x
Auston Matthews Looks Elite, But Something Doesn’t Add Up
IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

An illusion is taking place if, as a Maple Leafs fan, you only studied this graphic. Given Auston Matthews’ stellar season, you might assume that the Maple Leafs were cruising near the top of the Eastern Conference. But you’d be wrong, as Maple Leafs fans know all too well. The harsh reality is that the team is imperilled on a six-game losing streak and sitting at the bottom of the Atlantic Division. No surprise, an 8-12-2 record (18 points) will do that to a team.

Yet, the graphic shows just how well Matthews is playing. His numbers are elite. Matthews ranks in the 98th percentile for offence and 93rd percentile in defence. According to the chart, he has earned a 96 in offensive impact and a 90 in points. In 22 games, the 29-year-old centre has put up 12 goals and 17 assists for 29 points. That puts him on pace for 111 points over 84 games.

It would be his best regular-season total. Looking at his statistics, he’s been over 100 points twice. His highest point total is 107, but he’s also scored 106. Here’s the question Maple Leafs fans have to ask: If your $13.3 million franchise cornerstone is grading out near the very top of the league, why can’t the team win?

What the Numbers Tell Us About Matthews

Looking at the graphic again, Matthews’ 92 assist grade and 83 power-play grade are carrying the load. But his finishing grade is a modest 58. Clearly, he’s driving play and setting up teammates at an elite rate. But his five-on-five goal-scoring efficiency isn’t at its usual lethal level.

Now, looking at the defensive fine print, the 93 overall defence grade and an 87 in defensive impact look strong at first glance, until you see role difficulty at 76 and penalties taken at 62.

So, what’s the takeaway? His numbers show strong two-way results, but not strong hockey in his own zone. The chart is just a quick snapshot of what’s happening with Matthews, and fans would be wise not to read too much into it. It certainly doesn’t explain everything about why Toronto is losing.

Reading the fine print, the green and purple bars measure only regular five-on-five play, based on just 135 minutes of ice time. That is still a small sample of ice time. Furthermore, Matthews’ 29 points come from every part of the game. That includes 10 points on the power play (three goals and seven assists).

The Bottom Line for Matthews and the Maple Leafs

Matthews’ numbers look far better than the Maple Leafs’ season, yet they don’t explain the losing streak on their own. One graphic can’t tell us why Toronto has given up 76 goals in 22 games. Has the bottom six gone quiet? Is the suddenly inept penalty-killing sinking the team? Or is the goaltending failing to hold the team in games?

The graphic makes a solid case for Matthews’ individual start. But sadly, it offers little to a team that desperately needs answers.

This article first appeared on NHL Trade Talk and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!