
It’s time for Toronto Maple Leafs fans to accept reality. With the NHL season barely a quarter of the way through, any realistic hope of the Toronto Maple Leafs making the playoffs is gone. The Maple Leafs took a three-goal lead, but the Los Angeles Kings roared back and won 4-3 in a shootout Thursday night. Even a single point felt worth celebrating.
The Maple Leafs sit last in the Atlantic Division, 14th among the Eastern Conference’s 16 teams, and nine points out of a playoff spot. To make matters worse, they have six other teams to climb over just to reach the postseason.
How bad are their chances?
According to MoneyPuck’s Nov. 19 predictions, Toronto has a 1.6% chance of making the playoffs. Only the Vancouver Canucks (0.4%) and the Chicago Blackhawks (1.2%) have worse odds. And let’s not forget that those same Blackhawks just trounced the Maple Leafs 6–3. So, yes, for all intents and purposes, the season is over.
For some Maple Leafs fans, the answer will be simple. Stop watching the games and get on with your lives. There are probably more productive ways to spend three hours of an evening. But what about the more devoted fans? Those of us who will keep watching, no matter how hopeless things look?
Do we spend the next five months sitting frustrated in front of our televisions, computers or phones? Or, perish the thought, spend hundreds of dollars to experience that frustration in person?
Or do we find another reason to watch? With roughly 60 games remaining, perhaps it’s time for a survival guide.
This should be relatively easy for older Maple Leafs fans. We’ve had decades of practice. Younger fans might have a little more difficulty adjusting, particularly those who have grown accustomed to expecting the Maple Leafs to make the playoffs. From here on, treat every victory as an unexpected bonus.
If the Maple Leafs come close to winning, take comfort in the excitement they provided before the inevitable happened. If they get trounced, look for something positive. Perhaps one or two players had particularly good games.
If the goaltender has a terrible night but the rest of the team plays well, appreciate the skaters’ effort. If the skaters collectively decide to take the night off but the goalie keeps them in the game as long as humanly possible, go to bed knowing at least one player showed up.
There’s almost always something positive to take away from a game, even if you have to look pretty hard to find it.
As the season progresses, start deciding which players you would keep and which ones you’d like to see playing somewhere else next season. Then watch the games looking for evidence that supports your conclusions. Better yet, look for evidence that proves you wrong.
Maybe a player you’ve written off begins showing signs of becoming a useful contributor. Perhaps someone you thought was indispensable starts making you reconsider. Instead of simply watching the scoreboard, you’ll have something else to follow.
And unlike the real general manager, you won’t have to worry about salary caps, no-trade clauses or explaining your decisions to the media.
This might be the most important rule of all. Pay particular attention to the development of young players like Easton Cowan and Gavin McKenna. The Maple Leafs’ future success could depend heavily on what these two youngsters become.
Forget about whether McKenna makes a mistake that costs the Maple Leafs a goal. Watch what he does with the puck, how he reads the game, how he responds to adversity and whether he improves as the season progresses. The same goes for Cowan.
A spectacular pass, a clever play or even a glimpse of the talent that made these youngsters such highly regarded prospects can be worth watching, regardless of the final score. And with the Maple Leafs struggling to stay relevant in the playoff race, perhaps now is the time to give these young players more responsibility.
After all, the team has relatively little to lose and potentially a great deal to gain.
Now for the part that might make you question whether we’ve completely lost our minds. Despite everything we’ve just written, we’re not entirely convinced the Maple Leafs are finished. Before their current seven-game losing streak, Toronto went through a 13-game stretch in which they scored 54 goals.
That’s an average of 4.15 goals per game. Granted, they also surrendered 49 goals, or 3.54 per game, but those were some pretty entertaining hockey games.
Being ahead or behind by two or three goals didn’t necessarily mean much. Another goal always seemed to be just around the corner. The Maple Leafs went 7–4–2 during that stretch, collecting 16 of a possible 26 points.
That pace certainly wouldn’t be enough to dig them out of their current hole. But what if the team that scored more than four goals per game is closer to the real Maple Leafs than the one we’ve watched lose seven consecutive games? What if getting healthy allows them to rediscover that offence?
It’s a long shot, certainly. But long shots have happened before.
On Jan. 1, 2019, the St. Louis Blues were sitting at the bottom of the NHL standings. Five months later, they were Stanley Cup champions. Then there was the 2014–15 Ottawa Senators team. On Feb. 10, Ottawa was 14 points out of a playoff position.
Enter Andrew Hammond, a relatively unknown goaltender who quickly earned the nickname The Hamburglar. With Hammond leading the charge, the Senators went on a remarkable 23–4–4 run down the stretch and somehow made the playoffs.
Unfortunately for Ottawa, the golden carriage turned back into a pumpkin in the opening round, when Carey Price and the Montreal Canadiens sent the Senators packing. Still, it was one heck of a ride.
And if you want an example a little closer to home, consider the 1966–67 Maple Leafs. That team suffered a ten-game losing streak, recovered to win seven consecutive games, and then went on to lose only once in 12 games.
Oh, and one other little detail. They won the Stanley Cup.
Probably. The standings are ugly, the odds are worse, and there’s no guarantee that getting healthy will solve the team’s problems. But there’s also no guarantee that the Maple Leafs we’ve watched over the past eight games are the Maple Leafs we’ll be watching for the next 60.
Perhaps they get healthy, rediscover their offence and put together a winning streak that brings them back into the playoff conversation. Perhaps Cowan and McKenna develop into the kind of players who genuinely excite us about the future. Or perhaps the team continues to struggle and gives management every reason to make significant changes before next season.
Whatever happens, there are still reasons to watch. The trick is to stop measuring every game by whether the Maple Leafs win or lose and start enjoying the smaller things. Appreciate a great performance. Celebrate an unexpected victory. Watch the youngsters grow. And remember that even the most improbable comebacks have to start somewhere.
After all, being a Maple Leafs fan has always required patience, resilience, a sense of humour and, occasionally, a very short memory. And if the team somehow beats those 1.6% odds? Well, wouldn’t that be something.
[Note: I want to thank long-time Maple Leafs fan Stan Smith for collaborating with me on this post. Stan’s Facebook profile can be found here.]
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!