Yardbarker
x
Panthers WR battle in training camp will be the ultimate litmus test for who this team wants to be with some tough decisions ahead
Brett Davis-Imagn Images

The Carolina Panthers wrapped up the latest phase of the offseason program last week with mandatory minicamp and will have a break before returning in late July / early August for the start of training camp.

That's when the roster battles start getting real and the pads fully start to come on. Which eventually leads us to roster cuts and the formation of the 53-man roster.

All of this to say, tough decision are ahead for the front office and the coaching staff, and the position in the most interesting position is easily at wide receiver.

Carolina has two for sure roster locks at the position in Xavier Legette and first-round rookie Tetairoa McMillan. Veteran slot specialist Adam Thielen stands on some solid ground as well for the upcoming season.

Behind those three starters is where things start to get complicated in the Panthers' WR room and the decisions that are made can help determine what kind of team the Panthers want to be in 2025.

Panthers 2025 WR Battle Overview

Last season, the Panthers opted to keep seven wide receivers on the initial 53-man roster in Legette, Thielen, Diontae Johnson, Jonathan Mingo, Ihmir Smith-Marsette, David Moore, and Jalen Coker.

While speaking with reporters last week at minicamp, head coach Dave Canales noted determining the final spots in the room will be a "very difficult" process and it'll come down to who is showing overall team versatility.

"Special teams is going to be such a huge piece of that puzzle. How can these guys help us in the coverage units? Can they help us as a returner?" Canales explained. "That’s the part where we get to challenge our guys to find a role, take this thing seriously. You’re not here just to catch passes. We only get so many helmets on game day, so we need all of you guys to contribute in different ways."

So, let's look at the field and break it down into two categories: the vets and the youngsters.

The Vets

In this area really we're looking at three players in particular: Hunter Renfrow, David Moore, and Dan Chiesna.

Starting with Renfrow, the Panthers signed the five-year Carolina-native back in late April after taking a year off from the NFL. Renfrow shared he was dealing with ulcerative colitis following his release from the Raiders. He's a savvy route runner, locker room leader, and has made significant impacts on special teams before.

As for Moore, his lone season in Carolina last year was surprisingly productive hauling in 32 receptions and three touchdowns. That kind of impact allowed the Panthers to re-sign him for the 2025 season. He's got a lot of history with Canales too after previously playing for him in Tampa Bay and Seattle prior to joining the Panthers.

Then you have Chisena, who was a former UDFA in 2020, yet has 37 games under his belt over the course of five years. He's mainly be utilized as a special teams ace but recorded his first three receptions of his regular season career last year in Carolina.

By rocking with any of these three players, the Panthers will show they value experience and locker room presence at the position.

The Youngsters

As for the young, rising, players at the position the attention turns to Jalen Coker, Jimmy Horn Jr., Jacolby George, T.J. Luther, and Brycen Tremayne.

Starting with Coker, one might think the 2024 UDFA should be a roster lock, and I'd tend to agree with that. He's the future for this team in the slot after Thielen leaves and looked really good last season nearly reaching 500 receiving yards. But, with Thielen now healthy, Coker needs to show he can be utilized in different ways if he wants to make the final roster. Cutting him though, risks another team picking him up.

Horn seems like the strongest candidate to make the 53-man list out of the players in this section. The sixth-round rookie has a solid grasp on the punt return job and could have an immediate impact in that role using his explosiveness. 

And with George, Luther, and Tremayne, it all comes down to special teams impact as well. George, specifically, got a sizable contract from the team despite being a UDFA, although that's not always a tell tale sign of their roster status by training camp.

By rocking with players like Coker, Horn, and George over guys like Renfrow, Moore, and Chisena in some capacity, the Panthers will show the youth-movement extends to the WR room as well to allow this young nucleus to grow together through the fire.

This article first appeared on A to Z Sports and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!