Should Giants Move on from TE Chris Manhertz?

Manhertz ended up playing a bigger role in 2025 than most anticipated, but he was still serviceable.

While he was a relative non-factor in the receiving game with just one catch for seven yards, that was never supposed to be where Manhertz contributed.

As a blocker, Manhertz showed he’s still capable of helping quarterbacks and running backs alike. In 2025, Manhertz posted his best career blocking grades in both run and pass.

Why the Giants Should Keep Him

Finding good inline blockers is no easy task. For years, the NFL devalued the role in favor of more receiving upside.

While the league is coming back around to inline tight ends, the Giants could use an established player there while developing their next man up. Manhertz should be inexpensive and, barring a dramatic drop-off, effective still in 2026.

Why the Giants Shouldn’t Keep Him

If the Giants choose to re-sign Daniel Bellinger and/or give new coach John Harbaugh a familiar face in the tight end room (Isaiah Likely), then Manhertz might not have a place.

Theo Johnson and Thomas Fidone II should still be Giants in 2026, with a presumed third tight end in Bellinger or a free agent. Someone has to be left out, and that someone could very well be Manhertz.

Keep or Move On?

If the Giants intend to keep four tight ends on the roster, or three tight ends and a practice squad call-up option, then Manhertz should be kept. Of course, this all assumes that Manhertz intends to continue playing football in 2026.

He’s still a solid contributor considering the small role that the Giants have asked of him.

The value is there to retain Manhertz, but the question becomes: Is there a roster spot for him?

What happens next with the NY Giants? Find out! Follow and like us on Facebook. Visit our YouTube channel for the latest videos. Want to send a question in for our mailbag? Send it here.