On Facebook
On Flipboard
On Twitter
The Pittsburgh Steelers have seen many historic and legendary players throughout the franchise's history. Among them, Ben Roethlisberger and Terry Bradshaw
stand out as the greatest quarterbacks. Both Roethlisberger and Bradshaw dominated their eras and led the Steelers' offense to exceptional heights. Combined, they won six Super Bowls, with Bradshaw securing four and Roethlisberger winning two.
Debating who was the better quarterback is challenging due to the different eras in which they played. Bradshaw was a dominant force during the 1970s, a time when NFL quarterbacks often threw riskier deep balls, making his statistics harder to compare without watching him play. Over his 14-season career, Bradshaw recorded 107 wins and 51 losses, completed 51.9% of his passes, threw for 212 touchdowns and 210 interceptions, and amassed 27,989 passing yards.
Roethlisberger, who played for 18 seasons, led the Steelers to a 165-81-1 record. He completed 64.4% of his passes, threw for 418 touchdowns and 211 interceptions, and accumulated 64,088 passing yards. Statistically, Roethlisberger appears to be the greater quarterback. However, the different eras must be considered, and even Bradshaw has expressed a desire to play in the modern era to showcase his skills.
Ian Valentino of The 33rd Team analyzed the greatest quarterbacks in each of the 32 NFL teams' histories. When it came to choosing the Steelers' greatest quarterback of all time, Valentino selected Roethlisberger over Bradshaw.
“For as meaningful as Terry Bradshaw was for the Pittsburgh Steelers' Steel Curtain dynasty, Ben Roethlisberger evolved from a successful game manager as a rookie to a feared big-play hunter who drove elite offenses throughout his prime.”
Valentino acknowledged that choosing Roethlisberger over Bradshaw was a tough decision due to Bradshaw's pivotal role in the Steelers' dynasty of the 1970s. However, Valentino couldn't overlook the significant statistical differences between the two legendary quarterbacks.
“Bradshaw won two more Super Bowls than Big Ben but barely finished his career by completing over half his passes and with more touchdowns than interceptions. Roethlisberger had over 36,000 more yards, 216 more touchdowns, and only one more interception in 81 more games.”
Bradshaw is a Hall of Famer, four-time Super Bowl champion, two-time Super Bowl MVP, three-time Pro Bowler, and one-time All-Pro. Roethlisberger, a six-time Pro Bowler and two-time Super Bowl champion, was renowned for his resilience and powerful arm, making him a formidable opponent.
These attributes led Valentino to declare Roethlisberger the greatest quarterback in the Steelers' storied history. Valentino is confident that in 2027 when Roethlisberger is eligible for the Hall of Fame. He will be a lock to make it.
“With his powerful arm, the ability to stay upright through contact, and playmaking, Roethlisberger was always amongst the league leaders in key metrics. He led the league in yards twice and earned six Pro Bowls. Roethlisberger will be a Hall of Fame lock when he's eligible in 2027.”
If Bradshaw and Roethlisberger had swapped eras, the statistics might tell a different story. For those who never saw Bradshaw play in the 70s, it's challenging to grasp his greatness from stats alone.
The NFL was different back then, with fewer short and easy completions, which explains Bradshaw's lower completion percentage compared to Roethlisberger.
Steelers' Ben Roethlisberger And Terry Bradshaw Both On Mount Rushmore
There is no right or wrong answer. Both quarterbacks have immense value to the organization and are a key reason the Steelers are considered one of the greatest NFL franchises in history.
More must-reads:
- Five best NFL offseason value signings on offense: Bills get great deal with RB extension
- Dolphins humiliated by Lions at joint practice
- The '2023 NFL AP second-team All-Pro' quiz
Breaking News
Trending News
Customize Your Newsletter
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!
