Yardbarker
Yardbarker
x
Is Auston Matthews having the best season by any Toronto Maple Leaf, ever?
Auston Matthews for FanDuel promo and DraftKings promo 4.17 Auston Matthews (? John E. Sokolowski-USA TODAY Sports)

William Nylander shrugged, flashing his usual “What do you want from me?” smile.

“He’s the best goal scorer in league. I don’t know what else to tell you.”

Yes, we know. And we know that you know, William. But even by Auston Matthews’ standard…he’s finding new ways to top himself seemingly every night this season.

Matthews pacing the league in goals is obviously nothing new. Barring an injury or a late charge from the Florida Panthers’ Sam Reinhart, Matthews will run away with his third Rocket Richard Trophy in the last four seasons. But even for him…it feels like he’s somehow found a way to level up.

In the second period of the Leafs’ 4-3 overtime win over the Philadelphia Flyers Thursday night: bang, bang, bang. Matthews buried a natural hat trick in *checks notes* 7:49, the first and third on his patented laser wrister, the second on a bad-angle one timer.

“They’re a really stingy team, they play really hard both sides of the puck…so it’s just sticking with it, staying patient, trying to work them shift after shift, eventually getting those opportunities and capitalizing on them,” Matthews said.

Not only did it give him 45 goals in 51 games, it gave him five hat tricks on the year. For perspective: off-season signing Max Domi has five goals. Tyler Bertuzzi has six. Matthews has departed Planet Earth.

“We know by now he’s an exceptional player,” said Leafs coach Sheldon Keefe. “The year he got 60, that tear he was on towards the end of the season, it seems like he’s been on that all season to this point. So it’s exceptional. There’s not much else to say. Game changing tonight.”

Still stating the obvious? Maybe. Matthews is pretty clearly the greatest raw talent in team history. After longtime teammate Mitch Marner assisted on two of Matthews’ goals Thursday, the duo set a franchise record for the most goals involving two teammates with 211. They are 26 years old.

But is Matthews outdoing every other individual Leaf performance, ever, including his own previous bests, this season? Is he in the midst of the greatest single season performance in the franchise’s 106-year history?

The Leafs haven’t played in a Stanley Cup Final, let alone won the Cup, since 1967, of course, but they still have plenty of noteworthy individual campaigns on the books. Charlie Conacher led the NHL in goals five times in a six-year span between 1930-31 and 1935-36. In 1970-71, at 41 years old, Jacques Plante set an NHL single-season record with a .944 save percentage. Darryl Sittler’s 1975-76 season included an NHL record 10 points in one game, and he delivered a 111-point effort two seasons later. Doug Gilmour compiled a franchise-record 127 points and won the Selke Trophy in 1992-93. Many consider that season the best wire to wire by any Leaf, especially when they came within one win of reaching the Stanley Cup Final. And of course, Matthews is up against himself. When he buried 60 goals in 73 games in 2021-22, he became the first Leaf to win the Hart Trophy in 67 years.

This year: He’s currently tracking for 72 goals. No player has hit that mark since Teemu Selanne and Alexander Mogilny buried 76 apiece in 1992-93. They were the sixth and seventh players to join the 70-goal club, which also includes Phil Esposito, Wayne Gretzky, Jari Kurri, Bernie Nicholls and Brett Hull. By virtue of being becoming the eighth, Matthews would lay claim to the greatest Leaf season. He’d also be hitting the mark in a lower-scoring NHL season than any other 70-goal scorer played in.

The eye-popping numbers stand out, but it’s the context that makes Matthews’ season really special. When he scored 60 two seasons ago, he did so on a stacked team that set franchise records in wins with 54 and points with 115. They had six 20-goal scorers and 12 players reaching double figures in goals. They iced one of the NHL’s best defensive teams on top of ranking near the top of the league in most offensive categories.

This year? It’s no secret the Leafs have been an adventure defensively, grading out as one of the leakiest 5-on-5 teams in the league. Their scoring depth has evaporated. Matthews, Marner, William Nylander and John Tavares have accounted for a staggering 60.6 percent of Toronto’s goals. In the Leafs’ past 30 games? Matthews alone has scored 31 times. Nylander, Marner and Tavares have combined for 36 over that span. Every other Leaf: 43. Matthews’ effort Thursday was a microcosm of the season. He carried his flawed team to victory.

