Buffalo Sabres Reportedly Hire Marc Bergevin, Josh Flynn

Montreal reached the playoffs in four of his first five seasons as GM, even making a run to the Eastern Conference Final before an injury to star netminder Carey Price cost them a chance at seriously challenging the New York Rangers for the Prince of Wales Trophy.

Bergevin’s Canadiens struggled in the latter period of the 2010s, but ultimately returned to the playoffs during the COVID-19 pandemic. The 2020-21 Canadiens went on a dramatic run to the Stanley Cup Final, winning the Clarence S. Campbell Bowl before losing the Stanley Cup to the Tampa Bay Lightning. It was the Canadiens’ first trip to the Final since their victory in 1993.

Montreal fired Bergevin early in the following season as the Canadiens endured one of the worst starts to a season in franchise history. Bergevin was credited in Montreal with acting boldly and creatively to try to solve his team’s problems, an approach perhaps no better illustrated by his attempt to offer sheet Carolina Hurricanes star Sebastian Aho, or his franchise-altering trade of star defenseman P.K. Subban for future Hall of Famer Shea Weber.

Bergevin made numerous transactions that paid significant dividends for the Canadiens, and one could make the argument that he “won” far more trades than he “lost.” His tenure was littered with savvy moves, such as when he acquired future captain Nick Suzuki (among other assets) in a trade for Max Pacioretty, acquired Phillip Danault and the pick that became Alexander Romanov for two rental wingers in Tomas Fleischmann and Dale Weise; or when in January 2020, he traded a fourth-round pick for Marco Scandella, only to flip Scandella a few months later and receive a second-round pick (and a fourth-rounder) in return.

But with those big moves, many of which worked out for Montreal, also come a few high-profile mistakes. His major free agent signing of Karl Alzner was nothing short of a disaster, and his move to trade Mikhail Sergachev for Jonathan Drouin did not age well.

Bergevin also came under fire later in his tenure as GM for reportedly failing to “modernize” the Canadiens’ hockey operations department. The team reportedly lagged behind its peers in terms of the modernization, as Sportsnet’s Eric Engels reported in 2022 that the Canadiens did not have an in-house analytics department or at the time employ a dedicated skills coach.

From the Sabres’ perspective, the positives and negatives of Bergevin’s Canadiens tenure aren’t hugely relevant. What matters most is what Bergevin will be able to bring to Buffalo in his capacity as associate GM, and the key thing he’ll offer Kekäläinen is an immense amount of high-level hockey operations decision-making experience.

Kekäläinen’s work is far from over, as The Athletic’s Pierre LeBrun reported yesterday that the Sabres requested permission from Columbus to speak with assistant GM Josh Flynn, someone Kekäläinen worked closely with during his days running the Blue Jackets. According to LeBrun, permission was granted.

Flynn’s background is specifically within hockey administration, and in Columbus, Flynn is responsible for leading “salary cap management” and “contract negotiation,” according to his listing on the team website.

After firing Karmanos, the Sabres have two remaining assistant GMs on the staff who are holdovers from the Adams regime: Jerry Forton, who oversees amateur scouting, and Mark Jakubowski, who per Fairburn “mostly handles contracts.” It remains to be seen if Kekäläinen’s plans for his front office involve any other departures, or only just additions such as Bergevin’s.

There is no clarity at this time as to what major responsibilities Bergevin will hold in the Sabres front office. Karmanos’ significant responsibility was building and managing the AHL’s Americans, and it’s unclear whether Bergevin will directly take on that role.