x

It would appear that there is some confusion about the status of the Toronto Maple Leafs’ first-round pick; will it go to the Boston Bruins or the Philadelphia Flyers? According to Kevin Kurz of The Athletic, both remain contending for an extra 2027 selection.

Given the Leafs are 8-12-2 and falling down the Eastern Conference standings, this discussion has revived itself because two teams are currently in play for the selection and where it’ll lie, based on where the pick ends up. Let’s dive in.

On March 7th, 2025, the Maple Leafs made a pair of additions in an effort to help themselves amid a 52-win, 108-point campaign, surging into their Stanley Cup Playoff berth in 2025. Toronto made trades with the two aforementioned teams, acquiring forward Scott Laughton from the Flyers and defenseman Brandon Carlo from the Bruins. In each of those deals, a first-round pick was included, each with conditions. Philadelphia received a conditional 2027 first, and Boston a conditional 2026 first.

Here are the Boston conditions mentioned in the NHL’s Trade Summary List, according to Chris Johnston of The Athletic:

In the event Toronto transfers their 1st rnd pick in 2026 NHL Draft to Chicago (pursuant to an earlier trade) or Toronto’s 1st rnd pick in 2026 NHL Draft is a top 5 pick, then Toronto will instead transfer their own 1st rnd pick in either the 2027 or 2028 NHL Draft to Boston (whichever of those picks is not transferred to Philadelphia pursuant to an earlier trade)

To stay in chronological order, let’s turn to Boston’s side of things. Based on the writing, the conditions on the 2026 1st stated that if the Maple Leafs’ pick ended up in the top-five of the 2026 Draft order following the NHL Draft Lottery, the Bruins would have to wait for their chance at gaining another top-32 pick. At the lottery, Toronto’s downturn in 2025-26 gave them the fifth-best odds for the No. 1 pick. Alas, they won the lottery, ultimately selecting Gavin McKenna with the first overall selection.

Now, here are the Philadelphia conditions mentioned in the NHL’s Trade Summary List, according to Chris Johnston of The Athletic:

If Toronto’s 1st rnd pick in 2027 NHL Draft is in Top 10, then Toronto has the option to retain such pick and instead transfer their 1st rnd pick in 2028 NHL Draft to Philadelphia. If Toronto trades their own 2028 1st rnd pick (in a subsequent trade) prior to the 2027 NHL Draft, then the condition on 2027 pick is removed and Toronto’s own 2027 1st rnd pick shall transfer to Philadelphia.

So now what? Considering the Maple Leafs, on that very same March 7 date, sent a 2027 first to Philadelphia, there is now a conflict of interest between the status of who gets what. To clarify now, the pick is in play for 2027 between either side. Kurz reports that the Maple Leafs have the option to send the pick to either team if they finish in the top 10 of the 2027 NHL Draft. Whoever they choose to give the 2027 first to, the 2028 first for Toronto gets sent to the other team, unprotected, no conditions.

If the 2027 pick ends up outside of the top 10 following the 2027 NHL Draft Lottery, it automatically becomes owned by the Flyers, and the Bruins will receive the 2028 first-rounder, unprotected. Wherever Toronto finishes in 2028, that team will benefit from no loopholes. If the Leafs continue the downturn they’re in.

As of now, it’s hard to see Toronto willingly granting Boston a top-10 draft selection as a historic rival who has dismantled their deep playoff run hopes on several occasions in the 21st century; however, there is also risk in granting Boston the ability for an unprotected pick that can line up anywhere and is dependent on your team’s performance. If not for that top 5 protection Toronto had on that 2026 1st, imagine where the NHL would be right now, if Boston owned that pick and Toronto did not have a future pillar forward in McKenna.

This article first appeared on Pro Hockey Rumors and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!