-highs in yards/target and reception percentage.
It was clear despite having one of his worst career outings in the mainstream stats, those inside the league still recognized Kmet as one of the top players at his position for what he still was able to accomplish.
Thats why, in ESPN's latest Top-10 positional rankings, Kmet was listed as an honorable mention, but one gripe from a unanimous NFL personnel evaluator shows how Kmet's ranking is primed to drop even more after 2025.
"Probably underutilized as a three-down tight end. He can stretch the seams and work underneath for the QB." - Unnamed NFL personnel evaluator, via ESPN's Jeremy Fowler
Execs, coaches, scouts rank NFL's top 10 tight ends
— Jeremy Fowler (@JFowlerESPN) July 11, 2025
-Brock Bowers first-ever No. 1 debut since Top 10s began in 2020
-Kittle vs. Kelce: a great half-decade run
-How does a TE2 become overall TE8? https://t.co/XQ609T5DQH
After the Bears hired head coach Ben Johnson, Kmet's stock was on the rise, that's until Chicago used their first-round pick on Michigan tight end Colston Loveland.
When the pick was made, Kmet admits he was "taken aback" until speaking with his new coach and understanding the vision Johnson had in mind to utilize both players.
From Chicago's standpoint, having a dominant 2-TE formation is going to be fruitful for Johnson's scheme. From an outside standpoint, it's easy to see how those around the league could view Kmet's impact differently.
Over the past few seasons, Kmet has been THE guy at Chicago's tight end position. Now with Loveland in the picture, Kmet's underutilization as a three-down player will be even more evident to those watching based on how the team views Loveland.
"The versatility on both base and third down, that was really the biggest thing that stood out," offensive coordinator Declan Doyle said of Loveland. "He's a mismatch, he's a target, he's a guy that doesn't ever have to come off the field if you don't want him to."
Going with the younger, more explosive, target in this offense is the right move. But, that doesn't mean Kmet will be a full non-factor this upcoming season.
His reliable hands and blocking ability will still force the Bears to integrate him into the offense, paving the way for both tight ends to contribute.
"You understand that there’s going to be areas where we complement each other, and — just like any position room – there’s going to be areas that we compete for things," Kmet said. "That’s football and that’s how it should be. So, I’m excited about it — we’re going to make each other better."
All this to say, after the 2025 season, don't expect Kmet to rise any higher on this list. In fact, I can even seeing him continue to fall down the rankings, whether it's fair or not.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!