A look back at Jeff Skinner’s season trying to find a steady role with the Oilers

However, with Edmonton losing their first three games, it felt like the coaching staff had already made up their minds about Skinner. That perspective — likely rooted in concerns about his defensive game — seemed to follow him throughout the season, as Skinner was never really given an extended opportunity in a top-six role and was bumped down to the bottom six after just the third game.

The 5-foot-11 forward played between the third and fourth lines until December, with only brief stints in the top six. Things worsened after Christmas, when he was a healthy scratch for the first time on Dec. 29 against the Anaheim Ducks — the first of six healthy scratches over the next month.

While Skinner’s time in Edmonton didn’t pan out as hoped, two things stand out about him — his infectious smile and his willingness to do whatever was asked of him. He never complained about being benched or demoted, nor did he speak poorly about the situation in the media. Rather, he focused on improving his all-around game, especially on the defensive side of things. Following a series of scratches in late January, his 200-foot game took a clear step forward.

An example of this came when he was inserted back into the lineup against the Detroit Red Wings on Jan. 30. Not only did he score in the game, but he also made one of the best backchecks by any Oiler in the 2024–25 season — hustling to break up a 2-on-1 during a Red Wings attack and followed it up with a series of excellent plays in the games that followed.

Overall, it seemed like Skinner had turned the page from late January onward, adding a more defensive mindset to his game. Additionally, with injuries piling up down the playoff stretch, he played some of his best hockey of the season, tallying eight points in the final 14 games and finished the regular season with 16 goals and 13 assists.

Skinner’s Playoff Debut Finally Arrives

One of his biggest highlights during his time with the Oilers was when he made his long-awaited playoff debut. After playing 1,078 regular-season games, the 15-year NHL vet finally played in the postseason when he suited up against the Los Angeles Kings on April 21.

In just over 11 minutes played in Game 1 against L.A., he registered an assist and tied for second on the team in hits with five. However, the Oilers lost the game 6-5, and he was on the ice for three goals against at 5-on-5. Just like that, he was scratched for the rest of the series and more.

The veteran forward sat out the next 14 playoff games, and it looked like he wouldn’t see the ice again for the rest of the postseason — until Zach Hyman suffered a season-ending injury in Game 4 of the Western Conference Final against the Dallas Stars. This created an opportunity for Skinner to get back into the lineup, and he was given the nod for Game 5, where he made an impact almost immediately playing on the third line against the Stars.

In the first period, after a tough battle in front of the net, he kicked the puck to his stick and slid it between the pads of Casey DeSmith, who had replaced Jake Oettinger, scoring his first-ever playoff goal and helping the Oilers secure a 6-3 win to advance to the Stanley Cup Final.

With Skinner scoring his first-ever playoff goal and having a great Game 5 against Dallas,  naturally, you’d expect him to be in the lineup for Game 1 of the Cup Final against the Florida Panthers, right? Nope. As we saw all last season, big games from Skinner didn’t guarantee anything. With Connor Brown returning from injury, Skinner was the odd man out once again and was scratched for the first three games against Florida. That said, when the Oilers dropped Game 3 against the Panthers 6-1, a shake-up was needed, and the 15-year NHL vet was inserted into the lineup for the final three games of the series.

The Toronto, ON native averaged 12:15 minutes of ice time in the Stanley Cup Final but went pointless in three games, yet one of his most memorable moments came in Game 4, when he gave D-man Dmitry Kulikov a light, pest-like pat on the back and flashed his big wide grin after an Edmonton goal. But like many Oilers, his impact fell short when it mattered most in the Finals, and after being eliminated, the team chose not to re-sign him.

Did the Oilers Give Skinner a Fair Shot?

At 33 years old, he’s still got the hands — evident in the 16 goals he scored during the regular season, some of which were highlight-reel finishes. However, being undersized in today’s NHL is manageable if paired with speed, and that’s where the concern lies with Skinner. NHL Edge data showed his top speed last season was 21.96 MPH, ranking below the 50th percentile league-wide. In the playoffs, it dipped further to just 19.77 MPH, suggesting he never really quite hit his stride when it mattered most.

Still, despite the lack of footspeed the skill was clearly still there, and years from now, when we look back on Jeff Skinner’s time in Edmonton, we’ll likely remain puzzled as to why it seemed the coaching staff didn’t give him a fair shake. Moreover, the lingering question will be whether he deserved a longer look in the top six. I think of the example from Feb. 5 against the Chicago Blackhawks, when, after several games of playing well, he was finally rewarded with an opportunity to play alongside Draisaitl again — his first chance in a few months.

They connected for a beautiful goal, and Skinner picked up two points in the game, yet just two games later, he was back on the fourth line with Mattias Janmark. Or consider the stretches where he’d have a strong game, even score, only to be healthy scratched the very next night.

Overall, Skinner had some bright spots in Edmonton with nice finishes, and he seemed like a heck of a human being during his time with the Oilers, always smiling and laughing with his teammates. That said, I feel Zach Laing summed up the veteran forward’s stint in Oil Country perfectly in his recent article, pointing out that Jeffery Scott Skinner got the short end of the stick last season.