Nathan MacKinnon has been the most dominant player in the league for most of this season. Nikita Kucherov will be the first to hit 100 points. Connor McDavid is still pretty clearly the greatest hockey talent of the past three decades. But Matthews’ 2023-24 Hart Trophy case gets stronger by the day. Where would this team be without him? That question feels scarier than it has any other time in his eight NHL seasons.

The story isn’t written yet. A lot can change over the Leafs’ final 30 games. But what Matthews is doing in 2023-24 has never been done in a Maple Leafs sweater – not even by him.

This article first appeared on Daily Faceoff and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads:

Customize Your Newsletter

Yardbarker +

Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!

TODAY'S BEST

NHL players who will send their GM a 'thank you' card next summer
NHL

NHL players who will send their GM a 'thank you' card next summer

While it's possible a few moves will still occur in NHL free agency, most of the major wheeling and dealing is on pause. Here's a look at five players who will benefit the most this season from moves made by their general managers: New York Rangers right defenseman Adam Fox Fox was one of the top-producing defenseman in the league last season despite a revolving door of defensive partners next to him at five-on-five. To aid him, the Rangers signed Vladislav Gavrikov (seven years, $49M) with apparent goal of giving Fox the best defensive partner of his career. Gavrikov (6-foot-3, 220 pounds) was one of the best defensive defenseman in the league last season on the best regular-season defensive team (Los Angeles). If paired with Gavrikov, Fox could get increased minutes if the former King takes the toughest matchups. If split up, Fox will get the luxury of being matched against inferior opponents while Gavrikov takes the hardest minutes. Either way, that's a win for the former Norris Trophy winner. Carolina's wingers We're cheating a little bit here but with good reason. It's not really exactly where Carolina's new high-priced winger Nikolaj Ehlers (six years, $8.5 million AAV) will play — Carolina is likely to play him more often at five-on-five than he played in Winnipeg, where he was ninth in time-on-ice per game last season among forwards. Ehlers is an elite puck transporter who helped the Jets outscore opponents 100-55 at five-on-five the past two seasons, so at least one of Andrei Svechnikov, Seth Jarvis or Logan Stankoven will benefit from him. Montreal Canadiens right defenseman Lane Hutson Hutson (5-foot-9 and 162 pounds) will always have doubters because of his size. But some players transcend size, as Hutson did in an outstanding 60-assist rookie season in 2024-25. The Canadiens know that, in the right role, Hutson can do serious damage in creating offense at five-on-five and on the power play. Acquiring Noah Dobson, a 6-foot-4 right-handed-shot defenseman, will allow the Habs to keep Hutson in the ideal role. Dobson, playing a full season under HC Patrick Roy for the New York Islanders, put up his best career defensive metrics in high-danger chances against per 60 minutes (9.66) and expected goals against (2.29) in 70 or more games, according to Natural Stat Trick. Vegas Golden Knights Mark Stone Winger Mitch Marner's arrival could potentially give Stone a chance to take fewer shifts, play more games and be healthier come playoff time, when the Knights need his brand of two-way hockey to make up for Marner's history of playoff troubles. Stone, who has battled back problems for years, is 33 and on the back-nine of his career. The arrival of Marner has the potential to stretch out the effectiveness of the latter stages of his career. St. Louis Blues center Robert Thomas Thomas has quietly become one of the more effective No. 1 centers in the league. His back-to-back 80-plus-point seasons are driven primarily by his speed and skill as a setup man. In free agency, St. Louis added centers Pius Suter and Nick Bjugstad. Bjugstad should be able to take harder matchups at five-on-five. Suter, meanwhile, proved to be an effective penalty killer in Vancouver last season. That should allow Thomas to spend fewer minutes on the penalty kill, where he had the worst expected goals against per 60 rate (10.84, per Natural Stat Trick) of any Blues penalty killer to play at least 20 minutes on the PK last season.

Team Sinner or Team Alcaraz? Iga Swiatek makes her pick, describing preferred player as 'inspirational'
Tennis

Team Sinner or Team Alcaraz? Iga Swiatek makes her pick, describing preferred player as 'inspirational'

