In every professional sport, a high first-round pick is expected to not just be in the starting lineup on day one, but to produce. Immediately.
That’s the position in which Colston Loveland finds himself.
"My favorite pick of the draft so far is Colston Loveland to the Chicago Bears..
— Pat McAfee (@PatMcAfeeShow) April 25, 2025
I absolutely love this" ~ @PSchrags #PMSDraftSpectacular https://t.co/oVWDvViArR pic.twitter.com/ivCdDvkxOh
Selected at the ten-spot in the 2025 NFL Draft by Chicago, the tight end out of Michigan will be given all the chances in the world to thrive—and he’d better make some noise, or else there’ll be a whole lot of folks in the Bears’ front office wiping eggs off their faces.
But never fear, Bears Nation, because former Yahoo and ESPN NFL contributor Andy Beherns told Chicago Sports Stuff that Loveland will be just fine.
As for veteran Bears TE Cole Kmet, not so much.
Cole Kmet:
— AJ Shaw (@RealShawFather) May 2, 2025
-Has only finished in the top-10 in receiving yards once.
-A bad route runner.
-Drops a lot of easy passes.
The only thing he's really solid at is blocking. Hence why it makes sense to keep him this year and then move on from next year which will save this team $$$.
Behrens sees Loveland making an immediate impact, saying, “He's just a very gifted receiver, and if Ben Johnson's offense is what we think it can be—and if Caleb Williams becomes what we think he can be—Loveland can be a star, the kind of guy who settles in as an 1,100 yard receiver and gives you eight touchdowns, ten touchdowns, 12 touchdowns—numbers that allow a player to finish in fantasy as the TE1. He has a chance to be really special.”
The pundit was on the Loveland train back in 2023, recalling, “For me, he’s one of those guys like Jordan Addison. When you have NFL draft columns to write, and mock drafts to produce, you have to do your scouting. I still remember scouting Kenny Pickett and Addison [in 2023], and Addison made everything happen for Pickett. I was like, Forget the quarterback, I want this guy.”
As for the vet Kmet, Behrens wasn’t as optimistic. Not even a little bit.
“Kmet is not a perfect tight end, by any means. He's the sort of guy who, if he were attached to an offense that put up 5,000 passing yards, could back into some TE6-ish numbers, [but] I don't think he's a guy who can get it on his own. If Cole Kmet is going to be fantasy relevant, this offense will need to be spectacular, and I just don’t see it.”
Taking all of that into account, Behrens’ final grades for the two TEs won’t be at all a surprise.
“Best case scenario for Loveland will be an A. Kmet is more like a C-minus.”
Cole Kmet was initially “taken aback” when the Bears selected Colston Loveland with the 10th overall pick, but says the goal is to be the best 12 personnel tandem in the league. pic.twitter.com/jgoskHEMH1
— Bears on CHSN (@CHSN_Bears) June 3, 2025
Which could mean that come 2026, Cole Kmet might well be wearing another uniform.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!