Photo by Nathan Ray Seebeck-Imagn Images

The '2023-24 NFL first-team All-Pros' quiz

Created on November 4, 2025 | Total tries: 318 | Average Score: 20.9 out of 28 (75%) | Quiz FAQ

The 2025 NFL trade deadline has arrived, and one of the big names now on the move is defensive back Sauce Gardner.

Gardner is heading from the New York Jets to the Indianapolis Colts, and is a splash acquisition that shows the Colts believe their 7-2 start isn’t a fluke. Gardner was the 2022 Defensive Rookie of the Year with the Jets, defending an NFL-best 20 passes and intercepting two while making 75 tackles.

But with the Jets once again floundering at 1-7 and Gardner’s 4-year, $120.4 million contract extension set to kick in next season, the Jets decided to take two first-round draft picks from the Colts for the star cornerback.

Which brings us to today’s quiz. Gardner followed up his Defensive Rookie of the Year campaign in 2022 with a second-consecutive first-team All-Pro nod in 2023-24. With that being said, can you name every member of the NFL’s 2023-24 first-team All-Pro roster?

Good luck!

Did you like this quiz? Are there any quizzes you’d like to see us make in the future? Let us know your thoughts at quizzes@yardbarker.com, and make sure to subscribe to our Quiz of the Day Newsletter for daily quizzes sent right to your email!

Quiz Clue: Position / Team / Jersey # | Created on November 4, 2025 | Total tries: 318 | Average Score: 20.9 out of 28 (75%) | Quiz FAQ

SCORE:
0/28

TIME:
5:00

QB / BAL / #8

RB / SF / #23

FB / SF / #44

WR / MIA / #10

WR / DAL / #88

WR / DET / #14

TE / SF / #85

LT / SF / #71

LG / KC / #62

C / PHI / #62

RG / DAL / #70

RT / DET / #58

EDGE / CLE / #95

EDGE / PIT / #90

LB / SF / #54

LB / BAL / #0

LB / NYJ / #56

CB / DAL / #26

CB / NYJ / #1

CB / KC / #22

S / BAL / #14

S / TB / #31

K / DAL / #17

P / LVR / #6

KR / GB / #25

PR / NO / #22

ST / PIT / #28

LS / JAX / #46

Tommy Fradenburg is a freelance writer and an alumni of UNC Chapel Hill currently based in Charlotte, North Carolina. He religiously follows his favorite teams The New York Yankees and Dallas Cowboys (yes, he knows) as well as his alma mater the Tar Heels and West Ham United F.C. in the Premier League. See more of his work on Twitter @tommyfradenburg.

More must-reads: