Yardbarker
Yardbarker
x
Habs Analysis: Kaiden Guhle Injury Leads To Surprising Results
David Kirouac-Imagn Images

When Montreal Canadiens defenceman Kaiden Guhle was forced to miss the remainder of the season with a serious laceration on his leg, many assumed the team was in for a very rough ride down the final stretch of the season.

The assumption was rooted in logic, as Guhle absorbs an unreasonable amount of ice time for a team that struggles from a defensive standpoint.

Now that he’s been held out of action for eight games, we have a much better understanding of how the Canadiens have played without the 23-year-old defenceman. At the risk of borrowing a sentence from clickbait artists, the results are quite surprising to say the least.

Team Impact

Before we get going, it’s important to remember that we’re dealing with different sample sizes. Data analysis was invented for this very purpose, using smaller samples to project future developments, however, I still feel the need to remind everyone that there’s a significant discrepancy in the available data, as the Canadiens played 44 games with Guhle, and just eight without.

That being said, the eight games without him have produced some very encouraging results for the team.

With Guhle in the lineup, the Habs managed to control a little more than 48 percent of the shots (25th), 46.4 percent of the expected goals (27th), and 45 percent of the high-danger scoring chances (29th).

Without Guhle in the lineup, the Habs have controlled 50.2 percent of the shots (13th), 52.7 percent of the expected goals (8th), and 55 percent of the high-danger scoring chances (8th).

The uptick in high-danger scoring chances is particularly interesting, as it’s one area in which the Habs have struggled since Martin St-Louis took over as head coach.

There are other factors to consider beyond Guhle’s absence, and I don’t want to give anyone the impression that Guhle was the lone player dragging the team down when he was healthy, but there’s no denying the shocking disparity in results.

Individual Impact

Almost every defenceman has enjoyed an uptick in possession stats since Guhle’s injury. The only player whose shot share numbers declined is Alexandre Carrier, though we expected his fantastic stats to normalize at some point.

Both Lane Hutson and Jayden Struble are controlling over 55 percent of the shots in the last eight games, while Mike Matheson finally made it to the positive side of 50 percent without Guhle in the mix. Both Hutson and Struble have also controlled over 60 percent of the expected goals, yet another impressive improvement. Believe it or not, Hutson is playing less often at 5v5, with the bulk of Guhle’s minutes being absorbed by Carrier.

Even the bottom pairing of Arber Xhekaj and David Savard improved, which is quite a feat when you consider Savard’s stats tend to be well below-replacement.

Montreal Canadiens Brass Tacks

So, are the Canadiens really a better team without Guhle?

Statistically speaking, yes, they have been a better team in the last eight games, with important improvements in key areas.

But we need to keep Carrier’s numbers in mind, as he’s starting to suffer the same fate as Guhle, which includes very difficult assignments, almost unlimited ice time, and consequently, fairly ugly underlying numbers.

With Guhle in the lineup, Carrier controlled over 51 percent of the shots, scoring chances, and expected goals. Without Guhle there to absorb the most difficult minutes, Carrier has only controlled less than 47 percent of the shots, scoring chances, and expected goals.

It’s a testament to Guhle’s usage in the NHL, the hockey equivalent of dipping someone in delicious barbecue sauce before throwing them to the wolves. Not only does he play against the best opponents, he’s often forced to perform on his offside, which, in turn, makes everything much more difficult. Puck retrievals and zone exits, in particular, suffer when a defenceman tends to have the puck on his backhand.

However, there’s no denying Guhle is yet to reach the point where the underlying numbers would suggest he has what it takes to be a No.1 defenceman in the NHL, and the last stretch of games does indeed confirm that losing him to injury did not result in a death knell for the Montreal Canadiens, as many predicted.

All Montreal Canadiens statistics are 5v5 unless otherwise noted, via Natural Stat Trick.

This article first appeared on Montreal Hockey Now and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!