TODAY'S BEST
Troubling news emerges on Bears QB Caleb Williams’ workout with HC Ben Johnson
It might have been a good thing the Chicago Bears didn’t play Caleb Williams on Sunday. The Bears might need to hide their second-year quarterback as he irons out his wrinkles in the pre-snap process and with accuracy issues. The No. 1 pick in the 2024 draft struggled with timing and accuracy during the Bears’ joint practice with the Miami Dolphins on Friday. Caleb Williams was inaccurate in the red zone against no defenders On Sunday, Chicago Bears head coach Ben Johnson chose not to play second-year quarterback Caleb Williams against the Dolphins in their first preseason game. Instead, Johnson led a workout with Williams and wide receivers Rome Odunze and DJ Moore before the game. Per Brad Biggs of the Chicago Tribune, the Bears ran a total of 87 plays during the workout. All of the plays were routes in the air with no defenders on the field for the scripted practice. Despite going against no defenders bringing pressure or guarding his receivers, Williams struggled to hit his targets in the red zone. "Williams would stand next to Johnson, who would give him the play," Biggs wrote. "Then, the quarterback simulated a huddle with the player (only one ran a route on each snap) and gave the play call. They’d break the huddle, go to the line of scrimmage, Williams would simulate pre-snap actions and then the play would be run… "Before ending the session with eight deep balls, there was a 25-play set of snaps in the red zone. One thing Williams struggled to connect on was out routes to Moore and Odunze near the goal line. Those throws were not close and Williams consistently led the receivers too much." A closed-door problem for the Chicago Bears The throws weren’t close during routes on air… in the red zone? Williams wasn’t ready to take the field for the preseason game. For all of the flak he’s been getting from practice reports, the quarterback would have been relentlessly mocked for having these issues shown during an NFL Network broadcast. Biggs’ report is troubling, with a month to go before the season. Williams has much to improve upon, and the Bears are very much trying to do so without cameras present for a reason.
Oregon suspends former five-star WR recruit indefinitely
Oregon wide receiver Jurrion Dickey has struggled to live up to expectations in his first two seasons with the Ducks, and he is now in a terrible position heading into 2025 as well. Dickey has been suspended indefinitely by Oregon, head coach Dan Lanning announced on Tuesday. Lanning also suggested that Dickey may not play for the Ducks again. "We have two team rules; that’s respectful, be on time,” Lanning said, via James Crepea of The Oregonian. “There’s some pieces of that where I felt like he needed a break from us and we needed a break from that so we could focus on what’s in front of us right now. "Wishing him nothing but the best, as far as success and want to see him get back to where he can be a contributor somewhere; that might be here that might be somewhere else.” Dickey was a five-star recruit and rated as one of the top wide receivers in the country when he came out of Menlo-Atherton High School in Atherton, California, in 2023. He suffered an injury in his senior year in high school and redshirted as a freshman at Oregon. Dickey has two catches for 14 years during his time with the Ducks. Oregon went 13-1 in Lanning's third season with the program last season. The Ducks lost to eventual national champion Ohio State in the College Football Playoff quarterfinals.
Cubs catcher lost to horrific-looking injury on same day he returns from IL
After working to return to the Chicago Cubs' lineup following an oblique injury, Miguel Amaya suffered a gruesome-looking injury in his first game back with the Cubs on Wednesday night. Running to first base, Amaya just beat out an infield single on a slow dribbler to shortstop when his left foot landed forcefully on the base, causing his leg to buckle and sending Amaya flying down the first base line. Following the injury, Amaya was carted off the field in Toronto with a towel over his face. The emotions shown by Amaya as he was carted off indicated he knew already he would miss more time in a season that has been marred by injuries. After the game, Cubs manager Craig Counsell confirmed Amaya would be going back on the injured list with what was diagnosed as a left ankle sprain. X-rays, however, were negative. The 26-year-old Amaya had just told reporters after being activated from the 60-day injured list that he was thankful he was healthy. Just three at-bats later, Amaya was once again injured. Amaya's three at-bats against the Blue Jays on Wednesday represented his first game action since May 24, when he recorded just two at-bats against the Cincinnati Reds before leaving the game with an oblique injury. In just 96 at-bats this season, Amaya is slashing .281/.314/.500 with four home runs and 25 RBI. Amaya's injury is another blow for the Cubs, who have seen their lead in the National League Central evaporate as the Milwaukee Brewers have now won 12 consecutive games and are 20-4 since the All-Star break. As has been the case in Amaya's absence, Carson Kelly and Reese McGuire will continue to be the dominant presences behind the plate for the Cubs. Joining with Amaya, the duo has helped the Cubs record a 2.8 Wins Above Average (WAA) at catcher, the highest mark of any MLB team. After Amaya's injury, the Cubs would go on to post a 4-1 win over the Blue Jays.
