Cowboys fans are clamoring for Sean Payton after the latest questionable coaching decision by Mike McCarthy.
As strong a coaching candidate as Payton is, though, he may not be the best to get Dallas past its postseason misery.
In the Cowboys' divisional-round loss Sunday, McCarthy OK'd one of the more bizarre plays in postseason history.
In a last-ditch move that backfired phenomenally in the final seconds, running back Ezekiel Elliott snapped the ball to QB Dak Prescott before he was trucked by 49ers linebacker Azeez Al-Shaair.
Prescott quickly passed to KaVontae Turpin, who was tackled immediately, sealing the game for the 49ers.
this play pic.twitter.com/3c5VxptWeB
— Warren Sharp (@SharpFootball) January 23, 2023
Even though McCarthy likely saw the play during practices, he still loved it enough to trot it out as the Cowboys' last-ditch effort to save their season.
Afterward, owner Jerry Jones said the loss had no impact on McCarthy's job status.
Jerry Jones said this loss has no impact on Mike McCarthy’s job pic.twitter.com/he2rCuhCXX
— Jon Machota (@jonmachota) January 23, 2023
That didn't stop several people from clamoring for Jones to make a run at Payton.
Sean Payton to Dallas tomorrow?
— Jamey Eisenberg (@JameyEisenberg) January 23, 2023
Is a first-rounder in the 26-27 range enough to get Sean Payton to Dallas?
— Patrick Daugherty (@RotoPat) January 23, 2023
sean payton should probably be on Dallas Zillow right now.
— Brooke Pryor (@bepryor) January 23, 2023
Payton is a Super Bowl-winning coach who never wore out his welcome with the Saints, as McCarthy has with Dallas.
In New Orleans, Payton left after five consecutive winning seasons and four division titles from 2017-21. His offenses finished first in yards six times and in the top five in points nine times.
Jones' team, however, is looking to escape confounding coaching blunders and heartbreaking endings, so Payton might be the worst possible choice.
In a critical December 2007 game at home against Tampa Bay, Payton called a trick play while the Saints were up, 23-20. The call belongs in the cathedral of bad coaching decisions.
Running back Reggie Bush attempted to flip the ball to wide receiver Devery Henderson on a reverse, but it failed and Tampa Bay recovered the loose ball. The Bucs scored a touchdown on their ensuing 37-yard drive and won, 27-23.
Sean Payton said that one of his biggest coaching regrets is running this reverse play at the end of the 2007 #Bucs game on Week 13.
— Dov Kleiman (@NFL_DovKleiman) January 25, 2022
It led to a fumble, and the Bucs ended up winning. pic.twitter.com/lXwrhmMLEz
Payton admitted when he left New Orleans that play call was one of the biggest regrets of his career.
It didn't kill his aggressive spirit, which is partly why he was able to lead the Saints to their only Super Bowl berth and victory.
But Payton's aggressiveness came back to bite him several other times, most notably in the playoffs.
Moments before the "Minneapolis Miracle" in the 2017 divisional-round loss, he made his infamous SKOL clap, mocking Vikings fans.
Sean Payton on mocking Vikings 'Skol' clap before Stefon Diggs TD: 'It was good playoff fun' https://t.co/BnzDuDzhsf pic.twitter.com/73QD3zQr0x
— Around The NFL (@AroundTheNFL) January 16, 2018
In the "NOLA No-Call" 2018 NFC Championship, a 26-23 loss to the Rams, he called two pass plays after the two-minute warning in a tied game.
Instead of forcing the Rams to burn their final two timeouts and running time off the clock, New Orleans gave the ball back to Los Angeles with 1:41 remaining and one timeout. Kicker Greg Zuerlein attempted the tying field goal with 19 seconds left in regulation.
The no-call on a clear pass interference against the Saints was the headline of the game, but Payton's play-calling allowed the referees to become a factor in the first place.
Knowing the Cowboys' luck over the past 27 seasons, it's just as possible that Payton would only add to the team's heartbreak.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!