Nick Turchiaro-USA TODAY Sports

Maple Leafs’ Goalie Situation Sparks Controversy and Questions

Originally posted on NHL Trade Talk | Last updated 10/23/23

In just five games into the season, the Toronto Maple Leafs find themselves in the midst of a goaltending debate. Ilya Samsonov, who was expected to be the team’s starter, has struggled significantly, posting a disappointing .831 save percentage and allowing 14 goals in his first four games. His latest performance, where he let in three goals on the first four shots faced, led Maple Leafs head coach Sheldon Keefe to make a decisive move.

Keefe pulled Samsonov in favor of rookie netminder Joseph Woll, who has shown impressive prowess in his limited appearances. Woll boasts a stellar .949 save percentage, notably stepping up in a recent game against Tampa Bay. Woll stopped all 29 shots he faced, securing a win for the team and catching the attention of his coach.

Following the game, Keefe praised Woll’s dedication and performance, confirming that Woll would be starting in the upcoming game against the Washington Capitals. When asked if Woll’s strong play might result in more starts, Keefe acknowledged that the rookie goaltender was indeed pushing for more opportunities. Keefe emphasized Woll’s work ethic, highlighting how his hunger and preparation, even when not initially slated to play, demonstrated his readiness.

Keefe noted of Samsonov: “You can’t let in three goals on four shots. That’s it.” When asked about Woll, he responded, “He’s pushing.” Keefe added:

“We’ll keep building and stacking up good days. I think that kind of sent a message to the group that he’s hungry and because of that work, he was ready for tonight even though he wasn’t supposed to play. That’s a really great sign for a young player and I’m really happy for him.”

What’s Next for the Maple Leafs?

As the Maple Leafs navigate this early-season goaltending challenge, all eyes will be on Joseph Woll as he looks to solidify his role in the team and potentially reshape the goaltending dynamics for Toronto. The internal competition in net for Toronto is not a bad thing. Woll is pushing Samsonov and it will be up for Samsonov to respond.

The issue in Toronto becomes what happens if he doesn’t. If it’s left only up to Woll because Samsonov is not performing, a trade to find another backup might make sense. At the very least, Samsonov’s one-year extension will turn into a one-and-done.

This article first appeared on NHL Trade Talk and was syndicated with permission.

More must-reads: