Yardbarker
x
Phil Simms Talks Giants' Aura Farming
Michael Karas-NorthJersey.com / USA TODAY NETWORK

The New York Giants are in familiar territory. Sometimes, a rookie comes along who is too talented, too destined for stardom, to hand them a jersey number that isn’t aesthetically pleasing.

In 2024, the Giants pulled out all the stops to unretire No. 1 from Ray Flaherty’s family and give receiver Malik Nabers the jersey he desired. He immediately made good on it, ascending to the pantheon of elite NFL receivers despite bottom-barrel quarterbacking.

New York will hope edge rusher Abdul Carter has a similar rookie season, contending for Defensive Rookie of the Year and making the pass rush a league-best unit. And from the school of “look good, play good,” the Giants might grant him a unique opportunity.

Carter asked Hall of Fame edge rusher Lawrence Taylor for his No. 56, for which he was politely denied. Another figure from New York’s past might be more generous.

Giants legend Phil Simms unholstered his take on unretiring a jersey for a rookie, potentially putting No. 11 up for grabs.

“I told some of my friends, ‘Oh, I’d let him have it in a second. Could you just help it a little and make it better?’ I think it would be a lot of fun. It wouldn’t bother me,” Simms said, via FanDuel TV.

“I know it is (an honor), but whatever, I don’t know. If they really want it,” Simms added. “I don’t know if my family has said anything ... but my agent said, ‘Don’t you dare give up that jersey number.’ Well, first off, I don’t think Abdul Carter is gonna ask for it. But if it was up to me, I would probably give it to him.”

Carter wore No. 11 in college, a specific honor for Penn State that was handed down from superstar Micah Parsons, who also transitioned from linebacker to edge rusher before becoming a first-round pick. Parsons, of course, is a dominant presence. Carter will be expected to match him in New York.

“It would be an honor,” Carter tweeted in response.

Simms also expressed additional interest in Carter because he hoped the Giants would draft him at No. 3. That wish was granted, giving New York a blue-chip prospect that could be among the biggest building blocks on a promising defense.

"I had some fun with it, and the fact that he said it'd be (an) honor to wear, that's just him being really nice," Simms told Art Stapleton of The Record. "Man, it'll make me re-live my days of being an outside linebacker in high school. Truly, I can't wait to see him practice. I was hoping the Giants would get him. He's gonna fit in right away with the Giants culture."

Carter’s pedigree makes this an easy decision. He isn’t a quarterback, playing the sport’s hardest position and failing at a concerning rate. He has the production, and the athleticism, and by the looks of it, the character. Success isn’t guaranteed, but New York isn’t finding a safer bet to bestow such an honor.

For no other reason than how cool it would be for Carter to don the No. 11 on the biggest stage, Simms and the Giants should pull the trigger. Football, at its best, is fun. Why not have some in East Rutherford?

This article first appeared on Athlon Sports and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!