Jannik Sinner and Carlos Alcaraz are the two best players currently on the ATP Tour, with either man having won every Grand Slam this season. With their fan base divided, Polish WTA star Iga Swiatek has chimed in on the debate. Both men have established a professional rivalry that will likely go down in tennis history, with Alcaraz currently leading 8-5 in career meetings. The Spaniard defeated Sinner in the final to win the Roland Garros title earlier this year. However, Sinner avenged his loss a few weeks later, dethroning Alcaraz after defeating the defending champion in the final to win his first Wimbledon title. Swiatek joined Sinner in the winner's circle at SW19, as the former World No.1 powered through the field to win her maiden Wimbledon title. Swiatek dropped only one set en route to the final, where she soundly defeated American Amanda Anisimova in the final. Although Sinner sits on top of the ATP rankings after having won two Grand Slam titles this season, Swiatek admitted to employing the same approach as Alcaraz. The WTA star stated she preferred his more laid-back approach, in addition to his commitment to taking some personal time away from tennis. Alcaraz's approach suits her better, says Swiatek "I wish I was more like Carlos because I have got to say he is a big inspiration in terms of that,” said Swiatek in an interview with TVA Sports. “He always says that the most important thing for him on a tennis court is to enjoy it and have fun and I sometimes forget about that. “And sometimes with all the pressure around and things we need to do off the court, you need to remind yourself about this kid that started playing tennis, instead of winning for somebody and having this baggage on your shoulders. “For sure, when Carlos shows that and when he speaks about that, it is always a good reminder for me, and I try to do that as well, but without me working on it, I think my mind would automatically go to just working, working, working." The Warsaw native is competing at the 2025 Canadian Open in Montreal, where she is the second seed. Swiatek will kick off her campaign with a second round clash against China's Guo Hanyu on Wednesday.

Chicago Cubs OF suffers big injury before trade deadline
MLB

Chicago Cubs OF suffers big injury before trade deadline

The Chicago Cubs are down another bat with two days to go before the trade deadline on Thursday. The Cubs had more frustrating injury news to reveal after a second-straight loss to the Milwaukee Brewers on Tuesday night. The Brewers defeated Chicago 9-3 in front of 40,136 fans at American Family Field to take a two-game lead over the Cubs for first place in the NL Central. Per Jesse Rogers of ESPN, the Cubs thought they received good news on Ian Happ after x-rays came back negative on the outfielder’s shin. “Happ got x-rays that were negative after fouling a ball off his left shin,” Rogers posted on X. “Was limping some just now in the Cubs room. Jackson Chourio (hammy spasm) says he’s feeling better. Doesn’t think it’s serious.” Chicago Cubs to put Ian Happ on IL About an hour later, Rogers reported that Chicago is expected to put Happ on the injured list. The Cubs are set to call up Moises Ballesteros from Iowa. “Looks like the Happ injury might require an IL stint,” Rogers posted. “The team is calling up Moises Ballesteros from Triple-A, per a source. He’s hitting .331 down there. He had a cup of coffee with the big league team earlier this year.” Happ’s injury comes at a time when the Cubs are looking to trade for an extra bat. Chicago needs help on offense with inconsistency coming from rookie third baseman Matt Shaw. Happ was batting .227 with 14 home runs and 50 RBI. Bottom line, the Cubs need to make some moves by Thursday if this team wants to compete for the NL Central, much less a World Series.

Yankees’ Max Fried Makes Feelings Clear Before Trade Deadline
MLB

Yankees’ Max Fried Makes Feelings Clear Before Trade Deadline

The New York Yankees acquired several talented veterans after superstar outfielder Juan Soto walked in free agency this past offseason, with southpaw pitcher Max Fried (12-4, 2.62 ERA) chief among them. They signed the latter player to an eight-year, $218 million contract, and he's given them their money's worth thus far. Fried leads New York's pitching staff in wins and ERA. The 31-year-old is also tied for third in baseball in wins, is 11th in ERA, and is 11th with a 1.03 WHIP. Still, the Yankees could use pitching help, given that ace Gerrit Cole is out for the year after getting Tommy John surgery, and 2024 AL Rookie of the Year Luis Gil will make his first start of the season on Sunday. Fried was asked after Tuesday's bout with the Tampa Bay Rays if he's anxious to see what New York does ahead of Thursday's Trade Deadline, via SNY. "You've just got to take care of business every day," he said. "That's not something that we can control...We have baseball games to win." The Yankees did just that on Tuesday, beating the Rays 7-5 in a comeback effort. Fried earned his 12th win after allowing four runs (two earned) in 6.2 innings to go with nine strikeouts and two walks. The veteran also tossed a career-high 111 pitches. Over the last few days, the Yankees acquired third baseman Ryan McMahon from the Colorado Rockies and fellow third baseman Amed Rosario from the Washington Nationals. They also traded pitcher Carlos Carrasco to the Atlanta Braves for a player to be named later or cash. New York will face Tampa Bay again on Wednesday and Thursday.