One of the prominent reasons for the New York Rangers’ downfall last season was their drastic drop in power-play production. With largely the same personnel, they went from a 24.1% power play in 2022-23 and a 26.4% power play in 2023-24 all the way down to a 17.6% power play in 2024-25. That represented a drop from the seventh-best and third-best power plays all the way down to the fifth-worst last season.
They started last season with most of the same power-play weapons that had allowed them to be so successful in seasons prior: Adam Fox, Artemi Panarin, and Mika Zibanejad up top; Chris Kreider as an elite havoc-creator and quick-strike finisher netfront; and Vincent Trochek around the slot area. They also had skilled, versatile players like Alexis Lafreniere, Filip Chytil, Zac Jones, Reilly Smith, Kaapo Kakko, and other players who could either form a respectable second unit or be intermixed to create two balanced units. But through a combination of injuries, trades, and underperformance, the Rangers’ power play fell into disarray.
While there are some personnel changes going into this season, the Rangers still undeniably have the skill to improve upon their bottom-five power play percentage from last season. Chytil, Jones, Smith, Kakko, and Kreider are the most notable losses, while J.T. Miller, the ascendence of Will Cuylle, and the continued development of Gabriel Perreault are the major additions.
The Rangers have the talent to be far better on the power play than they were last season. Here, we will investigate what went wrong and some possible ways to fix it.
While there was a lot of reshuffling between the two different power play units last season, for the most part the top of the umbrella for the first unit consisted of Panarin, Fox, and Zibanejad. This combination had been lethal in the past because of the variety of different skills each player possessed: Fox is a master of poise and puck possession, Panarin is a great stickhandler and playmaker, and Zibanejad was one of the league’s best one-time threats.
Last season, for the most part, Panarin and Fox performed as expected. Zibanejad, however, did not. He struggled to get his shot off, was often wildly inaccurate with his release, and declined in his ability to make smart reads and pass out of trouble. His drop-off caused the top power play’s cohesion and effectiveness to decline markedly. Defenders were able to worry less about Zibanejad’s shot, or they were able to pressure him and create a turnover.
Going into this season, new head coach Mike Sullivan cannot be as reluctant as former head coach Peter Laviolette to juggle around the top of the power play to best complement the skills of Panarin and Fox. Zibanejad should get the first chance given his pedigree, but if he falters as he did last season, Sullivan needs to be willing to be flexible and make a change.
A major, if underappreciated, key to any power play is the ability to win puck battles. The majority of shots taken do not go in; instead, they create loose puck opportunities. That, combined with chipped pucks/rims into the zone from breakouts, passes that get tipped or deflected, and faceoff battles, can be the difference between a power play getting comfortably set up or having to spend an extra 15-20 seconds breaking back into the zone.
Skill was never an issue for the Rangers’ power play last season. When Panarin and Fox had the puck, more often than not, they made the right play and created a good opportunity. But winning these vital puck battles was an issue, and it hampered the Rangers’ ability to get their power play set up and maximizing their chance creation.
Kreider and Zibanejad were big culprits here. Kreider’s struggles were especially pertinent, as the net-front player on the power play is involved in almost every battle. It is his job to get to loose pucks, win battles, and create time and space for the players up top. One of the reasons the Rangers’ power play looked so much more rushed than usual last season was this inability to win as many puck battles.
This change can be realized through more effort from the highest skilled players on the team, but it can also be accompanied by personnel changes. Cuylle is an example of a player who earned his way onto the power play last season with his hard work and ability to get to the dirty areas of the ice. If some of the more talented players on the Rangers are struggling to win puck battles again this season, I would love to see a player like Cuylle get put in front of the net on Panarin and Fox’s power play to add an additional element of compete and grit.
While it is difficult to justify this claim with a statistic, it was clear from watching last season that the Rangers’ breakout was less effective. It looked like less of a tactical issue and more an issue of players trying to do too much individually, especially late in the season, along with the players without the puck not providing enough puck support.
The overall team struggles the Rangers endured were also likely a major factor in their power-play decline. When a team is struggling like the Rangers were, it is easier to grip the stick a little tighter on the power play and to feel extra pressure to score. This looked to be the case at times last season.
Nearly everything went wrong for the Rangers last season, and the power play was no exception. The good news is that the Rangers have the talent to be successful on the man advantage. But regardless of talent, producing on the power play is not an easy feat in the NHL, and the Rangers will have to do more with the talent they have if they want to experience more success. Hopefully, a fresh start to a new season, combined with implementing some of the changes above, will allow the Rangers’ offensive players to have more success on the man advantage this season.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!