Steelers' Mike Tomlin Delivers Stunning Praise For Common Weak Link On The Offensive Side Of The Ball
The Pittsburgh Steelers have a ton of new pieces to get integrated ahead of the 2025 NFL season. This is true for both sides of the ball, but the biggest X-factor for the team is a group that was in Pittsburgh during the 2024 season, and that is the offensive line. The unit is young outside of left guard Isaac Seumalo, as every other player is in their third-year or younger. Zach Frazier and Mason McCormick seem fairly reliable on the interior, while the tackle spots are going to be something fans keep a close eye on to begin the regular season. Broderick Jones and Troy Fautanu are being relied upon to take care of business at the two tackle spots. Each player was selected in the first round of their respective drafts by the organization, with the franchise even trading up to grab Jones. Jones spent most of the last two seasons at right tackle, but he will be starting on the left side of the offensive line in 2025, which happens to be his natural position. Fautanu missed most of his rookie year in 2024, so he is looking to come into the season healthy, while being able to make a positive impact. Head Coach Mike Tomlin spoke about his tackle situation after practice on Tuesday, and he sounded impressed with the growth he has seen from the two players throughout training camp. "I think they’ve gotten better every day," Tomlin said. "Broderick got slowed by a little day-to-day groin injury there for a spell, but has really been on the uptick since his return. Same with Troy. I like the trajectory of the group. But even though we’re leaving Saint Vincent College, man, we still are very much in development. We’ve got a lot of time in front of us between now and the opener." Fans have been excited to see Fautanu on the field, but a large portion of the fan base has been worried about whether or not Jones would be good enough to start at left tackle. The initial reports out of training camp were a bit concerning, but it seems as though the young player has improved as he has gotten more comfortable returning to the left side. Jones had a rough season in 2024 as he struggled with penalties and giving up sacks. It is important to note that both Russell Wilson and Justin Fields had instances where they held onto the ball for far too long and ran into sacks, but some of that still falls on Jones. Jones and Fautanu were going against two pretty good pass rushers during Pittsburgh's first preseason game against the Jacksonville Jaguars. Josh Hines-Allen and Travon Walker have each been two elite pass rushers in the their careers, and neither tackle allowed a pressure from either player. This is a good sign in Pittsburgh, as protecting Aaron Rodgers is going to be a top priority. Steelers' Tackles Have Been Battle-Tested Throughout Training Camp Both Jones and Fautanu have to go against some of the best in the world every day of practice. TJ Watt, Alex Highsmith, and Nick Herbig is as good of a trio at outside linebacker that anyone will find in the NFL, and they get to test the two young tackles every day. In addition to that, Pittsburgh has also upgraded the secondary. This likely makes Rodgers have to hang on to the football for a little bit longer, which tests the offensive line even more.
PRIVACY POLICY EDITORIAL POLICY CONTACT US
ABOUT YARDBARKER TERMS OF SERVICE
Use of this website (including any and all parts and
components) constitutes your acceptance of these
Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
This site is for entertainment purposes only.
There is no gambling offered on this site.
Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-Gambler.
