x
Steelers Pinpoint Asante Samuel Jr’s Looming Problem
Katie Stratman / Imagn Images

The Pittsburgh Steelers got absolutely demoralized by the Cincinnati Bengals. Ja'Marr Chase went off for 11 catches and 231 yards, while Joe Burrow completed 35 of 44 passes for 409 yards and four touchdowns without an interception. Pittsburgh walked into a divisional showdown and left with a 38-18 loss that raised uncomfortable questions about its defense.

Everybody knew the Bengals had an offense capable of putting up points. Still, Steeler Nation had every reason to expect more resistance from a defense that needed to get after Burrow and make those explosive receivers work for their opportunities. Instead, Cincinnati repeatedly found answers, and Pittsburgh never made its quarterback uncomfortable enough to change the game.

Naturally, that performance put the secondary under a microscope, including Asante Samuel Jr. However, Mark Kaboly offered a more specific explanation during a discussion on Steelers Collective. His concern centers on the matchups that give Samuel trouble, rather than a belief that the cornerback has been ineffective all season.

"Honestly, I don't know if they have an Asante Samuel problem," Kaboly said. "They have an Asante Samuel problem against the Bengals, and a Ja'Marr Chase and Tee Higgins problem. The rest of his stats throughout the season have been above average, if not good."

That distinction matters, even after a loss that made patience difficult. Kaboly's assessment gives Samuel credit for his broader work while acknowledging that Cincinnati presents a different challenge. It also leaves Pittsburgh with a question that cannot simply disappear after a better performance against somebody else.

The Steelers have to find a way to compete with this offense. Chase is difficult for anybody to cover, and Tee Higgins, who added five receptions for 66 yards, gives Burrow another dangerous option. Pittsburgh cannot build its answer around hoping those receivers suddenly become easier assignments.

"Who does match up against those two?" Kaboly said. "Maybe that's where the size comes in."

There is some fairness in that question. Elite receivers embarrass plenty of defensive backs, and Samuel should not carry the blame for everything that happened Sunday night. Coverage becomes a much harder job when an offense keeps finding ways to move the ball and the defense cannot interrupt its rhythm.

Still, acknowledging the difficulty does not erase the responsibility. Pittsburgh needed its secondary to hold up better, regardless of the names across the line of scrimmage. Giving Cincinnati credit and demanding more from the Steelers are two positions that can exist together.

Kaboly also suggested Samuel could bounce back in his next game, while questioning whether he should play every snap. He maintained that Samuel belongs on the field but expressed reservations about those assignments against elite receivers. That is an important limitation for a defense with ambitions beyond beating less dangerous passing attacks.

Steelers Must Find Answers For Samuel's Toughest Matchups

A rebound would certainly help Samuel and a frustrated fan base. It would not automatically settle the concern Kaboly raised. Pittsburgh needs to understand whether this was a bad outing that can be corrected or a matchup problem requiring different help and usage.

That does not mean the coaching staff should panic and overhaul everything. It does mean examining where Samuel is being asked to win, what support is available and whether the same approach makes sense against every opponent. Those are coaching questions worth asking before another talented offense forces the conversation again.

Samuel can be a useful player and still need protection in certain situations. The danger comes when a defense ignores those limitations because the previous week looked better. Pittsburgh has already seen how expensive that can become when Burrow has Chase and Higgins available.

For the Steelers, the next step is proving they learned something from the beating. Fans can accept that Cincinnati has exceptional talent. Watching that talent dictate the entire evening without enough resistance is much harder to swallow, particularly with divisional stakes attached. The answer needs to show up on the field, starting this coming week.

Should the Pittsburgh Steelers change Samuel's role against elite receivers, or give him another chance to respond? Share your Steelers takes on X with @anthonyghalkias, and follow for more Pittsburgh coverage, roster debates and discussion throughout the season.

This article first appeared on SteelerNation.com and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!