TODAY'S BEST

Jack Roslovic's waiting game may have cost him potential contract offer
NHL

Jack Roslovic's waiting game may have cost him potential contract offer

Free agent Jack Roslovic’s waiting game may have cost him a potential contract offer from one team. The Canucks have “cooled off on pursuing” the top remaining UFA, writes The Athletic’s Thomas Drance. There were talks between the Canucks and Roslovic’s camp last month, Rick Dhaliwal of CHEK and The Athletic said at the time, leaving them as one of a small list of confirmed suitors. It wasn’t without precedent, either. Vancouver had approached Roslovic last summer as well, before he ended up taking a one-year, $2.8M contract with the Hurricanes. That deal saw him tie his career-high of 22 goals in 81 games while also seeing more time at center than he did in 2023-24, likely sparking some optimism that he could help fill out the Canucks’ underwhelming depth down the middle. Nonetheless, it appears Vancouver’s braintrust has now pivoted to only pursuing long-term solutions to supplement anchor Elias Pettersson and, ideally, injury-prone but high-ceiling Filip Chytil in a top-nine role. “Vancouver is still in the market to land a centre, but the trade market is viewed as a more likely and realistic route of addressing the club’s greatest remaining need,” Drance said. “Vancouver would execute a trade today if the deal returned a credible middle-six centre — even if that centre had more of a defensive bent to their game.” The Canucks still have $3.27M in cap space left to facilitate a deal, per PuckPedia. As for Roslovic, he’s getting into crunch time with only one-year deals and PTOs available for most everyone at this point of the offseason. Sportsnet’s Elliotte Friedman reported in early August that there were five teams with legitimate interest in him but that he was taking his time to make a decision. Even with that intrigue and proven top-nine capability without much risk of regression — he’s still just 28 — a multiyear pact may simply be out of reach for him at this point. At the beginning of the summer, AFP Analytics projected him to receive a three-year deal worth north of $4M per season. With the way the market has broken, though, he might need to settle for another one-year deal at a comparable value to last year’s $2.8M cap hit.

Steelers undrafted rookie reportedly upset Mike Tomlin before being cut
NFL

Steelers undrafted rookie reportedly upset Mike Tomlin before being cut

The Pittsburgh Steelers surprisingly had a few quality undrafted free agents during 2025 training camp and preseason, as many of them have put up an actual fight to make it to the 53-man roster. Unfortunately, there is very little room on the team, so some very tough decisions will have to be made on that front. Guys like Max Hurleman and JJ Galbreath have been stating their case throughout camp and into gameday, giving the coaching staff a good problem. One decision was surprisingly easy, however. During his weekly Q A chat, insider Ray Fittipaldo was asked about undrafted rookie Roc Taylor and why he was let go right after the preseason Week 2 game against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. He spoke about something that happened right before that contest. "[Roc Taylor] actually got in Tomlin's doghouse at the joint practice," Fittipaldo said. "Not sure if that's the sole reason he was cut, but maybe part of it." Fittipaldo would not expand on what happened, but head coach Mike Tomlin saw enough of the rookie before gameday. It looked like Taylor would at least get first dibs on a practice-squad spot if he was released on roster cutdown day, but now, it seems like his chance of developing in Pittsburgh is gone entirely. Now, he is just hoping someone gives him a call for a chance to be on a practice squad elsewhere. It seemed like Taylor's stock was rising after preseason Week 2. Hurleman had a very rough game, and the former Memphis Tigers standout had three receptions for 39 yards against the Bucs. He was the second-leading receiver on the team, only behind Roman Wilson. It looked like he was forcing himself onto a roster spot, but apparently, Tomlin might have just been waiting until after the game to tell him to pack his bags and try again somewhere else. Steelers' recent receiver issues make Taylor cut even more concerning What makes this decision even more rough is the fact that the Steelers have three receivers who are not healthy at all. Calvin Austin III is trying to return after missing multiple weeks of practice with an injury, Ben Skowronek recently developed a toe issue and utility man Jonnu Smith has barely participated in practice since July. Spots were opening up for undrafted rookies to take, but Taylor may have said or done something inexcusable enough to lose that chance. The Steelers entered training camp with questionable wide receiver depth, and now it's only more concerning. Wilson's recent development has been the bright spot of the preseason at that position, as Scotty Miller has been taking over the role of WR3 since the game against Tampa Bay. That's why they brought in another possibly injured veteran, Gabe Davis, for a visit, and now they may be hoping that he does not sign elsewhere. Instead of Taylor taking the opportunity to push for a roster spot, guys like Hurleman and Brandon Johnson will be looking to make the team and stick around as numerous players recover from their injuries. With Davis having another visit on Wednesday and the Steelers playing in the preseason finale on Thursday, he most likely will not be signed until after that game. That means the bubble players can prove to the team that they don't need him. It's not public in regards to what Taylor did to get himself in trouble, but he could have had this prime opportunity to be on an active roster as an undrafted rookie. He could have easily been above Hurleman and Johnson on the depth chart. Instead, he is just hoping he makes any team's practice squad now.

