
Steel City Underground presents post-game takeaways following each 2025 NFL regular season game that focuses on how the Pittsburgh Steelers performed, key statistics, their opponents and more!
The Pittsburgh Steelers hosted the Indianapolis Colts – the NFL’s top offense entering the game – at Acrisure Stadium in Week 9 of the 2025 NFL regular season with a chip on their shoulders. After being analyzed following two consecutive disastrous games, Pittsburgh’s defense was fired up early and made a statement by successfully securing 6 turnovers and five sacks in a complete corral of the Colts.
The talk ahead of the game was all about how efficient Daniel Jones had been this season as the Colts’ quarterback, how Jonathan Taylor was in the running for Offensive Player of the Year and nearly unstoppable, how well the Indy defense had stood up, and how dangerous the No. 1 offense was due to the number of receiving stars they were fielding.
We wrote about these things ahead of the game, the keys to preventing another loss, and how the Steelers were looking for a reset in Week 9. It turns out that the Steelers were painfully aware of what was needed while some fans scoffed that we’d even suggest a reset was possible.
Taylor truly deserves to be at the top of the discussion for offensive recognition in league awards, but it will sting with the asterisk moment of remembrance that Pittsburgh’s torn and worn reeling defense held him to just 45 yards on 14 carries and allowed the back just 2 catches for 12 yards. The Steelers did that by mixing pressure packages despite being even more shorthanded in the defensive backfield when safeties Chuck Clark and Jabrill Peppers were a gameday scratch and linebacker Cole Holcomb was too ill to take the field. Darius Slay played through two injury situations in the game.
As for Jones, the Steelers mixed things up on the defensive front and stopped sending their edge rushers on an all-out blitz play after play – something that needed adjusted. By allowing T.J. Watt and Alex Highsmith to drop back, at times, and utilizing pressure from Jack Sawyer, Patrick Queen, Nick Herbig as well as stunts on the line with Derrick Harmon in and out of the lineup, a modified nickel and dime package limited Jones to 31/50 passing for 342 yards for just 1 touchdown.
Jones was sacked five times in this match: Keeanu Benton (1) Joey Porter Jr. (1), Watt (1, strip-sack), Highsmith (2, 1 strip-sack).
TRENT JORDAN WATT
@_TJWatt
#INDvsPIT on @paramountplus pic.twitter.com/44KIVr6HBd
— Pittsburgh Steelers (@steelers) November 2, 2025
In other words, the front and middle of the defense limited how efficient and effective Jones could be once the Colts offense became one-dimensional. Michael Pittman Jr led the Indy receivers with 9 catches for 115 yards (Alec Pierce also had 115 yards receiving), but only Josh Downs caught a touchdown pass. The only other Colts touchdown was a Jones keeper just outside the goal line.
The Pittsburgh offense wasn’t shockingly explosive, but it was decidedly efficient with Aaron Rodgers guiding it at quarterback. Rodgers has traditionally been known for good game and clock management, and in this game he continued to work through – and around – what Indianapolis’ defense presented. With a mix of passing and run plays, the offense capitalized largely on what their teammates on defense set up for them.
Jaylen Warren, the primary ball carrier for the Steelers recorded a two-touchdown game on 16 carries for 31 yards.
Rodgers connected with nine different targets in the passing game, including Pat Freiermuth (1 touchdown, 3 receptions for 27 yards). Beside Freiermuth, Calvin Austin III, Darnell Washington, Kenneth Gainwell, Jonnu Smith, Kaleb Johnson, D.K. Metcalf, Roman Wilson, and Warren accounted for 25 catches for 203 yards. Balance led to success.
8⃣ 8⃣ 8⃣ for the TD!
#INDvsPIT on @paramountplus pic.twitter.com/YH7pY1oZff
— Pittsburgh Steelers (@steelers) November 2, 2025
Teams can reset without playing a perfect game. The Steelers showed that on Sunday. Execution for a full 60 minutes is what is expected from every NFL team, and that is the “standard” in Pittsburgh.
Penalties were not nearly as costly this week, but still hurt the team. Porter had a big one that shot the Steelers in the foot.
Roman Wilson’s attempt to give a little something extra on a play that could have just allowed the Steelers to run out the clock (and instead gave the Colts a glimmer of hope in the final quarter) was a costly error when the ball was punched out of his hands mid-hurdle and recovered by Indianapolis.
Rodgers was sacked three times for a loss of 16 yards.
What looked like a muffed punt recovery by Brandin Echols for a touchdown was brought back for the offense to start a drive at the IND 11 that resulted in a turnover on downs instead of a touchdown.
Yes, the Steelers looked like they’d reset. They played complimentary football for a 27-20 win they weren’t intended to be able to do (per NFL insiders and analysts). Stacking this win with another complete game in Week 10 against the Los Angeles Chargers, on the road, would place them back on much firmer footing for the second half of the season.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!