Can Robertson Ever Be Physical Enough for the New Maple Leafs?

When the Toronto Maple Leafs talk about reshaping their identity, the word “physical” comes up a lot. Brad Treliving and Craig Berube want a team that can win puck battles, grind through playoff series, and impose itself on opponents. That raises a hard question: where does Nick Robertson fit into that picture?

Is Robertson a Skilled Scorer in the Wrong Role?

Robertson’s offensive instincts have never been in doubt. He shoots well, creates chances in space, and brings energy when he’s in the lineup. The problem is that he hasn’t stuck. Injuries have slowed him, but even when healthy, he struggles to carve out a regular role. He isn’t a natural bottom-six grinder, and yet he hasn’t convinced management he can handle the responsibilities that come with top-six duty on a contending roster.

Fans point out that Robertson doesn’t generate many high-danger chances. He can shoot from the perimeter, but getting inside—where playoff goals are scored—hasn’t been his game. At his size, even when he throws his body around, the impact is minimal. He has a bit of a mean streak, but more often than not he gets bounced around in heavy games.

Is It Time for Robertson to Get a Fresh Start?

The Maple Leafs now have a crowded forward group. Players like Max Domi, Bobby McMann, and new additions such as Dakota Joshua or Nicolas Roy (depending on how the lines shake out) are competing for the same spots Robertson might target. Unless he forces his way into a top-six role, the numbers don’t work in his favor.

That’s why so many believe it might be time to move him. He’s young enough to help another team, perhaps one with less pressure and more opportunity. In a different environment, his skill set might shine instead of being overshadowed by what he isn’t.