x
Defense Is the Capitals’ Biggest Weakness
Washington Capitals defenseman Cole Hutson (Daniel Kucin Jr.-Imagn Images)

A quarter of the way through the 2026-27 NHL regular season, the Washington Capitals are becoming a concern. They have dropped their last four contests and six of seven in November. They are sliding down the standings, currently sitting seven points out of a wild card spot and sixth in the Metropolitan Division.

Their power play is still a consistent issue, underperforming players are getting major ice time, and last season’s top scorers are not scoring at nearly the same rate, to name a few issues. While they have struggled all over the ice in their 10-10-0 start, defense has been the clearest area of weakness.

They are allowing 3.40 goals per game, the 12th-worst record in the league. They allowed 23 goals over their last four games. While goals against can be partially attributed to goaltender failure, a goalie needs an effective defense to back them up and make their job easier.

The Makeup of the Blue Line

The Capitals’ defense looks good on paper. They are large and physical, with a few also contributing offensively. Jakob Chychrun was the team’s third-highest scorer last season, and the defense scored 55 goals overall. This season, Cole Hutson has been a top offensive defender, scoring five goals and adding 10 assists.

Vincent Desharnais and Rasmus Sandin have both been out for extended periods. Desharnais has been out recovering from an appendectomy, and Sandin has yet to make his season debut after undergoing ACL surgery. They are both expected to make their returns soon, which could add some depth and strength to a struggling defense.

The biggest bodies on the blue line are Desharnais (6-foot-7, 230 pounds), Justin Holl (6-foot-4, 200 pounds), Jack St. Ivany (6-foot-4, 197 pounds), and Chychrun (6-foot-3, 215 pounds). The remaining members are all at least 5-foot-11. Size is not an issue for the Capitals; rather, the team’s overall defensive system and strategy are failing.

Spencer Carbery Addresses Issues

Head coach Spencer Carbery addressed the team’s defensive issues on 106.7 The Fan’s radio show, Sports Junkies. He noted two areas of weakness: a lack of protection at the net front, and giving up goals off the rush.

“We’re not doing nearly a good enough job protecting our net front. So those are battles. Those are competitiveness. That’s getting underneath sticks. If you look at a lot of our goals, you go like, ‘Geez, teams are scoring a lot on tips, rebounds, right at the net front.’ So we have to do a better job of that,” he said.

The Capitals are among the tallest and heaviest teams in the league this season. While size can come as a defensive advantage, strategy and skill must also come into play to protect the puck, especially at the front of the net. Both forwards and defensemen need to establish their positioning and use strategic techniques to throw the opposition off their game and regain possession.

“It’s a little bit of technique because you have to pop a stick at a certain time when you see a shot coming. It’s a little bit of digging in, physicality,” Carbery noted. He went on to explain that even smaller players can defend a larger opponent easily with the right timing and skill.

The team also needs to tighten up further from the net. “A lot of goals we’re giving up are coming off of – they have the puck maybe at their blue line or in their end, and then they’re skating at us, and they’re shooting in our net. That would be called a rush goal,” the coach explained. “So we’re giving up a lot of rush goals, whether it’s a two-on-one, three-on-two, or rush coverage, which we need to do a better job of. And a lot of that is coming off of turnovers and puck management.”

Concerning Numbers

The numbers tell the story when it comes to Washington’s defense. At even strength this season, they have controlled 50.2 percent of shot attempts and 51.4 percent of scoring chances, yet only 47.9 percent of high-danger chances. They are breaking down in their own end and giving up prime scoring opportunities.

Goaltending has not been at its best, either. Logan Thompson has a career-worst .878 save percentage (SV%) and 3.42 goals-against average (GAA). His backup, Charlie Lindgren, also has career-worst numbers with an .865 SV% and 3.47 GAA. Both goalies have been solid and reliable in past seasons, with Thompson even receiving Vezina Trophy votes last season. Clearly, there is a deeper issue going on than just a decline in goaltending.

A New System

The Capitals use a man-on-man defensive system that should, in theory, work well given their size advantage. However, there are far too many cracks in the system for them to continue as they are. They may benefit from an alternative defensive approach, especially given the overhaul their roster went through this offseason. The newest iteration of the roster seems not to be clicking in Carbery’s defensive system the way it has in seasons past.

He was asked if he would be willing to overhaul the defensive system after watching it break down through the first quarter of the season. While Carbery did not dismiss the idea entirely, he seemed keen to make a few more tweaks before starting fresh with a new play style.

“What gives me confidence…we’ve essentially played the same systematically with small little tweaks over the last four years. We’ve been successful at times. I believe in what we’re doing, and I think we can get there to where we can do it at a high level,” he said.


Spencer Carbery, Washington Capitals (Jess Starr/The Hockey Writers)

He went on to take ownership of the team’s defensive failings and showed awareness that there is cause for concern at the moment. “Is it showing right now? No. Is it giving me concern? Yes. Do we need to help the new players that we have inside of our system get this thing dialed in and be able to execute it consistently more often? Absolutely. Do I need to challenge some of the guys that have been here and perform this structure at a high level? Yeah, they need to do a better job of it as well. And do we as coaches need to do a better job of implementing it, emphasizing it, and teaching it? Yes, we do too.”

He admits that it may be time for a change, but emphasizes that change takes time, consistency, and comes with growing pains. However, Carbery continues to show his leadership as head coach and his belief in the team that the organization worked so hard to build.

“It’s not all doom and gloom. Can we become a good team? Yes, we can. We absolutely can. But we need to continue to focus on what we’re hanging our hat on as a team, and what it’s going to look like consistently night to night,” he explained, adding, “I know it’s a weird answer, but I’m not as worried about our results right now.”

The Capitals must turn things around quickly in order to prevent digging themselves a hole that they cannot climb out of come the playoff push. Whether it means tweaking and tightening up their current defensive system or trying a new one altogether, one thing is clear: it is time for change. Washington is seeking a win against the Boston Bruins and Philadelphia Flyers before American Thanksgiving.

This article first appeared on The Hockey Writers and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!