The Toronto Maple Leafs losing skid, coupled with injuries to Morgan Rielly and Chris Tanev’s carefully managed workload, is putting added pressure on Chayka to make a move. A draft pick projected to land 22nd overall still carries considerable trade value.
Waiting for a marginally better return could cost the Maple Leafs valuable ground in the playoff race. Toronto is not scheduled to own another first-round pick until 2029. Following the 2027 draft, how the organization handles this asset could prove pivotal to its long-term competitive window.
According to NHL insiders Elliotte Friedman and Pierre LeBrun, the Maple Leafs are willing to part with Colorado’s first-round pick. Likely to acquire a difference-making defenseman.
Chayka faces a tough decision: address Toronto’s defensive struggles now or wait for Colorado to stumble and potentially increase the value of the draft pick. Waiting could bring a better return, but delaying too long risks further damaging the Leafs’ playoff hopes.
The Maple Leafs have already surrendered their own first-round selections in both the 2027 and 2028 NHL Drafts. Those picks now belong to the Boston Bruins and Philadelphia Flyers, respectively, as a result of previous trades. That leaves Toronto with just one first-round asset it controls over the next two drafts.
With valuable draft capital already limited, that pick becomes an especially important bargaining chip as GM John Chayka explores ways to improve his roster. Whether the Maple Leafs are looking to address an immediate weakness, add an impact player, or make a significant move before the trade deadline, the Colorado pick could be central to any major transaction.
Simply put, Toronto has very little first-round flexibility remaining, making the decision to part with its final available pick one that would carry considerable long-term implications.
Without that draft capital, Toronto’s options to pursue impact players or explore offer-sheet opportunities are significantly restricted. With limited assets to work with, GM John Chayka must be strategic about when and how he uses them.
Nathan MacKinnon and Cale Makar’s injuries against Ottawa in mid-November have cast uncertainty over Colorado’s ability to sustain its impressive start. The Maple Leafs, meanwhile, have added incentive to watch closely, as they own the Avalanche’s 2027 first-round pick, top-10 protected, acquired in the Nicolas Roy trade.
If the Avalanche slide in the standings while those players are sidelined, the pick could move into the mid-teens instead of the late-20s, making it a more attractive trade asset or draft selection. A top-10 finish remains unlikely, but even a modest drop in the standings could significantly boost its value.
Matt Larkin from the Daily Faceoff sees the Maple Leafs targeting Alexander Nikishin. The Colorado pick would most certainly be included in any trade offer.
“More realistically, I would look at Alexander Nikishin to the Toronto Maple Leafs,” said Larkin. “We know he has a really high ceiling, and he could become a do-it-all defenseman if he finds a coach who trusts him and gives him more minutes and a bigger role. He was a star in the KHL, has high offensive upside, and is physical. I think he’s a do-it-all defenseman. If he gets a chance to grow, we know the Leafs need that type of player to build around.”
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!