
Thirty-three of the Dallas Stars/Minnesota North Stars’ 59 seasons have been played in downtown Dallas.
It’s no surprise, then, that the list of the best 10 players in franchise history has a distinctly Texas flavor. It’s the state that held the Stars when they won their first and only Stanley Cup in 1999 and the location that proved teams in the American South could succeed in the NHL on a sustained scale.
But we didn’t leave the North Stars all the way out of this list. Three of the 10 here played some of their time in Minnesota, including two who never called Dallas home.
The second longest-serving captain in Stars history, Hatcher wouldn’t make this list if points were all that mattered. Hatcher never scored more than 31 points in a season over his 16-year career, 12 of which came with the franchise.
But one All-Star game, two top-10 Norris Trophy finishes and captaincy during the most successful run in team history gets him a spot. The 1999 Stanley Cup is the capper.
Arguments could certainly be made to put Dino higher. He ranks fourth in franchise history in goals (332), eighth in assists (319) and sixth in points (651).
Ciccarelli played nine of his 19 NHL seasons when the team was still in Minnesota and he missed out on the franchise’s halcyon days, something most of the players ahead of him were a part of.
Turco is the franchise leader in games, wins and shutouts as he served as a staple in the post-Cup years from 2001 to 2010.
And while he’s remembered more as steady than spectacular, Turco did finish top five in Vezina Trophy voting three times, including a second-place finish in 2003 when his .932 save percentage and 1.72 goals-against average led the league.
Belfour was a known quantity when he joined Dallas in 1997. He’d already won two Vezinas in his first years with the Chicago Blackhawks.
His signing, though, ultimately put the Stars over the top when they captured the Cup in his second season. In his first, he led the league in GAA (1.88) and in his third, he led in save percentage (.919)
Bellows is a lot like Ciccarelli in that he never played in a Dallas Stars uniform and missed out on the team’s glory of the 90s. But he played 10 of his 17 seasons with the North Stars, making six All-Star teams and still ranks third in franchise history in goals with 342 and fourth in points with 722.
MORE: Dallas Stars’ Best and Worst Coaches Ever, Ranked
Admittedly, there may be some author’s bias to this pick as Lehtinen doesn’t rank in the top 10 in team history in points, though his 243 goals are ninth.
No, Lehtinen was the glue of the Stars’ top line for a bulk of the late 90s and early 2000s. A defensive whiz, he won the Selke Trophy three times and finished in the top 10 in voting for it another six.
Broten is the bridge from Minnesota to Dallas, ultimately playing 992 games for the club over 16 seasons. He was never a superstar, but is such an important piece of the team’s legacy, that he has to crack the top five. Broten’s 867 points rank third in team history.
No defenseman has played in more games or scored more points for the Stars than Zubov, whose power play quarterbacking and strong defense was among the best in the NHL in the 1990s and early 2000s. He finished top 10 in Norris Trophy voting seven times and scored 549 points in 839 games with the club over 12 seasons.
At the time of writing, Benn was just one point away from 1,000 for his career, an 18-season career spent entirely with the Stars. His game may have slowed down with age, but in his prime, Benn was one of the best power-forwards in the game.
He won the Art Ross Trophy in 2015 as the NHL’s leading scorer and ranks second in franchise history in games, goals and points.
It’s going to be a while before someone catches Modano for No. 1 on this list, unless Benn finds the fountain of youth for another five seasons. Modano is in the conversation for greatest American NHLer of all time.
He played 1,459 games with the Stars, kicking things off in Minnesota and finishing in Dallas in 2010. Over those 20 years, he scored 1,359 points and cemented himself as a Hockey Hall of Famer.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!