
Paul Finebaum hates underdogs. America was built by underdogs. Therefore, Paul Finebaum hates the people that built America and by extension America itself.
How else can you explain the completely nonsensical argument that Finebaum has been making over the past few weeks while lambasting the College Football Playoff for letting in American Athletic Conference champion Tulane and Sun Belt champion James Madison over teams like Notre Dame and Texas?
“It’s time to get rid of the G5 schools and I know how they got in there – it was a compromise – but America does not want to see Tulane nor do we want to see James Madison in the College Football Playoff. This is great in the NCAA basketball tournament – there are 68 schools. There are only 12 here and we don’t need around. I’m not going to give you the ‘all due respect’ because I don’t really care about Tulane or James Madison. They’re gonna lose by 25 to 45 points, they’ll be unwatchable games. Get them out of the playoff!”
Those were Paul Finebaum's words on ESPN's Get Up this morning, which not only dismiss the dozens of blowouts that have happened between power conference schools through the years, they spit in the face of America's 250-year history of supporting underdogs.
"It's time to get rid of the G5 schools."@finebaum weighs in on what he would do to fix the CFP system pic.twitter.com/Q9k0BZIbNU
— Get Up (@GetUpESPN) December 9, 2025
Finebaum's exact same argument would have made Paul Finebaum a Loyalist sympathizer leading up to the American Revolution. And while Finebaum is certainly old enough to have met George Washington, Benjamin Franklin, John Adams, Thomas Jefferson and the rest of them, America's chances of surviving the first winter, let alone winning the war were far slimmer than Tulane covering the spread against Ole Miss are.
But if Finebaum had been around to make this argument in the newspapers back in the 1770s, his response would've been something to the tune of "We don't need those people with gripes against the King. I don't really care about James Madison."
Switching the topic back to sports, here are just some of the historic upsets that have taken place in the United States and around the world that Paul Finebaum would never have allowed to take place in his perfect world:
Finebaum would, of course, state that he would support all of those great things happening. But now that he's made the nonsensical argument that underdogs shouldn't even be allowed to compete, he absolutely cannot be taken at his word.
If underdogs that have met every qualification to simply compete for something, they have the right to either lose on their own merit or attempt to spring an upset. They'll most likely fail, but America will root for them as they do for all underdogs. Because we are a nation that loves the underdog story.
But Paul Finebaum hates underdogs. The greatest achievements in American history have been achieved by underdogs. Therefore, Paul Finebaum hates what built America and by extension America itself.
Disclaimer: This article is 100% satire.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!