x
Blues Need to Flip Holloway & Neighbours in the Lineup
St. Louis Blues left wing Jake Neighbours celebrates a goal scored by St. Louis Blues center Robert Thomas (not pictured) next to Boston Bruins goaltender Jeremy Swayman (Joe Puetz-Imagn Images)

20 games into the 2026-27 season, the St. Louis Blues find themselves at 9-9-2 with 20 points in the Western Conference. While strong play from goaltender Joel Hofer has helped the Blues stay afloat, their inconsistent offense is stopping them from finding their full potential. Following Saturday’s 4-1 loss, the Blues have been held to one goal or less in seven of their 20 games, including six of their last 10.

While Head Coach Jim Montgomery has been patient with his forward lines, especially the top line, the Blues’ failure to generate offense calls for consistent lineup changes. A simple swap on the top six could make the difference. Dylan Holloway should move to the second line while Jake Neighbours moves to the first line.

The Finishing Problem

Advanced stats show the Blues play reasonably well on 5-on-5. They have a 50.6% Corsi rating with 44.1 expected goals. The problem is finishing. Their shooting percentage stands at just 7.5%, short of the league average of 8.8%.

The team appears to be aware of this problem. After Saturday’s loss, Neighbours said the team, including himself, needed to drive to the hard areas to create more opportunities and finish them.

“I wish I had the answer for you. I think there obviously needs to be more of a will and a want to go to the hard areas, make subtle plays that create offense and just execution at the end of the day. I can speak for myself, I don’t think I’ve been good enough and it trickles down.”

Neighbours Gives Top Line a Net-Front Presence

Holloway, Robert Thomas, and Jimmy Snuggerud thrive in open ice and off the rush, but they don’t crash the crease when the opposing defense fills the slot. Even without that, Thomas still has 14 points in 20 games, while Snuggerud is on pace for 40+ goals.

Replacing Holloway with Neighbours gives the top line a net-front specialist who can increase scoring without sacrificing a scoring forward. Neighbours has built his NHL career around winning below-the-net battles, screening goaltenders, and burying second-chance opportunities. This style led to 27 goals in 2023-24, followed by another 22 in 2024-25.

Putting Neighbours in front of the net on this line forces the defense to watch him as well as Snuggerud’s shot and Thomas’s passing. In short, the defense has to spread their attention to all three instead of focusing on just two players. This opens more ice for the trio.

Holloway and McTavish Could Be a Strong Duo

Moving Holloway to the second line may seem like a demotion at first glance. However, he has a chance to find his scoring touch again. That depends on him playing alongside Mason McTavish.

McTavish leads the Blues with 53 shots and is second on the team in goals with seven. However, his line has struggled to sustain possession in the offensive zone. Connor McMichael, a newcomer alongside McTavish, is off to a slow start in his Blues career, scoring just two goals while posting a team-worst minus-12.

Holloway is second on the team in shots and assists. As said earlier, the problem has been finishing, not creating chances. However, Holloway’s ability to quickly move down the ice can complement McTavish’s ability to get shots off quickly. Furthermore, McMichael’s playmaking capabilities can help create further chances. Despite the poor plus/minus rating, McMichael is tied for fourth on the team in assists.

Line Change Is Low Risk, But High Reward

The trade-off in swapping Holloway and Neighbours is going without some pure rush speed on the top line. However, what Neighbours brings as a net-front presence is a risk worth taking. Holloway adds speed to a second line that would benefit from quick zone entries.

The Blues play the Anaheim Ducks on Tuesday. It is unknown whether Montgomery is considering any line changes. However, given the offense’s struggles, it cannot hurt anything. The risk is low, but the reward is high.

This article first appeared on The Hockey Writers and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!