
Vancouver Canucks fans don’t need anyone to explain that the defence has become a problem. The numbers are ugly, the losses are piling up, and watching opponents find open space around the net has become increasingly familiar.
Through 18 games, Vancouver has surrendered 77 goals, the most in the NHL. The Canucks are allowing an average of 4.53 goals per game and have given up at least five goals in half their games. Their penalty kill isn’t helping either, operating at just 64.44 percent. Thursday’s 6-2 loss to Winnipeg was another reminder of just how far this group has to go.
But perhaps the more interesting question isn’t simply why Vancouver is defending so poorly. It’s whether the organization is asking too much of a young group that hasn’t had enough time to grow into its responsibilities. The departures of Quinn Hughes and Marcus Pettersson left enormous holes on the blue line. Those aren’t just two names missing from a lineup. They represent experience, puck-moving ability, defensive awareness, and the kind of composure that can settle things down when an opponent starts pushing.
Now, Zeev Buium and Tom Willander are getting significant NHL minutes as they learn the trade. Filip Hronek and Jamie Oleksiak are being asked to provide stability, but even experienced defencemen can only do so much when the overall structure isn’t working. Add Thatcher Demko’s absence until at least late December, and the margin for error gets even smaller.
Here’s something Canucks fans should consider: a rebuilding team has to let its young players make mistakes. That’s part of development. But there’s a difference between giving young defencemen an opportunity and putting them in situations where they’re constantly trying to survive.
Manny Malhotra has a difficult job. He needs to establish a defensive identity while developing players who are still learning what it takes to play regularly at this level. The Canucks don’t need to fix everything overnight, and a few more losses won’t necessarily mean the rebuild is failing. But they do need to show signs of progress. Better coverage, more reliable penalty killing, and fewer breakdowns in front of their own goalie would be a good start.
Fans can live with growing pains. What gets harder to accept is watching the same mistakes happen night after night without seeing much change.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!