Yardbarker
Yardbarker
x
What's behind the slow-moving safety market?
Icon Sportswire/Getty Images

What's behind the slow-moving safety market?

The weeks leading up to and immediately following the official start of NFL free agency saw a whirlwind of trades and huge money doled out to seemingly every NFL player to ever line up at wide receiver.

Yet, despite how important it is for teams to have solid pass defense, one position that showed surprisingly little activity was safety. Kurt Coleman might have been able to reach a deal with the Saints prior to the official start of the league year, but it was mainly because he was cut in late February by the Panthers rather than reaching free agency by playing out his contract. After that, there were few rumblings in the market.

It wasn’t until the fifth day of the league year that the Texans came to terms with former Cardinals safety Tyrann Mathieu, easily the best known and arguably the best skilled of the bunch. Yet even at the top of the safety class, the 25-year-old Pro Bowler could only garner a one-year deal for $7 million. That’s the kind of money little-known slot receivers were getting days before. It’s also about half of what he was slated to get from Arizona in 2018 before the team released him in a cap-cutting move.

Across the board, offers have been low for safeties. Morgan Burnett, the former Packers safety, was said to be seeking $10 million per season. He ended up signing with Pittsburgh a week into the official free agency period for less than $5 million per season over three years. Several young, high-profile safeties, such as Eric Reid, Kenny Vaccaro and Tre Boston, are still available, and plenty of useful veterans are as well, with little indication they’re in anything but a holding pattern for the time being.

"We're barely even getting phone calls, and we're not the only ones," one agent told Jason La Canfora. "You can't even get (BS) offers. We're literally getting nothing. I'm not even talking one year, $3 million. Nothing. And it's not just us."

The situation hasn’t gone unnoticed among media or the players themselves.

Reid’s plight is being connected to the ongoing conversation regarding player demonstrations during the national anthem. He was the first player to join then-49ers teammate Colin Kaepernick in taking a knee during the anthem, beginning in summer 2016. Like Kaepernick, Reid has stated that he no longer plans to protest during the anthem. That certainly hasn’t stopped teams from bypassing Kap, and increasingly some believe that’s the reason Reid has no bidders. For example, Eagles safety Malcolm Jenkins, who has been a leader among players involved in activism causes though has disagreed with Reid about specific tactics, suspects that NFL teams are avoiding Reid the same way they have with Kaepernick. 

“It would be hard to say that he's not getting any calls just on talent alone," Jenkins told ESPN. "I think any team that is considering him is going to weigh his political views and the strong stance that he's taken the last couple years, and that's unfortunate, but it's just kind of what it is.”

An agent told La Canfora that there’s a perception that teams' disinterest in Reid is driving down the market wholesale for the position. Effectively, the agent argues, teams are worried that they can’t shun Reid without it being obvious, so they’re lowballing free agent safeties across the board.

"It feels like, with Eric Reid in the market, and teams not wanting to touch him, that a lot of other safeties are also being held down. Instead of anybody getting $8 million to $9 million per year, no one is getting it."

Given that the NFL has effectively blackballed Kaepernick for more than a full season, it’s hard to blame anyone for that presumption. Still, there are a few mitigating factors with Reid and other safeties that should give pause.

For example, Seattle is still shopping Pro Bowler Earl Thomas. The Seahawks have had something of a fire sale of their once-vaunted defense this offseason, parting with Michael Bennett and Richard Sherman. They have reportedly been in talks with several teams about a potential deal and have even backed down from a steep initial asking price of a first- and a third-round pick.

Furthermore, the draft is considered to be deep at safety, with some analysts suggesting as many as six could go in the first three rounds. So it’s possible teams, as with other positions, are waiting to see how the draft shakes out before potentially meeting with available veterans on the market. After all, big-time collegiate playmakers are available this year, including Alabama teammates Minkah Fitzpatrick and Ronnie Harrison, along with Florida State's Derwin James, Wake Forest's Jessie Bates III and Stanford's Just Reid. 

Considering the recent draft capital used on safeties and the success of the young back-line defenders, it certainly plays a role. Last year alone, three safeties went in the first round and played well as rookies, with the Jets' Jamal Adams, Colts' Malik Hooker and Browns' Jabrill Peppers all getting on the field. Six more safeties were selected in the second round and another two went in the third.

Still, it's odd to see proven, reliable safeties sitting at home. How much teams have been willing to shell out at receiver makes the lull at the position suspicious, though teams have to save money somewhere. At this point, they have leverage to practice patience with the draft looming. After that, it should be easier to draw definitive conclusions, but it sure seems that there has been less of premium placed on what has been a pivotal position in today's NFL.

Mike Tunison

Mike Tunison is a freelance writer based in Alexandria, Va. and the former editor of Kissing Suzy Kolber. You can follow him at @xmasape on Twitter.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!

TODAY'S BEST

Cowboys fans won't like Jerry Jones' update on Micah Parsons standoff
NFL

Cowboys fans won't like Jerry Jones' update on Micah Parsons standoff

With the regular season approaching, the Dallas Cowboys should be aiming to extend EDGE Micah Parsons promptly. But they're still in no rush to do that. Parsons is set to play on the fifth-year option of his rookie contract in 2025 and has requested a trade. Dallas insists it has no plans to move the 26-year-old pass-rusher but hasn't clarified when it will extend him. Giving him a new deal before the regular-season opener against the Philadelphia Eagles on Sept. 4 at 8:20 p.m. ET (NBC, Peacock) seems wise. Dallas owner Jerry Jones, however, said that's not the team's deadline, nor does it need one. "No, not at all," Jones said Wednesday, via Jonah Javad of WFAA-TV in Dallas. "You don't have deadlines when you're playing under contract." Parsons is under contract, but that doesn't mean he must suit up. The EDGE could hold out of regular-season games, like former Cowboys star running back Emmitt Smith did in 1993. The Pro Football Hall of Famer missed the first two games of the season before becoming the league's highest-paid RB at that time. Parsons hasn't said whether he would hold out of regular-season games, but it's apparent he's unhappy with where things stand. "My mouth is closed," Parsons said Wednesday while leaving the practice field in Oxnard, California, via Field Level Media. Jones didn't say if talks with Parsons would resume when the Cowboys return to Texas for their second preseason game against the Baltimore Ravens. The matchup is scheduled for Saturday at 7 p.m. ET. The owner still seems confident Parsons will play on the fifth-year option if Dallas doesn't sign him before the start of the regular season. "Again, all you've got to go on are contracts," Jones said. "We are negotiating for a contract. When you do a contract, you would hope that after a negotiation, that's what both the team and player look to see what our obligations are. I have a lot of respect for the contract." Cowboys quarterback Dak Prescott and wide receiver CeeDee Lamb played the last years of their rookie contracts. Perhaps Jones wants Parsons to do the same. Still, that would be silly. Paying the four-time Pro Bowler should be a no-brainer for the Cowboys, so they should stop wasting time and show him the money.

Former Lakers, Clippers Big Man Joins Phoenix Suns in New Career Path
NBA

Former Lakers, Clippers Big Man Joins Phoenix Suns in New Career Path

One of the most lopsided trades of the last decade in the NBA was a "hallway" trade between the Lakers and Clippers. NBA veteran Mike Muscala was traded to the Los Angeles Lakers in exchange for Ivica Zubac, a young center at the time who needed development, along with Michael Beasley. In a win-now move for the Lakers in their first season with LeBron James, they gave up on a young center that showed promise, for a stretch big that the Lakers felt could help them get to the playoffs.

Troubling news emerges on Bears QB Caleb Williams’ workout with HC Ben Johnson
NFL

Troubling news emerges on Bears QB Caleb Williams’ workout with HC Ben Johnson

It might have been a good thing the Chicago Bears didn’t play Caleb Williams on Sunday. The Bears might need to hide their second-year quarterback as he irons out his wrinkles in the pre-snap process and with accuracy issues. The No. 1 pick in the 2024 draft struggled with timing and accuracy during the Bears’ joint practice with the Miami Dolphins on Friday. Caleb Williams was inaccurate in the red zone against no defenders On Sunday, Chicago Bears head coach Ben Johnson chose not to play second-year quarterback Caleb Williams against the Dolphins in their first preseason game. Instead, Johnson led a workout with Williams and wide receivers Rome Odunze and DJ Moore before the game. Per Brad Biggs of the Chicago Tribune, the Bears ran a total of 87 plays during the workout. All of the plays were routes in the air with no defenders on the field for the scripted practice. Despite going against no defenders bringing pressure or guarding his receivers, Williams struggled to hit his targets in the red zone. "Williams would stand next to Johnson, who would give him the play," Biggs wrote. "Then, the quarterback simulated a huddle with the player (only one ran a route on each snap) and gave the play call. They’d break the huddle, go to the line of scrimmage, Williams would simulate pre-snap actions and then the play would be run… "Before ending the session with eight deep balls, there was a 25-play set of snaps in the red zone. One thing Williams struggled to connect on was out routes to Moore and Odunze near the goal line. Those throws were not close and Williams consistently led the receivers too much." A closed-door problem for the Chicago Bears The throws weren’t close during routes on air… in the red zone? Williams wasn’t ready to take the field for the preseason game. For all of the flak he’s been getting from practice reports, the quarterback would have been relentlessly mocked for having these issues shown during an NFL Network broadcast. Biggs’ report is troubling, with a month to go before the season. Williams has much to improve upon, and the Bears are very much trying to do so without cameras present for a reason.

Phillies superstar may be building Hall of Fame case
MLB

Phillies superstar may be building Hall of Fame case

Philadelphia Phillies designated hitter Kyle Schwarber is in the midst of another impressive season. Schwarber entered Wednesday having posted a .249/.373/.578 batting line in his 528 plate appearances this season, hitting 42 homers while driving in a National League-leading 97 runs. The Phillies slugger was named to his third All-Star Game this season and, according to NBA Hall of Famer Charles Barkley, he should be the NL MVP. Schwarber has been one of baseball's premier power hitters since establishing himself in the majors in 2017. He's in his eighth season of hitting 30 or more homers and has reached the 40-homer plateau three times in his four seasons in Philadelphia. The 32-year-old Schwarber may find himself in elite company when his career comes to an end. He has already hit 326 homers in his career, potentially giving him a chance to reach the 500-home run plateau. If Schwarber does hit 500-plus homers, the narrative around his career may change. There have only been 28 players in MLB history to reach that plateau, 19 of whom are in the Hall of Fame. Two players — Albert Pujols and Miguel Cabrera — are not yet eligible and are expected to be enshrined on the first ballot. The seven players who have not been inducted into the Hall of Fame have been linked to PED use, torpedoing their candidacy. At the same time, his entire candidacy may be based on his home run total. Schwarber has a lifetime .232/.346/.499 batting line over 5,188 plate appearances; although batting average no longer carries much weight for the voters, he would have the lowest batting average of any non-pitcher in the Hall. His 20.7 fWAR has been dragged down by his defense and is unlikely to make him a favorite among the younger voters who put more emphasis on such metrics. Schwarber is marching toward the 500-home run plateau. If he does reach that mark, he could be a polarizing Hall of Fame candidate.