Shaquille O'Neal makes peace with longtime enemy — mostly
NBA

Shaquille O'Neal makes peace with longtime enemy — mostly

Shaquille O'Neal and Dwight Howard patched things up Sunday after years of feuding. But even while describing their rapprochement, O'Neal couldn't keep from teasing his longtime nemesis. The "Big Aristotle" was at the BIG3 playoffs Sunday to watch Howard's L.A. Riot play the Chicago Triplets. In the middle of describing to Rachel Nichols how he and Howard had made peace, O'Neal broke off his explanation to make fun of Howard for missing a dunk. The two Hall of Fame centers had sparred for years, despite their common ground as former members of the Orlando Magic and Los Angeles Lakers. Some of the tension seemed to be due to Howard adopting O'Neal's "Superman" nickname, though O'Neal claimed to Nichols that he was simply being tough on Howard to motivate him. That explanation doesn't account for the time O'Neal mocked Howard for playing basketball in the Taiwanese league or the decade-plus he's spent roasting Howard on his podcast, in public appearances and on "Inside the NBA." Still, it appears that the two have made peace. Despite O'Neal being left off the original list of presenters, he insisted that he'll be among a group of Hall of Famers inducting Howard Sept. 6, including Dominique Wilkins, Robert Parish, Dennis Rodman and Patrick Ewing. It means that two of the most dominant big men of their eras have finally buried the hatchet. It's added a new level of interest to the Hall of Fame ceremonies, and it should be a sweet moment between O'Neal and Howard. As long as Howard doesn't mention Superman.

Cardinals Writer Makes Controversial JJ Wetherholt Assessment
MLB

Cardinals Writer Makes Controversial JJ Wetherholt Assessment

The St. Louis Cardinals have seemingly waved the white flag on the season and the fan base is already preparing to riot for the call up and big league debut of top prospect JJ Wetherholt. Wetherholt is slashing .310/.403/.670 with nine home runs, a triple, and seven doubles in less than 30 games at the Triple-A level. Thomas Gauvain of Redbird Rants recently suggested that Wetherholt wasn't in the big leagues because he is blocked from receiving consistent playing time. Why hasn't JJ Wetherholt been called up yet? "Even with third baseman Nolan Arenado and second baseman Brendan Donovan on the IL, St. Louis Cardinals manager Oli Marmol is trying to squeeze in playing time for Masyn Winn, Nolan Gorman, and Thomas Saggese," Gauvain wrote. "Alec Burleson and Ivan Herrera are rotating between corner outfield duties and designated hitter appearances. There's not much time or space for Wetherholt on the major-league roster as things currently stand. "You don't promote a prospect of Wetherholt's caliber unless you intend on playing him every day. There's an argument that you make the roster work around JJ Wetherholt rather than the other way around, but the focus throughout the 2025 season in the majors has been to give young players full runway to prove their value or lack thereof. Bumping down Thomas Saggese, who is still only 23 and is 11 for his last 41, and Nolan Gorman, who has a .936 OPS over his last 11 games, for Wetherholt is a difficult argument to make." Every player listed who is supposedly blocking Wetherholt from receiving consistent playing time is under contract for next season, too. Would that mean the Cardinals would leave their top prospect in Triple-A next year? This doesn't make too much sense, as Wetherholt is the level of prospect that a team builds around. If he was the team's fifth or sixth ranked prospect, this argument would make sense. But he's the fifth or sixth ranked prospect in all of baseball. The star infielder has proved he can dominate at Triple-A. It's time for the Cardinals to bring him up to the big leagues to see what he can do. The rest of the roster can form around him.