Three Unique Replacements if Rams Tyler Higbee Retires

"Pitts caught a career-high 88 passes — 20 more than in his rookie season — for 928 yards and five touchdowns. There was more consistency in Pitts’ game, but his 7.5-yard average depth of target was also the lowest of his career. Pitts heads into free agency on a head of steam."

Pitts' breakout year came via a version of the McVay offense, which was coordinated by former Rams assistant Zac Robinson. However, Robinson's offense needs more refinement and with the speed that Pitts was able to create, the prospect of having Pitts with the current Rams tight ends would be a defensive coordinator's nightmare.

Charlie Kolar

Valentine ranks Kolar at ten, with a PFF grade of 77.6 after Kolar played his role with a Ravens team in need of help after getting hammered with injuries.

"Despite being third on the Ravens’ tight end depth chart, Charlie Kolar still manages to have a positive impact on offense," stated Valentine. "He’s not a massive contributor in the passing game despite catching a career-high 10 passes for 142 yards and two touchdowns. Where Kolar makes his money is in the Ravens’ excellent running game."

"Kolar’s 71.5 PFF run-blocking grade was 15th at his position, with the fourth-year tight end excellent at sealing the edge and allowing Derrick Henry (80.4 grade; 14th) to bounce outside or keep his feet churning north to south. The former fourth-round pick is a free agent this offseason and could make some money as a strong run-blocker."

Kolar worked with Rams offensive coordinator Nate Scheelhaase at Iowa State, and his ability as a run blocker would help take the team's 13 personnel package to the next level, helping Colby Parkinson and Terrance Ferguson establish themselves in a more prolific way next season.

Jake Tonges

Tonges was a breakout star for the San Francisco 49ers in 2025, finishing the year with a 77.9 grade as Valentine ranked Tonges as his ninth best tight end in the NFL.

"With Kittle banged up for half the season, the 49ers leaned into 2022 undrafted free agent Jake Tonges for production at the tight end position," stated Valentine. "Tonges entered the 2025 campaign with just one target in his career, all the way back in 2022, but he deputized tremendously for Kittle."

"Tonges caught 40 passes for 366 yards and five touchdowns in 17 games, despite playing eight contests with fewer than 10 total offensive snaps on the field. Like Kittle, Tonges is a strong run-blocker, compiling a 74.4 PFF run-blocking grade in 2025 — the fifth-highest among tight ends. Tonges registered four games with a PFF grade over 80.0, and he also compiled a 90.3 PFF grade in the divisional round against the Seahawks."

Tonges would be the perfect addition as his blocking skills would allow him to assist as a tight end and as a fullback. On top of that, he's perfect for every formation the Rams enjoy using and he's able to play off a variety of teammates.

The one problem is that he's a restricted free agent, and the 49ers seem to love him, thus acquiring Tonges this offseason is likely to be too expensive or just impossible.