Keefe benches dependable defender for right-handed shot

As the Toronto Maple Leafs maintain cruise control holding a playoff spot, head coach Sheldon Keefe has made a puzzling decision. Given the plethora of depth on the blue line, he’s chosen to bench one of his better defencemen.

Benoit’s Benching

Toronto Maple Leafs defenceman Simon Benoit has been benched for the past two games. After signing a one-year deal in August, he’s likely to be a healthy scratch again on Sunday against the Carolina Hurricanes. This decision has left fans frustrated, particularly given his reputation for adding a physical edge—a quality seemingly absent in his counterparts, T.J. Brodie and Timothy Liljegren.

Healthy Scratch Raises Questions

Benoit’s style of play has endeared him to Maple Leafs fans for its simplicity and effectiveness. Unlike Brodie and Liljegren, Benoit is known for his ability to handle opposing players with physicality. This makes him stand out, giving the Maple Leafs a strong presence near the boards and in front of the net.

Before, Benoit and Jake McCabe formed a tough defensive pair, which played a big role in the Leafs six-game win streak in February. Their partnership exemplified the kind of hard-nosed defensive play crucial in high-stakes matchups.

Physicality vs. Development

Maple Leafs coach Sheldon Keefe‘s decision to scratch Benoit raises eyebrows. While strengthening the blue line is a priority, particularly after struggles with an all-lefty defense, Liljegren’s inclusion sparks debate. Does his right-handed shot outweigh Benoit’s physicality, a quality seemingly lacking in the current lineup? Despite the coaching staff prioritizing Liljegren’s development, Benoit’s absence implies that Keefe prioritizes the righty defensive shot above all else.

This move by Keefe casts doubt about the team’s commitment to defense, especially considering the playoffs loom and a more than likely first-round matchup with the Boston Bruins. The Leafs' history with the Bruins is a brutal one. These games almost always erupt into physical battles, the kind where tensions boil over and fists fly. It’s exactly the situation where the Leafs have faltered in the past. Benoit’s physical presence would be a huge asset – someone who can stand his ground and answer the bell when the Bruins come calling.

Prioritizing Right-Handed Shots or Defensive Reliability

With Keefe opting for Brodie and Liljegren, questions arise about whether the coaching staff prioritizes right-handed defencemen over a player known for his defensive reliability, even if it sacrifices some offensive potential. Liljegren’s ability to weather the Bruins’ storm is now a question mark, given his struggles against them recently.

While Benoit’s physicality is undoubtedly an asset, it’s worth noting that Brodie and Liljegren bring a veteran presence and strong positional play to the blue line, which can be invaluable, especially in high-pressure situations. However, it’s important to consider Benoit’s recent growth, particularly since the All-Star break. While he may not contribute much to the scoresheet, his development indicates a willingness to improve. On the other hand, there’s a question of complacency with his counterparts. If Benoit can evolve his game, why haven’t Brodie and Liljegren shown similar growth? Are they becoming too comfortable in their roles?

Edmundson Offers Lineup Flexibility

Newcomer Joel Edmundson, acquired before the deadline from the Washington Capitals, has strengthened the Maple Leafs defence. While he usually plays on the left side, Edmundson stated that he is open to switching to the right if necessary. This means there’s a chance of reshuffling the defensive pairs, like teaming Edmundson with Brodie and reuniting McCabe with Benoit, offering another option for the team.

Awaiting His Return

As the Maple Leafs progress through the season, attention will remain on Benoit’s being benched and its impact on the team’s defensive performance. Whether his exclusion is temporary, or part of a larger strategy remains uncertain. For now, Benoit’s supporters eagerly await his return to the lineup, hoping that his physicality and defensive grit will once again fortify the Maple Leafs’ blue line.