
When it comes to Edmonton Oilers greatness, you’re basically looking at two different eras: Wayne Gretzky’s and Connor McDavid’s.
Not to spoil it, but those two players are – obviously – the top two players in team history. The real question when determining the other eight of the best 10, is how many from each era get the nod.
Well, let’s just say it’s seven, plus one guy who happened to have the misfortune of missing both eras but ended up a legend in his own right thanks to his greatness for his home country.
Let’s take a look at the 10 best players in Oilers history.
No one in Oilers franchise history has played more games than RNH. The former No. 1 overall pick is now in his 16th year in the NHL, all of which have come with Edmonton.
He ranks eighth in goals, sixth in assists and seventh in points and even at age 33, he’s still – as of early November – putting up more than a point per game.
Fuhr back-stopped four of Edmonton’s five Stanley Cups win from 1984 to 1990. The only reason he didn’t make it for all five is because he missed the postseason in the team’s final Cup run in that 1989-90 season.
Fuhr won the Vezina Trophy as the NHL’s best goalie in 1987-88 and, really, remains underrated thanks to all the firepower he had around him in the 80s.
Captain Canada played 15 of his 19 NHL seasons with the Oilers, both starting and finishing his career in Edmonton. In that time, Smyth scored 296 goals and 631 points, with both figures ranking in the top 10 in franchise history.
He served as a stabilizing force in the post-Cup-run era and then as a bridge to the team’s modern-day resurrection. Smyth is an absolutely beloved figure across Canada and nowhere more than in Alberta.
One of the premier offensive defensemen of all-time, Coffey scored 1,531 points over 1,409 games in his 21-year career. And while only seven of those seasons came with Edmonton, they were massive, as he led the back end for the first three of the Oilers’ Cups of the 80s.
Coffey won the Norris Trophy three times in his career, including twice with Edmonton, and finished top five in that trophy’s voting another eight times total.
A very strong case could be made that Draisaitl deserves at least one more spot up in these rankings. We won’t necessarily disagree, even if we have him at No. 6.
He ranks only behind the No. 4 and No. 1 player on this list in franchise history when it comes to goals, and only behind No. 1 and No. 2 when it comes to points. But with no Stanley Cup (yet), we’re leaving him just outside the top five.
MORE: Oilers’ Best and Worst Coaches Ever, Ranked
Perhaps Anderson’s ranking here has more to do with how he’s regarded in Oilers lore. But, honestly, the man won six Stanley Cups and that’s impossible to deny. Anderson was an All-Star seven times in his 12 seasons with Edmonton and his 417 goals rank fifth in team history.
Arriving to Edmonton just two years after the No. 1 player on this list and then to Los Angeles just two years after that No. 1 player went there, Kurri is forever tied to Wayne Gretzky (spoiler). He was an animal in his own right, anyway, scoring 1,398 points over his 17 NHL seasons and winning five Stanley Cups.
Only 12 of Messier’s incredible 25 seasons came in Edmonton and he was 30 when he left the Great White North. Most of those 12 years were spent with Gretzky, but even after the Great One left, Messier led the team to another Stanley Cup win and won the Hart Trophy as the NHL’s best player. A true legend.
The Gretzky comparisons are unfair. They’re also apt. The NHL had not seen such a dynamic offensive player since Wayne until McDavid hit the scene. He’s won the Hart Trophy twice and the Ross five times.
McDavid has also led the NHL in scoring six times in his 11 seasons and as of early November, he’s on pace to have the highest single-season scoring total ever. The only thing that remains is a Cup.
For this writer’s money, there’s been no more dominant player across North American team sports in my lifetime. For fun, my brother and I used to just occasionally take screenshots of Gretzky’s Hockey Reference page and text to each other when they crossed our mind some 20, 25 years later.
Nine Harts, four Cups, five Lindsays, 10 Rosses, two Smythes, five Byngs. Frankly, he’s No. 1 on all the lists.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!