Matt Detrich/IndyStar / USA TODAY NETWORK

Peyton Manning’s Shadow Made Patriots Legend Tom Brady Shine

Originally posted on Athlon Sports | By Andy Hageman | Last updated Jul 22, 2025 3:15 PM ET

Tom Brady, the NFL’s almost undisputed GOAT, clinched seven Super Bowl titles and redefined quarterback greatness. His fierce rivalry with Peyton Manning, a two-time champ, fueled an era of gridiron excellence. Brady recently revealed how their battles sharpened his competitive edge and redirected his legacy.

Brady’s blog on TomBrady.com shares the intensity behind their clashes, writing, “I made myself believe Peyton thought he was better than me”—admitting he viewed Manning as an opponent to level up his game.

Brady outmaneuvered Manning in 11 of 17 meetings, while Manning held a slight edge in playoff wins (3–2).

Fans still revere the matchup. Coverage from The SportsRush quotes Brady’s raw admission: “He was my enemy… didn’t respect me.”

Their on-field battles, spanning 2001 to 2015, were chess matches of elite football IQs. In retirement, both men thrive: Brady as a minority owner of the Las Vegas Raiders and Fox NFL analyst, influencing the future of the game:

Meanwhile, Manning dominates the media with “The Breakdown” podcast (co-hosted with Bill Belichick) and endearing commercials, backed by his five MVP awards.

Looking back, NFL fans were treated to something rare: two generational quarterbacks at the peak of their powers, trading bombs and brilliance for over a decade. Brady and Manning weren’t just rivals; they were living legends, turning every matchup into must-watch magic, gridiron wizardry if you like.

Their rivalry, now cordial, continues to ignite debates: Who truly reigned supreme? The legacy is written in Super Bowl rings, MVPs, and unforgettable NFL moments.

This article first appeared on Athlon Sports and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads: