
The New York Jets made the biggest splash of Tuesday’s NFL trade deadline, trading two key pieces from their once-great defense and diving headfirst into yet another rebuild.
In trading former All-Pros Sauce Gardner and Quinnen Williams, the Jets effectively pulled the plug on a defense that allowed the third-fewest points in the NFL just last season. While losing two players of such caliber will sting for Jets fans, they should take comfort in the fact that they received a huge haul of compensation to help turn their sinking ship around.
Gardner, a two-time first-team All-Pro, is less than four months removed from agreeing to a four-year, $120.4 million extension with the Jets, but had seen his play drop considerably under head coach Aaron Glenn’s defense. Since breaking into the league with a 62.7 passer rating allowed in 2022, Gardner has seen that number rise for three straight seasons before topping out at 98.1 in 2025. It is unwise for a team of the Jets' caliber to pay top dollar for any cornerback, and paying $30 million for someone putting up Gardner’s level of production is downright malpractice.
In addition to getting Gardner’s money off the books, the Jets will also get two first-round picks from the Indianapolis Colts. The value of these picks will largely depend on the Colts' record over the next two seasons, but even if they stay at the top of the AFC, those picks give the Jets two strong opportunities to add impact players. Completing the deal is wide receiver Adonai Mitchell, who couldn't find a spot in a crowded Colts receiving corps but is just 18 months removed from being the 52nd overall pick in the draft.
Although the Jets only received one first-round pick in the Williams trade, it might be the most valuable asset they obtained all day. That 2027 selection will be the higher of the two picks the Dallas Cowboys hold — one from their own draft and the other from the Green Bay Packers in the Micah Parsons trade. Considering the Cowboys' volatile organization and their struggling defense, it’s quite possible that the pick lands in the top 10. Add in a second-round pick in 2026, former first-round defensive tackle Mazi Smith and the opportunity to remove Williams’ four-year, $96 million contract from the books, and this deal looks like another long-term win for the Jets.
The Jets are loaded on draft picks pic.twitter.com/0TGuszsTQ6
— FOX Sports: NFL (@NFLonFOX) November 4, 2025
Of course, all of this only means so much if Glenn can’t get the most out of his players, and the Jets aren’t any closer to finding a franchise quarterback for the first time this century. Still, new general manager Darren Mougey now has an opportunity to remake the roster in his image. With eight first- and second-round picks combined in the next two drafts, the Jets can rebuild quickly if they hit on even half of these selections.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!