The Buffalo Bills’ rookie class is off to a rough start this season. And while players around the league whom the Bills had the opportunity to draft are excelling with their respective teams, it’s fair to criticize the direction the Bills took this past spring.
Particularly at the safety position, where Atlanta Falcons’ third-round pick Xavier Watts has quickly become one of the most talented young defensive players in the NFL this season.
Watts was selected with the No. 96 overall pick of the 2025 draft, 24 picks after the Bills settled on edge rusher Landon Jackson with the No. 72 overall pick. While Watts has started all four of his team’s games this season, Jackson has been a game-day active just once through Buffalo’s first five matchups during his rookie year.
XAVIER WATTS GAME WINNER pic.twitter.com/Nbs2JkZvIc
— Rise Up Penix (@RiseUpReader) September 15, 2025
Not only has Watts been on the field with regularity, but he has also excelled, recording a couple of interceptions and four passes defensed through Weeks 1 through 4. Both of those numbers lead the Falcons’ defense, while the first-year pro is also tied for second on the team in total tackles with 23. Jackson has played just 16 defensive snaps this year. He was named the NFC Defensive Rookie of the Month for the month of September.
The Bills entered the offseason with a significant question mark at the safety position , with incumbent starters Taylor Rapp and Damar Hamlin both set to return to the team, while second-year S Cole Bishop was also in competition to earn a starting role.
As it turns out, despite continued growing pains, Bishop has been the team’s best player in the back-end this season, while Rapp has taken a significant step back in his production. And now Hamlin is on Injured Reserve for the next four games due to a pectoral injury, joining rookie defensive backs Max Hairston and Dorian Strong, along with rookie defensive tackle T.J. Sanders, on the mend.
Xavier Watts is a known stud. Watts is going to be one of the best safeties in the NFL one day. pic.twitter.com/tNkMoOwHjN
— Caleb Conrad (@CalebConrad23) September 7, 2025
The injuries have left Buffalo scrambling for depth , particularly at safety, as they get set to potentially turn to veteran Jordan Poyer, who may receive a practice-squad call-up this week against Atlanta. With the deficiencies at the position, discussion surrounding the team’s decision to turn elsewhere in the draft has resurfaced.
With Jackson a relative non-factor this season and the team’s first, second and sixth-round picks on IR, it’s been pretty easy for Bills fans to point to the disappointing start for Rapp as proof of why Buffalo should have elected to select a safety in the draft.
While it may have been tough on general manager Brandon Beane and company to project injuries to three of their rookies, the safety position is an area in which the Bills have struggled to find their footing since the years Poyer and former Bills S Micah Hyde were in their prime. And with the great importance the team’s safeties take on within a Sean McDermott-style defense, it seemed like a no-brainer that the team should have added a young player to the mix.
The Bills will get a close-up look at Watts on Monday night, when they head to Atlanta to take on the Falcons at 7:15 p.m.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!