3 Reasons Anthony Stolarz’s Maple Leafs Deal Makes Sense

The Toronto Maple Leafs made headlines this weekend by re-signing goaltender Anthony Stolarz to a four-year, $3.75 million-per-season contract. At first glance, the numbers and the term might raise eyebrows—but when you dig into the details, the deal makes a lot of sense for both Stolarz and the Maple Leafs. Here are three reasons why.

Reason 1. Stolarz’s Performance Stacks Up

Stolarz’s numbers speak for themselves. Last season, he started 33 games, winning 21 for a .682 winning percentage. That’s slightly better than Joseph Woll’s .671 mark over 41 starts. Beyond wins, Stolarz had a better save percentage (.926 to .909) and a lower goals-against average (2.14 to 2.73).

Reason 2. The Maple Leafs Are Rewarding Experience and Security

Stolarz is 31, five years older than Woll, and has dealt with injuries in the past. Neither goalie has an established track record as a long-term starter, but Stolarz is regarded as the more consistent option in the present.

The Maple Leafs are securing a player who can provide immediate stability while giving Woll time to return from his leave of absence and continue developing. In a position as unpredictable as goaltending, having an experienced, proven option is invaluable.

Reason 3. Stolarz’s Term and Salary Cap Considerations

Stolarz’s contract isn’t just about AAV—it’s about guaranteed money and term. He landed one more year than Woll, ensuring an extra $3.75 million in earnings. By the time the deal expires, he’ll be 36, an age when few NHL players are still competing.

For Toronto, the slightly longer term is a calculated gamble, softened by a rising salary cap. It’s a balance of security for Stolarz and financial prudence for the team.